Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 55
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
1 hour ago, Gus said:

The stall call seemed to occur because Ryder took a shot. He took a shot when they were both out of bounds so why does the shot mean anything? 

Agreed. That was BS and a crappy way to end the match 

Posted
35 minutes ago, IceMan said:

It was a takedown for Arnold. Reaction time needs to be more defined. Way too many examples of inconsistencies with the current rules book. It currently states reaction time is "The amount of time a wrestler is provided by the referee to react to individual scoring or wrestling situations... Reaction time is determined by each individual referee and is described only as a period of time that is not instantaneous." 

The reality with Arnold vs. Ryder's match is, you plug another referee in and the match is scored differently here with the same sequence. Same goes for several matches throughout the season. Needs to be defined better or we need a better review process. 

What section of the rule book is that in?

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, forkemaz said:

What section of the rule book is that in?

Rule 2, Section 2, Article 12

Edited by BaldAt23
Posted
5 hours ago, Greenwave said:

Could have gone either way every time that scenario comes up.   But when you leave it to the refs who made the call on the mat to review their own call it’s very unlikely for them to change.

 

 The real issue is this has happened to Arnold several times on last second attempts.  Why can TnT not get the kid to pull the shot attempts sooner.

I agree, no doubt that if he opens up, and has more courage, he wins a majority of these close matches, would be really cool to see. 

Posted
1 minute ago, BaldAt23 said:

Rule 2, Section 2, Article 12

Yeah i went back and found it but i appreciate the prompt answer. Im still looking for a good definition of control and a takedown 

Posted
2 hours ago, Nak21 said:

I thought it was a takedown. And what a major let down, Gabe shoots the first time in his wrestling career and is rewarded with that? Great. He’s never doing that again…

Seriously though, he got screwed, twice. Didn’t even get dinner or any drinks first.

Technically he didn't shoot, it was a throw-by

Posted

It seems its just that breif definition of a takedown, the description of reaction time and the section with 5 pictures that define a take down with reaction time. But its a big rule book and im still snooping around.

Posted (edited)
11 hours ago, Hammerlock3 said:

Arnold, who i like as little as any ncaa wrestler, was treated as badly by the refs in that match as any wrestler since Ryan churella. 

So was the 106 or 113 pounder in the Iowa high school state finals. He faced up the wrestler and was stretched out in a tie up and I guess the ref decided to call that he was involved in an attempted reversal sequence and wouldn’t give him the escape and send it to overtime.  Kid gave up one point in the match at 2 seconds remaining of period 2 and was denied his own escape at 10 seconds of period 3. Kid was still crying when they gave him his silver medal 15 minutes later. 

Edited by jmoney
Posted
11 hours ago, Hammerlock3 said:

Arnold, who i like as little as any ncaa wrestler, was treated as badly by the refs in that match as any wrestler since Ryan churella. 

Ian Miller would like a word...

Takedown in regulation for sure. 

With regard to the OT stalling, I thought the ref was calling Arnold on the kickout that took him OB.  That has been stalling, it replaced the old fleeing the mat rule.   Yes, it sucks to end a match like that but that was a better call than the the missed TD that was reviewed.   In real time, I didn't think Ryder's OB shot had anything to do with the stalling call.  

Also, 2nd time a Hawkeye has lost an OT match by giving up a stall call.  Crazy.  

Posted
2 hours ago, Dogbone said:

Ian Miller would like a word...

Takedown in regulation for sure. 

With regard to the OT stalling, I thought the ref was calling Arnold on the kickout that took him OB.  That has been stalling, it replaced the old fleeing the mat rule.   Yes, it sucks to end a match like that but that was a better call than the the missed TD that was reviewed.   In real time, I didn't think Ryder's OB shot had anything to do with the stalling call.  

Also, 2nd time a Hawkeye has lost an OT match by giving up a stall call.  Crazy.  

Regarding the second stall call on Arnold, this is what the 2025-26 and 2026-27 NCAA Men's Wrestling Casebook says regarding when to call stalling in a kickout situation at the OOB line:

"A.R. 5-17. Is it a mandatory stall call when a wrestler kicks out from a lower leg hold? RULING: No. A wrestler who stays in bounds while kicking out of a lower leg hold in either the neutral or down position, should not be called for stalling unless the referee believes Rule 5.7.1 (avoiding wrestling as an offensive or defensive strategy) applies. If, however, a kick out by a wrestler results in an out of bounds call being made by the referee, then the wrestler kicking out shall be called for stalling (Rule 5.7.8)" (emphasis mine)

My question is if Arnold's kickout actually pulled Ryder out of bounds? Unfortunately the footage angle doesn't show Ryder's foot that is nearest the OOB line. My assumption would be that if Arnold's kickout pulled Ryder out of bounds then a stalling call would be warranted, but if Ryder stepped out of bounds on his own then no stall call would be warranted. 

