Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
22 minutes ago, fishbane said:

It useful to have leverage in a negotiation, but if you are going to have future dealings with that person/entity it is wise to use it with care.  Sure you might have them over a barrel and be able to get exactly what you want now, but if that is a really bad outcome for the other side then they will be angry, resentful, and more difficult to deal with in the future.

A classic example of this is the Treaty of Versailles to end WWI.  The central powers were defeated had no leverage with which to bargain as a result Germany was dealt significant territorial and financial losses in the deal.  Resentment over this in Germany is one of the things that lead to WWII.  The allied powers got their reparations, but also another war. 

At the time President Wilson felt the allied powers should be lenient with Germany.  The other day President Trump suggested the US had erred in giving Greenland back to their ally after WWII.  It's an absurd position.  The Kingdom of Denmark losing 98% of their land to an ally.  With friends like that who needs enemies?

Making threats to get what would be given willingly serves no purpose. Denmark and Greenland allow the US military access to the island.  Threatening to either take the island by force or to coerce them into giving it up through economic penalties is counter productive.  The US can achieve its security objectives without owning the island.

Oh no not angry and resentful.  Two years in they’d all realize they’re better off than they were. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

  • Replies 237
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
28 minutes ago, fishbane said:

It useful to have leverage in a negotiation, but if you are going to have future dealings with that person/entity it is wise to use it with care.  Sure you might have them over a barrel and be able to get exactly what you want now, but if that is a really bad outcome for the other side then they will be angry, resentful, and more difficult to deal with in the future.

A classic example of this is the Treaty of Versailles to end WWI.  The central powers were defeated had no leverage with which to bargain as a result Germany was dealt significant territorial and financial losses in the deal.  Resentment over this in Germany is one of the things that lead to WWII.  The allied powers got their reparations, but also another war. 

At the time President Wilson felt the allied powers should be lenient with Germany.  The other day President Trump suggested the US had erred in giving Greenland back to their ally after WWII.  It's an absurd position.  The Kingdom of Denmark losing 98% of their land to an ally.  With friends like that who needs enemies?

Making threats to get what would be given willingly serves no purpose. Denmark and Greenland allow the US military access to the island.  Threatening to either take the island by force or to coerce them into giving it up through economic penalties is counter productive.  The US can achieve its security objectives without owning the island.

Why did you stop the story there.  Did this anger and resentment lead to prosperity?  Or ruin?

Posted
58 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

It’s Greenland.  There’s 60,000 people there.   It will never be in a position of power against most any country let alone America.   It’s how it works.  

Which is why it's part of the Kingdom of Denmark and the Kingdom of Denmark is part of a strategic alliance with other states (NATO).

58 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Which it sounds like is exactly what Trump is working on.   

He could have done this without the threats to use force or tariffs and gotten the same result.

Posted
1 hour ago, Offthemat said:

Why did you stop the story there.  Did this anger and resentment lead to prosperity?  Or ruin?

I assumed you knew the history.  After the treaty of Versailles the Germans were resentful, which lead to the the Nazi party rising to power.  The Germans waged WWII to try and get back what they had lost and then some.  The destruction from the war far exceeded an reparations collected after WWI.  ultimately , the Germans were defeated and treated less harshly at the end of WWII.  Eighty years of peace between the major European powers followed.

Posted
1 hour ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Oh no not angry and resentful.  Two years in they’d all realize they’re better off than they were. 

If you don't understand why the other side would be resentful or unhappy with the outcome then you probably didn't really understand what was important to them in the first place.  I suspect it will take more than two years.  American colonists were angry and resentful over not having representation in the UK Parliament.  Today the US and UK are allies, but it took decades and a few wars to get there.

Posted
1 hour ago, fishbane said:

Which is why it's part of the Kingdom of Denmark and the Kingdom of Denmark is part of a strategic alliance with other states (NATO).

He could have done this without the threats to use force or tariffs and gotten the same result.

A.  So?
B.  Again it’s called leverage. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, fishbane said:

If you don't understand why the other side would be resentful or unhappy with the outcome then you probably didn't really understand what was important to them in the first place.  I suspect it will take more than two years.  American colonists were angry and resentful over not having representation in the UK Parliament.  Today the US and UK are allies, but it took decades and a few wars to get there.

