Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
11 minutes ago, headshuck said:


I am just glad they’re not raiding Comey’s home and rifling through his wife’s underwear drawer.

Like if he was illegally storing classified documents? 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
39 minutes ago, headshuck said:


Yes, like copies of the documents that he leaked to the press

He should have been fried for that one too. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted

https://jonathanturley.org/2026/04/29/shell-speech-why-the-comey-indictment-is-likely-to-fail/#more-243828

Shell Speech: Why the Second Comey Indictment is Likely to Fail

Below is my column on Fox.com on the second indictment of former FBI director James Comey. Despite being one of Comey’s longest critics, the indictment raises troubling free speech issues. In the end, it must be the Constitution, not Comey, that drives the analysis and this indictment is unlikely to withstand constitutional scrutiny. If it did, it would allow the government to criminalize a huge swath of political speech in the United States.

Here is the column:

In the last year, coverage of former FBI Director James Comey appears to be reverting to the level of a high school yearbook. Last March, we were discussing how Comey channeled Beyoncé in a classified meeting and then may have revealed a code name in an encore performance for family. Now we are back to discussing Comey’s beach shell art on social media.

The latter controversy is now at the heart of a second criminal indictment of Comey. In November, a court dismissed the first indictment for false statements after a challenge to the status of the acting U.S. attorney.

However, this indictment is being brought in North Carolina, the location of the beach where the offending shells were found. Comey will now likely create a new category of protected shell speech.

The problem with this indictment will be the merits. The indictment concerns an image that was later removed by Comey showing “86 47” in shells on a beach. Comey has a rather odd history of drawing inspiration from shells. This message, however, had a lethal twist since many interpreted the message as essentially calling for the killing or “86-ing” of Trump.

Comey insists that he did not make the shell art and that he only posted it to his more than 1 million followers on X. He was merely the captive of his shell muses.

440px-comey-fbi-portrait.jpg?resize=155%For over a decade, I have been one of Comey’s most vocal and consistent critics. I have dozens of columns criticizing his excesses and the damage that he has done to our system.

For that reason, I would prefer to crawl into one of Comey’s conversant shells than write a column supporting him. However, here we are. The fact is that I believe that this indictment is facially unconstitutional absent some unknown new facts.

To convict Comey, the Justice Department will have to show that his adolescent picture was a “true threat” under 18 U.S.C. § 871 and § 875(c). It is not.

The First Amendment is designed to protect unpopular speech. Popular speech rarely needs protection. It also protects bad and hateful speech. It even protects lies so long as those lies are not used for the purpose of fraud or other criminal conspiracies.

In 1969, the Supreme Court declared a more direct threat protected under the First Amendment. In Watts v. United States, an 18-year-old anti-war protester exclaimed, “If they ever make me carry a rifle the first man I want to get in my sights is L. B. J.”

While the court did rule that “the statute [criminalizing presidential threats] is constitutional on its face,” it emphasized that “what is a threat must be distinguished from what is constitutionally protected speech.”

The court ruled that the expression of wanting to kill a president is “a kind of very crude offensive method of stating a political opposition to the President.” Saying the same thing in shell is only further removed from criminal speech.

Citizens are allowed to denounce and even wish a president ill. I have written about what I called this “age of rage.” It is not our first. This nation was founded in rage. The Boston Tea Party was rage. In forming this more perfect union, we created the world’s greatest protection of free speech in history. It is arguably the most American contribution to our Bill of Rights. Great Britain did not — and still does not — protect free speech as we do.

It comes at a cost. Perhaps Comey is that cost. However, he has a right to write out any hateful thoughts that come to him on his walks on the beach.

A true threat requires “statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals.” Virginia v. Black, 538 U.S. 343, 359 (2003).

It is certainly true that the threat can be implied. However, “The ‘true’ in that term distinguishes what is at issue from jests, ‘hyperbole,’ or other statements that when taken in context do not convey a real possibility that violence will follow.” Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66, 74 (2023).

At the time, Comey quickly deleted the post and said that it never occurred to him that it would be interpreted as being violent.

In a subsequent Instagram post, Comey said he assumed the shells that he saw on a beach walk were “a political message” and that he “did not realize some folks associate those numbers with violence.”

We will have to wait to see if the administration has a “smoking shell” allegation that makes Comey’s shell speech more menacing as a willful and knowing threat. I cannot imagine what that would be beyond a sleeper surfer hit squad waiting for a shell signal.

Absent such new evidence, it appears to be yet another Comey posting that makes his Beyoncé renditions seem professional in comparison.

Ironically, the indictment is unlikely to survive a challenge, but it is likely to fulfill Comey’s narrative about the administration. It will undermine the legitimate objections to the lawfare waged under Comey.

Comey’s shell speech should not be celebrated, but it should be protected.

Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the New York Times best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.”