And for those who are not aware what the NCAA Wrestling Casebook is, it gives various and numerous (42 pages) examples of wrestling and officiating scenarios, and how to properly handle them. It is an excellent resource for referees, wrestling officials and us wrestling fans who enjoy learning the intricacies of wrestling officiating. Here is the link: https://ncaaorg.s3.amazonaws.com/championships/sports/wrestling/rules/mens/2025-27PRMWR_CaseBook.pdf

Edit: P.S., Also, in slow motion, it can be seen that Ryder momentarily and just barely goes out of bounds in that sequence. That would have been an interesting challenge had Iowa made it.

Posted
2 hours ago, Dogbone said:

Ian Miller would like a word...

That was more of a table worker/NCAA thing than a ref thing from what I remember.

"Half measures are a coward's form of insanity."

Posted

Many Iowa guys wrestle out of fear (of being taken taken down, of failure, of losing, of being chastised by the two bulldogs, T & T).   

Most Penn State guys wrestle out of freedom (of scoring points, of opening up action, of getting into scramble positions, of enjoying the opportunities, of being encouraged by Sanderson).

There is a difference in culture, coaching, and team approaches .... that makes a difference.     

Posted

From my perspective as an official, I don't see the control on the mat.  I'm sure you can find a screen shot with his hands on the mat and Arnold with a hold, but that's an instant and cannot be used to determine "beyond reaction time."

The rule quoted above refers to "beyond reaction time" which leaves a lot to be determined, but I figure, if Joey Blaze didn't get the take down last week (he had it a lot longer), then this is not a TD either.

 

Posted
35 minutes ago, Pablo said:

From my perspective as an official, I don't see the control on the mat.  I'm sure you can find a screen shot with his hands on the mat and Arnold with a hold, but that's an instant and cannot be used to determine "beyond reaction time."

The rule quoted above refers to "beyond reaction time" which leaves a lot to be determined, but I figure, if Joey Blaze didn't get the take down last week (he had it a lot longer), then this is not a TD either.

 

Thanks for providing your opinion as an official.    While I know beyond reaction time is subjective, doesn't the actual reactions need to matter?   For Example, Ryder's initial reaction after he is shucked to his knees and Arnold behind is arms is to circle on his knees (his hands reposition on the mat a few times and his body turns about 90 degrees) and then he comes up and reaches back.    It all happens within a second (so objectively a short period of time) but in my subjective opinion this should be a TD because Ryder has 2 separate reactions and it is the 2nd one (standing and reaching back) and not his first "reaction"  that gets him out of the TD. 

 

Posted

I just watched it.   He looked like he had control but the guy got up right away.   He obviously did not have control.  If he had broken him down, he would have gotten the call.   But I'm not up on the going out of bounds call on this kind of thing.   The way I saw it, Arnold had a take down if they stopped the match right then.   But they didn't and he had no control.   

That's they way I saw it. 

mspart

Posted
2 hours ago, Psalm 1 guy said:

Regarding the second stall call on Arnold, this is what the 2025-26 and 2026-27 NCAA Men's Wrestling Casebook says regarding when to call stalling in a kickout situation at the OOB line:

"A.R. 5-17. Is it a mandatory stall call when a wrestler kicks out from a lower leg hold? RULING: No. A wrestler who stays in bounds while kicking out of a lower leg hold in either the neutral or down position, should not be called for stalling unless the referee believes Rule 5.7.1 (avoiding wrestling as an offensive or defensive strategy) applies. If, however, a kick out by a wrestler results in an out of bounds call being made by the referee, then the wrestler kicking out shall be called for stalling (Rule 5.7.8)" (emphasis mine)

My question is if Arnold's kickout actually pulled Ryder out of bounds? Unfortunately the footage angle doesn't show Ryder's foot that is nearest the OOB line. My assumption would be that if Arnold's kickout pulled Ryder out of bounds then a stalling call would be warranted, but if Ryder stepped out of bounds on his own then no stall call would be warranted. 

And for those who are not aware what the NCAA Wrestling Casebook is, it gives various and numerous (42 pages) examples of wrestling and officiating scenarios, and how to properly handle them. It is an excellent resource for referees, wrestling officials and us wrestling fans who enjoy learning the intricacies of wrestling officiating. Here is the link: https://ncaaorg.s3.amazonaws.com/championships/sports/wrestling/rules/mens/2025-27PRMWR_CaseBook.pdf

Edit: P.S., Also, in slow motion, it can be seen that Ryder momentarily and just barely goes out of bounds in that sequence. That would have been an interesting challenge had Iowa made it.

Thanks for providing.  I don't know if Arnold's kickout took Ryder OB but I am still okay with this being a stall call. 

That seems to have been a more consistent stall call this year. 

Most times the defending wrestling is using a whizzer to force the action toward the edge and then kicking out.   So whether it is a required stall call or subjective, it seems appropriate and consistent for that to be stalling, especially when compared to the reaction time TD that seems all over the board.  

Posted
3 minutes ago, mspart said:

I just watched it.   He looked like he had control but the guy got up right away.   He obviously did not have control.  If he had broken him down, he would have gotten the call.   But I'm not up on the going out of bounds call on this kind of thing.   The way I saw it, Arnold had a take down if they stopped the match right then.   But they didn't and he had no control.   