Again, Greenland will realize very quickly they’re in a better spot. They’ll get over it much sooner than others 

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
1 hour ago, fishbane said:

If you don't understand why the other side would be resentful or unhappy with the outcome then you probably didn't really understand what was important to them in the first place.  I suspect it will take more than two years.  American colonists were angry and resentful over not having representation in the UK Parliament.  Today the US and UK are allies, but it took decades and a few wars to get there.

Japan was resentful too.  Probably still are.  They’re still a valued ally. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
3 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

A.  So?
B.  Again it’s called leverage. 

Leverage can be powerful tool to get you something you wouldn’t otherwise be able to obtain.  You shouldn’t waste it where it is not necessary.

Trump constantly threatening tariffs and scraping deals on a whim will just cause allies and partners look elsewhere to countries with more stable trade policies and international relations.  Canada just made a deal with China for reduced tariffs on EV imports more such deals will follow if these trade games continue. 

Trump should use these tactics on countries that charge high tariffs on US imports, carry huge trade deficits with the US, partake in unfair trade, etc.  Doing it to allies like the UK that had a trade surplus with the US and charged low (2.2% on avg.) tariffs before liberation day serves no purpose and is counter productive.

3 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Again, Greenland will realize very quickly they’re in a better spot. They’ll get over it much sooner than others 

It is highly unlikely that the US will possesses Greenland, but should the US somehow force this the hard feelings will last a long time.  If you feel like something was taken from you wrongly it can be hard to let go. Just ask Trump.  He believes the 2020 election was stolen and is still going on about it more than 5 years later.   He brought it up in his speech at the World Economic Forum this week.

Posted
25 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Leverage can be powerful tool to get you something you wouldn’t otherwise be able to obtain.  You shouldn’t waste it where it is not necessary.

Trump constantly threatening tariffs and scraping deals on a whim will just cause allies and partners look elsewhere to countries with more stable trade policies and international relations.  Canada just made a deal with China for reduced tariffs on EV imports more such deals will follow if these trade games continue. 

Trump should use these tactics on countries that charge high tariffs on US imports, carry huge trade deficits with the US, partake in unfair trade, etc.  Doing it to allies like the UK that had a trade surplus with the US and charged low (2.2% on avg.) tariffs before liberation day serves no purpose and is counter productive.

It is highly unlikely that the US will possesses Greenland, but should the US somehow force this the hard feelings will last a long time.  If you feel like something was taken from you wrongly it can be hard to let go. Just ask Trump.  He believes the 2020 election was stolen and is still going on about it more than 5 years later.   He brought it up in his speech at the World Economic Forum this week.

Like anything in life people lose but have to get over it.  It’s been 80+ years since WWIi. If you don’t think Japan is still mad they got what they got you’re an idiot.  They moved on because they had to.  So will Trump, so will Greenland.  

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
3 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Like anything in life people lose but have to get over it.  It’s been 80+ years since WWIi. If you don’t think Japan is still mad they got what they got you’re an idiot.  They moved on because they had to.  So will Trump, so will Greenland.  

Did you forget the history lesson that defeated combatants in WWII were not treated as harshly as in the treaty of Versailles?  That is one reason why 80 year of peace followed WWIi.  There was less bitterness and economic hardship.  If the allied forces sent Japan a bill for nuking them relations might have been frosty longer.  

Not to mention Japan has culpability in that they were a belligerent.  What has Greenland or Denmark done to harm the US?  The US is supposed to be an ally of Denmark.  To use economic or military pressure to take their land is totally out of bounds.  Sure if it happens Denmark will have to move on, but that would be without the US as an ally and NATO would be changed forever.  How could the US remain?

If your business partner ran off with 98% of your property you would shrug and say “Sometimes you lose.  I gotta get over it.” And go back to doing business with them.  That partnership is over.

Posted
1 hour ago, fishbane said:

Did you forget the history lesson that defeated combatants in WWII were not treated as harshly as in the treaty of Versailles?  That is one reason why 80 year of peace followed WWIi.  There was less bitterness and economic hardship.  If the allied forces sent Japan a bill for nuking them relations might have been frosty longer.  

Not to mention Japan has culpability in that they were a belligerent.  What has Greenland or Denmark done to harm the US?  The US is supposed to be an ally of Denmark.  To use economic or military pressure to take their land is totally out of bounds.  Sure if it happens Denmark will have to move on, but that would be without the US as an ally and NATO would be changed forever.  How could the US remain?

If your business partner ran off with 98% of your property you would shrug and say “Sometimes you lose.  I gotta get over it.” And go back to doing business with them.  That partnership is over.

