Wrestlestat ratings, brotha - not rankings. It goes off all the results, not just the last tournament (which should probably be factored in, I agree). Also, Kasak destroyed Taylor twice last season. Destroyed. Whereas Taylor lost to Blaze, Kasak, Kasak, and Askey.
Again: Ratings, not rankings, determined by a formula taking all results in to account.
Sinclair is currently 'ranked' at 197 on Wrestlestat, that is why he isn't there.
Also add in that he had two Major Decision losses (Plott, #5@184 and Buchanan, #1@197lbs) and two regular decision losses (Volker, 12@197 and Smith, #23@197), and his rating is only good for 1517.39 on Wrestlestat's Elo system. That is good enough for #8 at 197lbs and #9 at 184lbs.
In media rankings wrestlers will get a pass on some losses, especially as the season progresses. That doesn't happen with wrestlestat's ratings system. Unfortunately, a loss to Smith in November is just as damning as a loss to Smith in February.
As far as McEnelly? He had a lot of close wins. Those don't help when using a computer program that factors in margin of victory (a 4-1 OT victory of Bullock, for example).
Ferrari's close matches were to Plott (victory) and Starocci.