Here is the data on the 75%ers.
My point in focusing on the 100%ers is that I am a glass half full kinda guy. That is my choice. Reasonable people can make different choices.
Think of it as they are innocent of loses until they are proven guilty. They never lost at the NCAA tournament. Some can look at that as they might have lost with one more chance at the front end, some may not.
The reality is that in a different era 22 of 30 75%ers did take the lose in their freshman year. But it was a different era. When did injury years become a thing? I see three guys on there who lost a year to injury (Lange, Young, and Johnson).
Draw any conclusions you like, but for me I like to view the category as undefeated at the NCAA tournament, just as some view overall undefeated as a category. Sanderson was undefeated for 159, Uetake for 58, McCready for 25. Where do you draw the line? 158? 100? I don't know.