Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
3 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

So your hypotheticals are ok but not mine?  Got it.  China does not have the water it needs to sustain itself.  Just across the border in Russia is the world’s deepest lake that would supply them with all the water they need.  Very likely a conflict will arise because of that lake and a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control.  Europe can’t defend itself now and Russia knows it.  Without America Europe is done. Actually the demise of nato started in trumps first term when he forced them to pay what they agreed to pay.  Trump could only do so much in term one as he didn’t control the Oval Office, senate and house like he currently does.  Plus he learned that he needed to clean house and bring in his own people for this term.  Yes, it did start up when Biden was president. I don’t blame him but I do blame the people that were running him and hiding his senility.  America during that time went hard to wokeness like Europe did and is the reason Trump reelected. 
 

At some point Greenland will become part of America. They would be wise to get something for their people while they can. 

I’m fine with hypotheticals so long as they make sense.  I am not sure Lake Baikal is the solution to China’s water problems.  There is the country of Mongolia and a massive desert between it and the part of China where everyone lives.  Is China occupying Mongolia in your hypothetical future?

Even if it is a solution it’s a little ridiculous to think that Russia would lose a conflict with China occupying its eastern part and then be able to control Europe either simultaneously or shortly thereafter.  The EU without the US, Canada, and other NATO allies has 3x the population and ~10x the GDP of Russia.  A Russia that has taken 4+ years to stalemate with the poorest country in Europe isn’t going to be able to control the entire continent much less coming off taking an L to China in the east.  You are delusional. 
 

A war already occurred where the US sent troops to Greenland back in the 1940s.  This was long before you made up the buzzword salad “woke liberal new world order.”  Even then the great and not woke US did not attempt to take territory it had no claim to from an ally.  With Trump in office three more years the Greenlanders are really only betting that such a war won’t break out in the very near future.  The next president will likely not care about controlling Greenland against the wishes of Greenland and the Danish government like every other president before Trump.

  • Replies 237
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted (edited)
35 minutes ago, fishbane said:

I’m fine with hypotheticals so long as they make sense.  I am not sure Lake Baikal is the solution to China’s water problems.  There is the country of Mongolia and a massive desert between it and the part of China where everyone lives.  Is China occupying Mongolia in your hypothetical future?

Even if it is a solution it’s a little ridiculous to think that Russia would lose a conflict with China occupying its eastern part and then be able to control Europe either simultaneously or shortly thereafter.  The EU without the US, Canada, and other NATO allies has 3x the population and ~10x the GDP of Russia.  A Russia that has taken 4+ years to stalemate with the poorest country in Europe isn’t going to be able to control the entire continent much less coming off taking an L to China in the east.  You are delusional. 
 

A war already occurred where the US sent troops to Greenland back in the 1940s.  This was long before you made up the buzzword salad “woke liberal new world order.”  Even then the great and not woke US did not attempt to take territory it had no claim to from an ally.  With Trump in office three more years the Greenlanders are really only betting that such a war won’t break out in the very near future.  The next president will likely not care about controlling Greenland against the wishes of Greenland and the Danish government like every other president before Trump.

A.  I never said anyone was occupying anyone else.  
B.  I never said China or Russia would win any conflict. But water is the most important resource there is.  90% of chinas water is undrinkable. Things don’t need to happen all in a three year timeframe. 
C. Russia has more nukes than any country on earth. I wouldn’t give them a reason to use them if I were Ukraine or Europe.  GDP and/or population won’t matter one iota if they use them. Btw that poorest country on the planet you’re referring to has received billions of dollars from the US and other nations.  Pay attention.  
D. I never coined any phrase (wish I did ) but the wokesters sure earned it.  
E. Allies change over time. See Japan.  
F.  The next President would be wise to look further into the future than a couple years. You would be too. 

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
28 minutes ago, fishbane said:

I’m fine with hypotheticals so long as they make sense.  I am not sure Lake Baikal is the solution to China’s water problems.  There is the country of Mongolia and a massive desert between it and the part of China where everyone lives.  Is China occupying Mongolia in your hypothetical future?

