Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
25 minutes ago, braves121 said:

I have less ire for a map being approved by the voters of the state compared to legislators making maps that benefit the without putting it up to voters 

You have less ire for voters that vote by just over 50% to go from just over 50% D to R to just over 90% D to R?   You definitely have no problem compartmentalizing that's for sure.   How is it that 50% of voters can force almost all congressional districts to go D?   Maybe all Red states should do the same according to your logic.   But you would be up in arms screaming how unfair it is.   The districts should be centralized and not stretched out.  Just my opinion.   

mspart

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
8 minutes ago, mspart said:

You have less ire for voters that vote by just over 50% to go from just over 50% D to R to just over 90% D to R?   You definitely have no problem compartmentalizing that's for sure.   How is it that 50% of voters can force almost all congressional districts to go D?   Maybe all Red states should do the same according to your logic.   But you would be up in arms screaming how unfair it is.   The districts should be centralized and not stretched out.  Just my opinion.   

mspart

Yea red states should put it up to their voters we are on the same page there. 

Posted
Just now, braves121 said:

Yea red states should put it up to their voters we are on the same page there. 

Who votes for the politicians that make the policies?  And do you feel that anytime a politician wants to change or implement a policy it should go up for vote first?

Posted

What he is saying is what the Founders feared and why they put in two houses of congress.   That a pure democracy would become one sided and oppressive.   The fact that 50+% of the voters can decide that 90+% of the House seats will go to one party makes no sense, unless you subscribe to the above.   In which case you are for an oppressive situation.   That VA vote is oppressive.   

mspart

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
1 minute ago, mspart said:

What he is saying is what the Founders feared and why they put in two houses of congress.   That a pure democracy would become one sided and oppressive.   The fact that 50+% of the voters can decide that 90+% of the House seats will go to one party makes no sense, unless you subscribe to the above.   In which case you are for an oppressive situation.   That VA vote is oppressive.   

mspart

The founders also thought blacks were property, women couldn’t vote, and only certain land owning men could vote, not everything they did was great and should be how we govern today.

  • Poopy -1 1
Posted

Having 50% determine 90% of the representation is not great and should not be how we govern today.  

mspart

 

Posted
On 5/4/2026 at 4:31 PM, braves121 said:

Aka how a majority of bills are passed within our government. Majority rules has been the foundation of our country 

No!!!  Representative government and that said government has very limited duties and powers.  No majority can take away your inalienable rights bestowed by our creator (or fact of personhood for the atheists).  We have no rulers - including the majority.  The government has limited, temporary,  and revocable authority.  No rulers.

People who tolerate me on a daily basis . . . they are the real heroes.

Posted
6 minutes ago, Lipdrag said:

No!!!  Representative government and that said government has very limited duties and powers.  No majority can take away your inalienable rights bestowed by our creator (or fact of personhood for the atheists).  We have no rulers - including the majority.  The government has limited, temporary,  and revocable authority.  No rulers.

Socialists want to.   

Posted
On 5/4/2026 at 4:31 PM, braves121 said:

Aka how a majority of bills are passed within our government. Majority rules has been the foundation of our country 

Wrong.  That is ochlocracy.  We have checks and balances and a number of safeguards to prevent this.

Posted

The fact that the people in office get to slice up maps and pick their voters to remain in power - or unduly shift the balance of power - is insane.

It's wrong regardless of who does it. 

We're in a time where governors are canceling elections (and thereby votes) and will actively redistrict for elections in which more than 40K votes have been cast because the SCOTUS essentially has decided that the Voting Rights Act had run its course, which unironically will be shown to be specious by the very case it ruled on. 

They've thrown out the umbrella during a rainstorm because they aren't getting wet. 

 

Posted
21 minutes ago, KSoze said:

The fact that the people in office get to slice up maps and pick their voters to remain in power - or unduly shift the balance of power - is insane.

It's wrong regardless of who does it. 

We're in a time where governors are canceling elections (and thereby votes) and will actively redistrict for elections in which more than 40K votes have been cast because the SCOTUS essentially has decided that the Voting Rights Act had run its course, which unironically will be shown to be specious by the very case it ruled on. 

They've thrown out the umbrella during a rainstorm because they aren't getting wet. 