That's they way I saw it. 

mspart

While I understand it isn't the rule, I don't think the OB should be able to save a guy. 

The only reason Ryder's "reaction" was able to avoid the TD was because Arnold couldn't follow him without going OB so Arnold stays in same spot and tries to keep a foot in while Ryder turns and gets an angle to stand up.   If it wasn't for the OB, Arnold follows him around and Ryder can't reach back. 

I don't know if I like, he had control but the guy stood up so he didn't.  

Posted

For the stall call, I realize Burroughs is an OkC homer, but note that the announcers predicted it - they said, Arnold can't turn around here or he's going to get hit for stalling, and that is exactly what happened.  He turned away, he got hit.

I also expected it for the same reason.  I thought it was a pretty obvious call.

You can all be picking nits and saying how you don't like it, but, man, if it's so obvious that it can be predicted, you can't really say it's that bad of a call.

Posted
2 hours ago, Dogbone said:

Thanks for providing your opinion as an official.    While I know beyond reaction time is subjective, doesn't the actual reactions need to matter?   For Example, Ryder's initial reaction after he is shucked to his knees and Arnold behind is arms is to circle on his knees (his hands reposition on the mat a few times and his body turns about 90 degrees) and then he comes up and reaches back.    It all happens within a second (so objectively a short period of time) but in my subjective opinion this should be a TD because Ryder has 2 separate reactions and it is the 2nd one (standing and reaching back) and not his first "reaction"  that gets him out of the TD. 

 

To be fair, I'm not an NCAA official, and just do high school.

You all are focusing on the issue of reaction time, but when we (officials) talk about take downs, we are always talking about control.  Is control established?  And that means on the mat (which can be a tripod),** not standing.

It's crazy, but what constitutes control can even depend on whether control has been established.  Someone above brought up the HS tournament match where the wrestler was given a reversal as opposed to an escape + takedown.  I saw that and didn't have any problem with the call there, either.  The official clearly indicated that he still had green in control, despite the fact that he was only really holding an arm, but yeah, once control has been established, that can still count, although if they were on their feet, it would never be considered a takedown.  I think the biggest problem with that call was that the scorekeeper originally gave the wrestler an escape and takedown, so they had to go to the bench and correct the score.  The official was clear all along that it was a reversal.  Had the score been done correctly in the first place, it wouldn't have been nearly as controversial.

**I was working one night with a guy who is probably the best official in the state, and he got on me for that - he said, patience is good, and I did a good job of letting the action develop and didn't make the quick call, but control with the hands down is a takedown so go ahead and call it.  It was an awesome experience working with him.  The best part was, the things the coaches were bitching about, he was like, nah, you were great there, just work on this other stuff that they didn't talk about...

Posted
2 hours ago, Pablo said:

From my perspective as an official, I don't see the control on the mat.  I'm sure you can find a screen shot with his hands on the mat and Arnold with a hold, but that's an instant and cannot be used to determine "beyond reaction time."

The rule quoted above refers to "beyond reaction time" which leaves a lot to be determined, but I figure, if Joey Blaze didn't get the take down last week (he had it a lot longer), then this is not a TD either.

 

Honest question - do they provide officials with guidance on how long "reaction time" is allowed in these kind of sequences? Example: give the defending wrestler about 1/2 second to respond and if they are still controlled after that, award the takedown. 

Is there any guidance on how to interpret what reaction time is quantifiably? 

Posted (edited)
25 minutes ago, IceMan said:

Honest question - do they provide officials with guidance on how long "reaction time" is allowed in these kind of sequences? Example: give the defending wrestler about 1/2 second to respond and if they are still controlled after that, award the takedown. 

Is there any guidance on how to interpret what reaction time is quantifiably? 

Absolutely not, but I'll tell you one thing, that patience is a virtue.  The most common way to get into trouble as an official is to be too quick on a call.  I was having a problem with that on my fall calls - note that NCAA and freestyle falls just need both shoulders to contact the mat at the same time and boom.  But NFHS actually requires 2 seconds.  I was jumping the gun and calling it more like the NCAA version, but it got me into trouble for calling falls before they were established.  Better to slow down and confirm and double check both shoulders and let them wrestle than to jump the gun on a pin call (I make a lot more conscious effort now to do that).  

The same would be on a takedown - don't rush the call.  You are more likely to make the wrong call calling it too soon than too late.  It's not perfect - you can still miss some things that you maybe should have called, but slow down and make sure the action has played out and you are more likely to get it right.

My least favorite call is when I jump the gun on an escape that goes straight to a takedown.  Was it really an escape or just a reversal?  If I had just waited a second, I would have known better.

So how to interpret reaction time?  If it falls apart by the time I am ready to make the call, it didn't happen.  Of course, that depends on your timing, but I have a lot of patience.  Maybe too much at times.  Maybe "reaction time" refers to MY reaction time - do I have enough time to react to make the call?

Again, this is what we talk about in high school, and I don't speak for an NCAA official.  Although we do talk about watching them to see how they do things.,

Edited by Pablo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...