Even if it is a solution it’s a little ridiculous to think that Russia would lose a conflict with China occupying its eastern part and then be able to control Europe either simultaneously or shortly thereafter.  The EU without the US, Canada, and other NATO allies has 3x the population and ~10x the GDP of Russia.  A Russia that has taken 4+ years to stalemate with the poorest country in Europe isn’t going to be able to control the entire continent much less coming off taking an L to China in the east.  You are delusional. 
 

A war already occurred where the US sent troops to Greenland back in the 1940s.  This was long before you made up the buzzword salad “woke liberal new world order.”  Even then the great and not woke US did not attempt to take territory it had no claim to from an ally.  With Trump in office three more years the Greenlanders are really only betting that such a war won’t break out in the very near future.  The next president will likely not care about controlling Greenland against the wishes of Greenland and the Danish government like every other president before Trump.

https://ipdefenseforum.com/2023/06/prcs-growing-thirst-may-spark-tension-with-russia-over-lake-baikal/

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
4 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

A.  I never said anyone was occupying anyone else.  

"Very likely a conflict will arise because of that lake and a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control." How does that happen without China occupying part of Russia?

9 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

C. Russia has more nukes than any country on earth. I wouldn’t give them a reason to use them if I were Ukraine or Europe.  GDP and/or population won’t matter one iota if they use them. 

That is not a path to control just destruction.

13 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

F.  The next President would be wise to look further into the future than a couple years. You world be too. 

The next president would be wise to not manufacture unnecessary conflicts over territory the US has no claim. 

Posted (edited)
8 minutes ago, fishbane said:

"Very likely a conflict will arise because of that lake and a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control." How does that happen without China occupying part of Russia?

That is not a path to control just destruction.

The next president would be wise to not manufacture unnecessary conflicts over territory the US has no claim. 

A.  That’s what I originally said. A conflict at some point is likely because of water.  Probably just a matter of when. 
B.  Germany was destroyed, then controlled.  Japan too. 
C.  Not a country on this planet that hasn’t been taken in war or conflict by a nation with no claim. Right or wrong it’s a fact. 

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
5 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

A.  That’s what I originally said. A conflict at some point is likely because of water.  Probably just a matter of when. 

What about the second part of that statement? "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control" China is currently occupying part of Russia or this will happen after the future conflict?

7 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

B.  Germany was destroyed, then controlled.  Japan too. 

Germany and Japan didn't have nuclear weapons.  Europe does.

8 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

C.  Not a country on this planet that hasn’t been taken in war or conflict by a nation with no claim. Right or wrong it’s a fact. 

This cannot be a fact as it is an unintelligible statement.

Posted
Just now, fishbane said:

What about the second part of that statement? "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control" China is currently occupying part of Russia or this will happen after the future conflict?

Germany and Japan didn't have nuclear weapons.  Europe does.

This cannot be a fact as it is an unintelligible statement.

A.  That’s your comment. I never said who wins the conflict. Just that there would be one. 
B.  Not as many. Not nearly enough.  USA is the only country that comes close. 
C.  Google it. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
8 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

A.  That’s your comment. I never said who wins the conflict. Just that there would be one. 

Literally exactly what you wrote "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control".  No idea what you ment.  This is not true currently. So I figured you were talking post conflict.

8 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

B) Not as many. Not nearly enough. USA is the only country that comes close. 

It's enough.  5000+ is unnecessary.

8 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

 C.  Google it. 

No point.  No one knows what you are trying to say when you speak in a triple negative like that.  Do you not get when I ain't trying to not say?  I didn't think so.

Posted
2 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Literally exactly what you wrote "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control".  No idea what you ment.  This is not true currently. So I figured you were talking post conflict.

It's enough.  5000+ is unnecessary.

No point.  No one knows what you are trying to say when you speak in a triple negative like that.  Do you not get when I ain't trying to not say?  I didn't think so.

A.

image.thumb.png.d29f2246ac24f3b4f53d8dc711bf08eb.png

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
3 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Literally exactly what you wrote "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control".  No idea what you ment.  This is not true currently. So I figured you were talking post conflict.

It's enough.  5000+ is unnecessary.