Resentful is your favorite word. They’ll get over it. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
4 minutes ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

The world is better off if: 66% of Nato funding and 1/3 of the force, is safer and in a better defensive position.

Nonsense.   The US has fewer than 200 troops on Greenland.  If they want to increase that number or expand the space force base there they could do that.  In the past they have had significantly more under the treaty.  They could put golden dome missiles on the island too.  None of that requires the island to change hands.  

Forcing Greenland to become part of the US is counter productive.  The US will get kicked out of NATO.  That does not make us safer.  If more troops or golden dome missiles on Greenland makes us safer then we can do that under the current treaty without taking the island and keep NATO intact and be better off.

If having the US military on the island ultimately proves to be the greater threat to Denmark and Greenland’s sovereignty than Russia or China than other countries will take note.  The US has 100+ military installations in 50+ different countries.   Some of those countries may reevaluate those treaties given the fate of Greenland/Denmark.  If those installations are important to US security then this could also make us less safe.

Posted (edited)
29 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Nonsense.   The US has fewer than 200 troops on Greenland.  If they want to increase that number or expand the space force base there they could do that.  In the past they have had significantly more under the treaty.  They could put golden dome missiles on the island too.  None of that requires the island to change hands.  

Forcing Greenland to become part of the US is counter productive.  The US will get kicked out of NATO.  That does not make us safer.  If more troops or golden dome missiles on Greenland makes us safer then we can do that under the current treaty without taking the island and keep NATO intact and be better off.

If having the US military on the island ultimately proves to be the greater threat to Denmark and Greenland’s sovereignty than Russia or China than other countries will take note.  The US has 100+ military installations in 50+ different countries.   Some of those countries may reevaluate those treaties given the fate of Greenland/Denmark.  If those installations are important to US security then this could also make us less safe.

First of all:  I didn't say we have to take over the country. 

Second:  Maybe forcing them to to acknowledge what is safest for all. Ok Europe is going to kick us out of NATO . Sure.

Third: your third paragraph is BS. They are already part of NATO and located in strategic air space. So their little equipment they/us now have on the ground is going to be taken out anyway. Build it so it has the advantage. Your scenario is dumb. Give Russia and China a military advantage so Greenland won't have its current military structure attacked, kind of sit back and get bomb thinking.

Edited by Gene Mills Fan
Posted
38 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Nonsense.   The US has fewer than 200 troops on Greenland.  If they want to increase that number or expand the space force base there they could do that.  In the past they have had significantly more under the treaty.  They could put golden dome missiles on the island too.  None of that requires the island to change hands.  

Forcing Greenland to become part of the US is counter productive.  The US will get kicked out of NATO.  That does not make us safer.  If more troops or golden dome missiles on Greenland makes us safer then we can do that under the current treaty without taking the island and keep NATO intact and be better off.

If having the US military on the island ultimately proves to be the greater threat to Denmark and Greenland’s sovereignty than Russia or China than other countries will take note.  The US has 100+ military installations in 50+ different countries.   Some of those countries may reevaluate those treaties given the fate of Greenland/Denmark.  If those installations are important to US security then this could also make us less safe.

Kicked out of NATO by Europe  Bahahahahahahahaha. That’s cute. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
1 minute ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

First of all:  I didn't say we have to take over the country. 

This thread is “should we invade Greenland?”  That is what is being discussed.  Though President Trump has backed off taking it by force, he has floated using coercive tactics to obtain it which will damage our relationship with our allies all the same.

It is obvious we do not need ownership to meet security objectives.  Trump still says otherwise.  That is a problem for Greenland, Denmark, NATO, and the United States.

5 minutes ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

Second:  Maybe forcing them to to acknowledge what is safest for all.

Trump is seeking ownership.  The US can try to make the case that US ownership means greater safety for Greenlanders and Denmark, but I don’t think it is a very compelling case.  Sovereignty is more important to them and an invasion by China, Russia, or another country is far from imminent.  

The US government appears to share my assessment of the threat of a Chinese or Russian invasion.  If they thought invasion were imminent and Greenland was as important to national security as Trump claims, we would have more than 100-200 troops at a single p space force base on the island.  In the past under the same treaty that is still in effect the US had three military installations and thousands of troops on the island and could have even more military build up than that under the treaty.  Yet there has been no build up.

Perhaps at some point in the future risk of invasion will be more real and this argument will have more weight with Greenlanders.

