D1 P4P Top Five (Nov. 2023)

[peanut]

1. Starocci
2. Brooks
3. Vito
4. KOT
5. Carr

[Hammerlock3]

whose kot?

brooks is better than starocci, he just just gave up a stupid reversal to ISU. 

[Hammerlock3]

keagan otoole got it

[Ohio Elite]

I wouldn't argue with KOT at #1

[Konquest]

1. Brooks

2. O'Toole

3. Starocci

4. Vito (was #1)

5. Carr (Keckeisen or Fix could move into this spot)

[nhs67]

I think it's...

1 - Steveson
2 - Stalrocci
3 - Brooks
4 - O'Toole
5 - Carr

[Jimmy Cinnabon]

Can Vito still be in the top 5 after losing to a freshman who isn't even the starter on his own team?

[ionel]

How can it not be Crookham at this point.  Steveson hasn't even wrestled a match.

[Wrestleknownothing]

1 hour ago, nhs67 said:

I think it's...

1 - Steveson
2 - Stalrocci
3 - Brooks
4 - O'Toole
5 - Carr

I checked every college roster and I could not find a Steveson.

But then I wandered down to the Largo Events Center, past the bingo set up to where they had cranked the basketball nets up and out of the way....and THAT is where I found a Steveson. Not sure if that is the same guy. This guy had a hollow-eyed, lost look of regret.

[Husker_Du]

I'll take a stab at it

1. Starocci - 3 titles. hasn't lost since Feb '21

2. Brooks - 3 titles, 3 career losses

3. KOT - 2 titles, 3 career losses 2 of them to Carr, who he has the last HTH over

4. Carr - Placings of 2, 3, 1 - only 3 career losses (KOT, Deakin and Hunter Willits), has win over #3

5. Keckeisen - 2, 3, 3 - six career losses, three of them to Brooks (Bernie, Hidlay (who he also beat) + plus Abe Assad)

I'd probably go Real + Hidlay next

 

[ionel]

Pretty sure to be a P4P you need to have weighed in so we know how many pounds and have at least 1 win.  

[ionel]

1 hour ago, Wrestleknownothing said:

I checked every college roster and I could not find a Steveson.

.

Maybe try "Stevenson."  

[Ohio Elite]

9 minutes ago, ionel said:

Maybe try "Stevenson."  

Who?

[ionel]

25 minutes ago, Ohio Elite said:

Who?

The kid who was gonna be the next great hwt out of hs, prob better than Bruce B.  

Edited November 17, 2023 by ionel

[flyingcement]

1. O'Toole

2. Vito

3. Brooks

4. Starocci

5. Fix

[ionel]

3 minutes ago, flyingcement said:

1. O'Toole

2. Vito

3. Brooks

4. Starocci

5. Fix

What's Vito's record?

[flyingcement]

2 minutes ago, ionel said:

What's Vito's record?

[CHROMEBIRD]

P4P based on what? Only the current season? All-time college record? Including freestyle? Including pre-college wrestling? SOS? Total # of bonus points? Let us know what you are thinking, man.

[flyingcement]

I interpreted it as - who is the best right now - given the entirety of their track record.  

[mspart]

Spencer Lee has now set the precedent of not getting the 4th national title.    Will Stalrocci or Brooks follow in his footsteps?

mspart

[ionel]

https://intermatwrestle.com/forums/topic/2124-smokers-meat/page/23/#comments

 

[peanut]

3 hours ago, CHROMEBIRD said:

P4P based on what? Only the current season? All-time college record? Including freestyle? Including pre-college wrestling? SOS? Total # of bonus points? Let us know what you are thinking, man.

Based on vibes. But here are some of the accolades I had in mind:

• Starocci- 3x champ, two undefeated seasons
• Brooks- 3x champ, U23 world champ, one undefeated season
• Vito- 1x champ, world champ (only the 4th athlete to win world/Olympic gold before senior year)
• KOT- 2x champ, U23 world champ, one undefeated season
• Carr- 1x champ, U20 world champ, 2-1 vs. KOT, one undefeated season

Edited November 18, 2023 by peanut

[peanut]

7 hours ago, Jimmy Cinnabon said:

Can Vito still be in the top 5 after losing to a freshman who isn't even the starter on his own team?

Yes.

[Lipdrag]

21 hours ago, CHROMEBIRD said:

P4P based on what? Only the current season? All-time college record? Including freestyle? Including pre-college wrestling? SOS? Total # of bonus points? Let us know what you are thinking, man.

Make your list and tell us what you are thinking.  Don't over think it.