Candidates for top four:
Burroughs- seven world level golds (including one Olympic gold), ten total medals (wrestled across rule changes, during the six weight classes era, had to fend off DT and Dake at home)
Smith- six world level golds (including two Olympic golds)
Snyder- six world level golds (including one Olympic gold), 11 total medals
Bruce- five world level golds (including two Olympic golds), 13 total medals
Dake- five world golds, eight total medals
DT- four world level golds (including one Olympic gold), six total medals
Kemp- three world golds (US boycotted 1980 Olympics), four total medals
Gable- two world level golds (including one Olympic gold)
Menhert- two Olympic golds