 

“By the way, the VRA already says that: “[N]othing in this section establishes a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population.” So reaffirming that intentional discrimination is what matters, and that you can’t merely look to effects, seems obviously the right result here.“

https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2026/04/the-supreme-court-does-justice-on-districting.php

The Calais decision merely corrects decades of faulty interpretations by the courts.  “ Chief Justice John Roberts: “The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.””

Posted
1 hour ago, Offthemat said:

“By the way, the VRA already says that: “[N]othing in this section establishes a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population.” So reaffirming that intentional discrimination is what matters, and that you can’t merely look to effects, seems obviously the right result here.“

https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2026/04/the-supreme-court-does-justice-on-districting.php

The Calais decision merely corrects decades of faulty interpretations by the courts.  “ Chief Justice John Roberts: “The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.””

I realize that conservatives are going to have this perspective and will create various strawmen to make their point, but what this decision does is allow maps that will effectively eliminate all minority representation for those districts in Louisiana. Roughly 40% of the state's population will have zero representation in a representative democracy because the state is now allowed to draw a map to dilute the voting power of the minorities. It's the new Jim Crow era. 

It literally was what the VRA was for. 

You can't stop discrimination on the basis of race by discriminating on the basis of race. 

 

Posted

 “[N]othing in this section establishes a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population."

That sentence is in the act, it is not a strawman.  The recent decision merely restores the original intent of the act.  

Are you trying to say that black people's interests can only be served by black representatives?  That white people won't vote for black candidates?  That black people can only be represented effectively by black dimocrax?  The current makeup of the House and the election of Obama would argue against those stances. 

Posted

Since texas said they redrew their districts to include more Hispanics will they have to redraw their map? Tennessee is splitting their one black district into 3 new ones but Texas gets to do Hispanic districts? 

Posted (edited)
27 minutes ago, Offthemat said:

 “[N]othing in this section establishes a right to have members of a protected class elected in numbers equal to their proportion in the population."

That sentence is in the act, it is not a strawman.  The recent decision merely restores the original intent of the act.  

Are you trying to say that black people's interests can only be served by black representatives?  That white people won't vote for black candidates?  That black people can only be represented effectively by black dimocrax?  The current makeup of the House and the election of Obama would argue against those stances. 

It is a strawman because people aren't asking for proportional representation - they want to maintain any representation. He's shifting the argument to suit his position. 

You seem to be arguing that the very people who are going to create maps to eliminate all representation for black people are going to serve their interests. That's a pretty bold claim and it flies in the face of history. 

I also don't think it's a stretch to say that someone who shares similar life experiences would represent you interests better than someone who does not. If you're a white farmer in rural Iowa, your interests are likely to be better served by a white farmer from rural Iowa than they are by a chiropractor from Des Moines. 

In fact, I'd argue that those are exactly the type of representatives we should have, in districts where people share common interests - you know, as is depicted in the now gutted VRA. 

Which brings me back to the point: Gerrymandering is wrong no matter who does it. 

 

Edited by KSoze
Posted
17 hours ago, Lipdrag said:

No!!!  Representative government and that said government has very limited duties and powers.  No majority can take away your inalienable rights bestowed by our creator (or fact of personhood for the atheists).  We have no rulers - including the majority.  The government has limited, temporary,  and revocable authority.  No rulers.

the problem is the majority wins, and then APPOINTS the rule makers.

all of the policy... that is not part of what congress does, other than appoint people to these departments/agencies.

who then make rules... 

Posted
1 hour ago, KSoze said:

You seem to be arguing that the very people who are going to create maps to eliminate all representation for black people are going to serve their interests. That's a pretty bold claim and it flies in the face of history. 

Did you miss the part where discrimination is unconstitutional?

 

1 hour ago, KSoze said:

I also don't think it's a stretch to say that someone who shares similar life experiences would represent you interests better than someone who does not. If you're a white farmer in rural Iowa, your interests are likely to be better served by a white farmer from rural Iowa than they are by a chiropractor from Des Moines.

This utopian dream of yours would require absolute democracy, which in practice you’d find very undesirable.  Statements like this exhibit a superficial level of sophistication in the subject, at best. 

 

1 hour ago, KSoze said:

Which brings me back to the point: Gerrymandering is wrong no matter who does it. 