No point.  No one knows what you are trying to say when you speak in a triple negative like that.  Do you not get when I ain't trying to not say?  I didn't think so.

B.   Russia would destroy Europe in a nuclear war. 
 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted

So when you wrote  "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control" you meant a few islands and a river inlet totaling maybe 400km^2?  That is a very small piece of Russia.  Far more of modern Russia used to part of China than the other way round.

10 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

B.   Russia would destroy Europe in a nuclear war. 
 

A war that will not be fought. 

11 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

B. Again

https://theweek.com/news/defence/104574/nato-vs-russia-who-would-win

 

Without the US they’re done. 

“Even without the US, the collective military capability of Nato members is ‘formidable’, said George Allison in The Telegraph.”

…

“With an integrated command structure developed over decades, better trained and equipped troops and the ‘notable difference in the quality of Western weapons, all this adds up to the conclusion that Nato would quickly prevail in any conventional war against Russia’, said Al Jazeera.

Yet herein lies the ‘danger’: that ‘a series of defeats might force Moscow to use tactical nuclear weapons or face total defeat’.”

That’s all from your source.  With Russia struggling for years in a conventional conflict with the poorest nation in Europe they are not about to start a direct conflict with the entire continent.  It would not end well for the Russians and possibly the entire world if things go nuclear.  It doesn’t really matter either way your assertion that Russia will control Europe is unlikely.  Russia simply lacks the requisite number of troops/population to control the entire continent. 

Posted (edited)
8 minutes ago, fishbane said:

So when you wrote  "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control" you meant a few islands and a river inlet totaling maybe 400km^2?  That is a very small piece of Russia.  Far more of modern Russia used to part of China than the other way round.

A war that will not be fought. 

“Even without the US, the collective military capability of Nato members is ‘formidable’, said George Allison in The Telegraph.”

…

“With an integrated command structure developed over decades, better trained and equipped troops and the ‘notable difference in the quality of Western weapons, all this adds up to the conclusion that Nato would quickly prevail in any conventional war against Russia’, said Al Jazeera.

Yet herein lies the ‘danger’: that ‘a series of defeats might force Moscow to use tactical nuclear weapons or face total defeat’.”

That’s all from your source.  With Russia struggling for years in a conventional conflict with the poorest nation in Europe they are not about to start a direct conflict with the entire continent.  It would not end well for the Russians and possibly the entire world if things go nuclear.  It doesn’t really matter either way your assertion that Russia will control Europe is unlikely.  Russia simply lacks the requisite number of troops/population to control the entire continent. 

NATO currently includes the USA.  As I’ve stated without America everything changes.  Formidable doesn’t mean winning and without America they’re not even formidable.  Keep trying. 

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
12 minutes ago, fishbane said:

So when you wrote  "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control" you meant a few islands and a river inlet totaling maybe 400km^2?  That is a very small piece of Russia.  Far more of modern Russia used to part of China than the other way round.

A war that will not be fought. 

“Even without the US, the collective military capability of Nato members is ‘formidable’, said George Allison in The Telegraph.”

…

“With an integrated command structure developed over decades, better trained and equipped troops and the ‘notable difference in the quality of Western weapons, all this adds up to the conclusion that Nato would quickly prevail in any conventional war against Russia’, said Al Jazeera.

Yet herein lies the ‘danger’: that ‘a series of defeats might force Moscow to use tactical nuclear weapons or face total defeat’.”

That’s all from your source.  With Russia struggling for years in a conventional conflict with the poorest nation in Europe they are not about to start a direct conflict with the entire continent.  It would not end well for the Russians and possibly the entire world if things go nuclear.  It doesn’t really matter either way your assertion that Russia will control Europe is unlikely.  Russia simply lacks the requisite number of troops/population to control the entire continent. 

image.thumb.png.43c1c36da6ac42b5aeebb0706161d1ee.png

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
34 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

C.

image.thumb.png.889bcb21678d8478bc0a95f22dd8f183.png

You googled some thing that started with “are there ny countries …” and not the unintelligible statement “Not a country on this planet that hasn’t been taken in war or conflict by a nation with no claim. Right or wrong it’s a fact.” Whatever you searched for still generated a list of countries that avoided war and/or occupation.
 

