Well, you did say "the years he could have been an NCAA champ." I would assume one of the years he won B10, but prob his best shot was 2019.
He had a bad draw (or it looked that way at the time) in 2019:
1st round: the funky returning AA Joe Smith, who happened to not really be at his peak (but on paper, not a great first round for the #1)
2nd round: Bullard from NC State. Ok, not exactly prime David Taylor level of greatness...
Quarters: prob the best version of Mekhi, fresh off his U20 world title. Marinelli loses 3-1 in a match where he definitely had his chances.
Semis: He would have had the Wick/Marstellar winner, who ended up being Wick.
Prime Mekhi beats Cenzo Joseph 7-1 in final.
I'm not saying Marinelli should have won that. Mekhi is the reason he didn't, not the draw. But that was not a great spot in the bracket.
Starocci had a tougher one (on paper) last spring, but also may have ended up wrestling a couple guys (Mekhi, Griffith) who were past their prime and also played to Carter's strengths. The difference is that Carter won. He's just better all the way around.