Like the Heisman, the Hodge is a season-season award given to the wrestler who gets the most amount of first-place votes from the Hodge Trophy Voting Committee and Fan Vote based on these criteria: record, dominance/bonus-point percentage, quality of competition and sportsmanship.
The above is from the WIN voting site. NO mention of past accomplishments. Felt like that was a factor in the past.
Regarding sportsmanship, do we have any data points to judge from?