The US has no claim to Greenland and the residents do not want to be part of the US.  Trump is now breaking the trade deals he made with ally nations not 6 months ago over this nonsense claim.  What was the point of the trade deals?

Posted
Just now, fishbane said:

You googled some thing that started with “are there ny countries …” and not the unintelligible statement “Not a country on this planet that hasn’t been taken in war or conflict by a nation with no claim. Right or wrong it’s a fact.” Whatever you searched for still generated a list of countries that avoided war and/or occupation.
 

The US has no claim to Greenland and the residents do not want to be part of the US.  Trump is now breaking the trade deals he made with ally nations not 6 months ago over this nonsense claim.  What was the point of the trade deals?

Name a country on this planet that hasn’t been taken by war or conflict.  Might be one. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
3 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

image.thumb.png.43c1c36da6ac42b5aeebb0706161d1ee.png

Outer Manchuria is part of Russia that used to be part of China.  You had said "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control.”

Posted
1 minute ago, fishbane said:

You googled some thing that started with “are there ny countries …” and not the unintelligible statement “Not a country on this planet that hasn’t been taken in war or conflict by a nation with no claim. Right or wrong it’s a fact.” Whatever you searched for still generated a list of countries that avoided war and/or occupation.
 

The US has no claim to Greenland and the residents do not want to be part of the US.  Trump is now breaking the trade deals he made with ally nations not 6 months ago over this nonsense claim.  What was the point of the trade deals?

History of the world proves that what countries want isn’t what always happens. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
10 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

NATO currently includes the USA.  As I’ve stated without America everything changes.  Formidable doesn’t mean winning and without America they’re not even formidable.  Keep trying. 

Now you are arguing with your own source…

Posted
Just now, fishbane said:

Outer Manchuria is part of Russia that used to be part of China.  You had said "a large piece of what was once Russia that is now under chinas control.”

Nope. But even IF I did it’s still a reason for conflict along with the water they need.  Prove me wrong. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
1 minute ago, fishbane said:

Now you are arguing with your own source…

Nope. You’re using NATO with America.  As I’ve stated many times Trump wants out of NATO and Europe is done without it. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
5 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Nope. But even IF I did it’s still a reason for conflict along with the water they need.  Prove me wrong. 

Sure conflict whatever that means.  The water is Russia’s and it’s up to them whether they want to do the pipeline thing or not.  It would seem being dependent on Russia for water would limit China’s control over Asia.

6 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Nope. You’re using NATO with America.  As I’ve stated many times Trump wants out of NATO and Europe is done without it. 

No I’m not and neither was your source.

10 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

History of the world proves that what countries want isn’t what always happens. 

Greenland is self governing.  If they don’t want to join the US they can simply not join the US.  The US cannot purchase what is not for sale.

Posted
6 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Sure conflict whatever that means.  The water is Russia’s and it’s up to them whether they want to do the pipeline thing or not.  It would seem being dependent on Russia for water would limit China’s control over Asia.

No I’m not and neither was your source.

Greenland is self governing.  If they don’t want to join the US they can simply not join the US.  The US cannot purchase what is not for sale.

If a war breaks out Greenland will immediately be seized by the US. We’ve covered this multiple times already 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted (edited)
23 minutes ago, fishbane said:

Sure conflict whatever that means.  The water is Russia’s and it’s up to them whether they want to do the pipeline thing or not.  It would seem being dependent on Russia for water would limit China’s control over Asia.

No I’m not and neither was your source.

Greenland is self governing.  If they don’t want to join the US they can simply not join the US.  The US cannot purchase what is not for sale.

Korea was a conflict not a war.  It resulted in two separate countries. So sure. 

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Bryson Galloway

    North East HS, Pennsylvania
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Slippery Rock
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Joe Constable

    Fort Dodge, Iowa
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State
    Projected Weight: 285

    Konner Larkin

    Valiant Prep, Arizona
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Arizona State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Adan Castillo

    Clovis, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Little Rock
    Projected Weight: 285

    Sy Strobel

    West-Oak, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Appalachian State
    Projected Weight: 184
×
×
  • Create New...