 

Well, being as drawing the lines will be done by politicians it’s unlikely that politics will be removed from the process, but at least that’s constitutional.  Drawing them based on race is not. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Scouts Honor said:

all of the policy... that is not part of what congress does, other than appoint people to these departments/agencies.

Not so much, anymore.  The longtime dodge Congress has played by employing agencies to do the dirty work has been curtailed by recent Court decisions, putting the onus back on elected officials.  Back to the Legislative branch writing the laws and the Executive branch enforcing them. 

Posted
35 minutes ago, Offthemat said:

Did you miss the part where discrimination is unconstitutional?

Tell that to the folks in Louisiana.

35 minutes ago, Offthemat said:

This utopian dream of yours would require absolute democracy, which in practice you’d find very undesirable.  Statements like this exhibit a superficial level of sophistication in the subject, at best. 

Ah, yes. The utopian paradise where your representative is an actual member of your community. 

35 minutes ago, Offthemat said:

Well, being as drawing the lines will be done by politicians it’s unlikely that politics will be removed from the process, but at least that’s constitutional.  Drawing them based on race is not. 

Talk about exhibiting a superficial level of sophistication in the subject. 

 

Posted (edited)
31 minutes ago, KSoze said:

Tell that to the folks in Louisiana.

Racism is displayed in different ways.  
 

Can you name any black representatives who were elected in districts that are predominantly white?  How about Senators.  Are there any black Senators who represent states that are predominantly white?  Given that the country is predominantly white, how did Obama get elected?

Are there any predominantly black districts with a white representative?

Edited by Offthemat
Posted (edited)
20 minutes ago, Offthemat said:

name any black ... who were elected in districts that are predominantly white?  

Obama, Tim Scott ...  🙅‍♀️

Edited by ionel

.

Posted (edited)
25 minutes ago, ionel said:

Obama, Tim Scott ...  🙅‍♀️

“A growing number of Black representatives are being elected from predominantly white districts, with 30 out of 60 Black lawmakers in Congress representing such areas as of 2023. This shift indicates a decline in the historical barrier of white voters supporting Black candidates.“

Of course, race baiters still rule. 

Edited by Offthemat
Posted
1 hour ago, KSoze said:

Tell that to the folks in Louisiana.

Gotta check the mayors too 

Top 10 Most Populous U.S. Cities
  • New York, NY: Zohran Mamdani (Assumed office Jan 2026)
  • Los Angeles, CA: Karen Bass (Since 2022)
  • Chicago, IL: Brandon Johnson (Since 2023)
  • Dallas, TX: Eric Johnson (Since 2019) [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
 

 
Other Major U.S. Cities (Pop. over 250,000)
  • Washington, D.C.: Muriel Bowser (Since 2015)
  • Charlotte, NC: Vi Lyles (Since 2017)
  • Baltimore, MD: Brandon Scott (AAMA President)
  • Detroit, MI: Mary Sheffield (Since 2026)
  • Milwaukee, WI: Cavalier Johnson (Since 2021)
  • Atlanta, GA: Andre Dickens (Since 2022)
  • New Orleans, LA: LaToya Cantrell (Since 2018)
  • Philadelphia, PA: Cherelle Parker (Since 2024)
  • Kansas City, MO: Quinton Lucas (Since 2019)
  • Memphis, TN: Paul Young (Since 2024)
  • St. Louis, MO: Tishaura Jones (Since 2021)
  • Cleveland, OH: Justin Bibb (Since 2022)
  • Pittsburgh, PA: Ed Gainey (Since 2022) [1, 3, 4, 6, 7]
 

💡 Historical Note: For the first time in history, the four largest cities in the U.S. (NY, LA, Chicago, Houston) were led by Black mayors simultaneously from 2022 to 2024. As of 2026, following recent elections, Black leadership remains at the helm of the three most populous cities.
  • Wrestle +1 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Eli Gabrielson

    Archbishop Spalding, Maryland
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Maryland
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Jackson McLees

    Travelers Rest, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to The Citadel
    Projected Weight: 149

    Gunnar Gossett

    Union Local, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 165

    Dylan Frass

    Olentangy Liberty, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 285

    Emma Bacon

    Wyoming Seminary, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State (Women)
    Projected Weight: 131
×
×
  • Create New...