Not to pick on Rutgers, but couldn't the same critique be made about every sport Rutgers competes in??
For whatever reason, they aren't a power player in anything. Goodale might run the most successful program in the entire athletic department? Football, Basketball, Baseball all would love to have a top ten finish in the NCAAs, be middle of the pack of the most dominate conference and be known as one of the better home environments in the nation.