19 minutes ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

Third: your third paragraph is BS. They are already part of NATO and located in strategic air space. So their little equipment they/us now have on the ground is going to be taken out anyway. Build it so it has the advantage. Your scenario is dumb. Give Russia and China a military advantage so Greenland won't have its current military structure attacked, kind of sit back and get bomb thinking.

You are confused.  That is not the argument being made.   

Greenland is currently an autonomously governed part of Denmark and as discussed earlier the threat of either Russia or China invading is remote.  These are hypothetical future threats.  On the other hand, the US is actively seeking ownership of the island.  The USA is the biggest threat to Greenland’s sovereignty right now.

The US can build it up its military on the island under the treaty without ownership, if Trump refuses to do that without ownership then US security isn’t really his objective it’s territorial expansion.  As you said it would be dumb for Trump to give Russia and China an unnecessary military advantage.  He could “build it so it has the advantage” but he won’t.  

Posted
50 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

I’ll take that bet. 

No point.  It’s based on a hypothetical that will not happen.  The US will not get ownership of the island under Trump’s presidency.

Posted

1. Trump always goes for broke and negotiates to better than before.  I was not answering the OP I was stating fact. 

you called it nonsense.  we have triple Turkeys manpower involved in NATO all over the world and they are second in supplying the NATO force. 

I'm not for invading but ownership or leasing to avoid an, Afghanistan like equipment exit, if ever needed.  Every president and the Pentagon have projected this as the safest scenario.

2. We only need the land where we build. They will be economically reciprocated by supplying and supporting Americans working next to them. Increased markets and imports and commodities will increase their economy. 

This is not a new urgent plan. It's a practical long term application. not only for immediate safety but for future negotiation purposes and strength to demand peace with a Bigger stick.

3. they(Russai China) aren't going to take over Greenland just bomb the currently weak military structures in place as they send missiles or aircraft on the way to harm us. Any strategic plans that involve this location are mute if we can do what we want their weakening their global demands and presence.    

 

Posted
4 hours ago, fishbane said:

No point.  It’s based on a hypothetical that will not happen.  The US will not get ownership of the island under Trump’s presidency.

So then why’d you say it ? 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
6 hours ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

1. Trump always goes for broke and negotiates to better than before.  I was not answering the OP I was stating fact. 

you called it nonsense.  we have triple Turkeys manpower involved in NATO all over the world and they are second in supplying the NATO force. 

I'm not for invading but ownership or leasing to avoid an, Afghanistan like equipment exit, if ever needed.  Every president and the Pentagon have projected this as the safest scenario.

The US is at a near all time low for manpower and bases in Greenland.  This is not the result of anything Denmark, Greenland, or NATO has done.  If more troops or aircraft in Greenland makes the US safer he could send them to that base right now.  If more bases would make the US safer the US has the right to build additional bases in Greenland under the current treaty with NATO approval.  This would not be a problem to get.   

Every president has projected what as the safest scenario?  Which presidents?  The reason there are under 200 troops in Greenland is likely $$.  Maintaining the bases and personnel above the artic circle is expensive and I am sure troops are not jumping up to volunteer to go there.  If Trump, Biden, or Obama felt this was important they would have sent more troops and resources long ago, but the danger is remote and the costs high so they didn't.

Finally the fact you wrote "The world is better off if: 66% of Nato funding and 1/3 of the force, is safer and in a better defensive position." Is not a fact but an opinion.  If the US becomes safer by either taking Greenland by force or coercing it from our allies through economic pressure it could end NATO.  NATO staying in place is better for the world and improves US safety more than US ownership of Greenland and no NATO. 

Trumps go for broke strategy here stands to gain nothing and damages our alliances and NATO.  Look at the World Economic Forum.  Mark Carney's speech got a standing ovation.  Trump gives a speech shitting on our European allies and does not.  Then he announces that Board of Peace and literally none of the European powers sign onto it.  How are we better off?  Closer to countries such as Argentina, Saudi Arabia, and Hungary and not as close with Denmark, UK, and Canada NATO members that actually buy our products and services.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Bryson Galloway

    North East HS, Pennsylvania
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Slippery Rock
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Joe Constable

    Fort Dodge, Iowa
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State
    Projected Weight: 285

    Konner Larkin

    Valiant Prep, Arizona
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Arizona State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Adan Castillo

    Clovis, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Little Rock
    Projected Weight: 285

    Sy Strobel

    West-Oak, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Appalachian State
    Projected Weight: 184
×
×
  • Create New...