For those that think Turley is a tool of the right, here you go.   This sounds like a very unhinged man of the right!!!  🙂 

mspart

 

 

Posted (edited)

Turley is good but not infallible.  He is occasionally more superficial in his assessments of cases than one would expect.  At least here:

38 minutes ago, mspart said:

We will have to wait to see if the administration has a “smoking shell” allegation that makes Comey’s shell speech more menacing as a willful and knowing threat.

      he alludes to the possibility that the government may possess what has been hinted at, that there is evidence of his obfuscation and what the FBI likes to call ‘lack of candor’ in his electronic communications.  If Comey has incriminated himself with his own words then he is going to have a difficult road ahead.  That remains an ‘if’ and Comey is a lawyer, but when you weave a tangled web…

Turley is definitely not an ideologue. 

Edited by Offthemat
Posted
1 hour ago, Offthemat said:

Turley is good but not infallible.  He is occasionally more superficial in his assessments of cases than one would expect.  At least here:

      he alludes to the possibility that the government may possess what has been hinted at, that there is evidence of his obfuscation and what the FBI likes to call ‘lack of candor’ in his electronic communications.  If Comey has incriminated himself with his own words then he is going to have a difficult road ahead.  That remains an ‘if’ and Comey is a lawyer, but when you weave a tangled web…

Turley is definitely not an ideologue. 

... but:   a sleeper surfer hit squad waiting for a shell signal.  🤔

.

Posted
1 hour ago, ionel said:

... but:   a sleeper surfer hit squad waiting for a shell signal.  🤔

He may have been spending too much time with the FOX comedians lately. 

Posted
3 hours ago, mspart said:

https://jonathanturley.org/2026/04/29/shell-speech-why-the-comey-indictment-is-likely-to-fail/#more-243828

Shell Speech: Why the Second Comey Indictment is Likely to Fail

Below is my column on Fox.com on the second indictment of former FBI director James Comey. Despite being one of Comey’s longest critics, the indictment raises troubling free speech issues. In the end, it must be the Constitution, not Comey, that drives the analysis and this indictment is unlikely to withstand constitutional scrutiny. If it did, it would allow the government to criminalize a huge swath of political speech in the United States.

Here is the column:

In the last year, coverage of former FBI Director James Comey appears to be reverting to the level of a high school yearbook. Last March, we were discussing how Comey channeled Beyoncé in a classified meeting and then may have revealed a code name in an encore performance for family. Now we are back to discussing Comey’s beach shell art on social media.

The latter controversy is now at the heart of a second criminal indictment of Comey. In November, a court dismissed the first indictment for false statements after a challenge to the status of the acting U.S. attorney.

However, this indictment is being brought in North Carolina, the location of the beach where the offending shells were found. Comey will now likely create a new category of protected shell speech.

The problem with this indictment will be the merits. The indictment concerns an image that was later removed by Comey showing “86 47” in shells on a beach. Comey has a rather odd history of drawing inspiration from shells. This message, however, had a lethal twist since many interpreted the message as essentially calling for the killing or “86-ing” of Trump.

Comey insists that he did not make the shell art and that he only posted it to his more than 1 million followers on X. He was merely the captive of his shell muses.

440px-comey-fbi-portrait.jpg?resize=155%For over a decade, I have been one of Comey’s most vocal and consistent critics. I have dozens of columns criticizing his excesses and the damage that he has done to our system.

For that reason, I would prefer to crawl into one of Comey’s conversant shells than write a column supporting him. However, here we are. The fact is that I believe that this indictment is facially unconstitutional absent some unknown new facts.

To convict Comey, the Justice Department will have to show that his adolescent picture was a “true threat” under 18 U.S.C. § 871 and § 875(c). It is not.

The First Amendment is designed to protect unpopular speech. Popular speech rarely needs protection. It also protects bad and hateful speech. It even protects lies so long as those lies are not used for the purpose of fraud or other criminal conspiracies.

In 1969, the Supreme Court declared a more direct threat protected under the First Amendment. In Watts v. United States, an 18-year-old anti-war protester exclaimed, “If they ever make me carry a rifle the first man I want to get in my sights is L. B. J.”

While the court did rule that “the statute [criminalizing presidential threats] is constitutional on its face,” it emphasized that “what is a threat must be distinguished from what is constitutionally protected speech.”

The court ruled that the expression of wanting to kill a president is “a kind of very crude offensive method of stating a political opposition to the President.” Saying the same thing in shell is only further removed from criminal speech.

Citizens are allowed to denounce and even wish a president ill. I have written about what I called this “age of rage.” It is not our first. This nation was founded in rage. The Boston Tea Party was rage. In forming this more perfect union, we created the world’s greatest protection of free speech in history. It is arguably the most American contribution to our Bill of Rights. Great Britain did not — and still does not — protect free speech as we do.

It comes at a cost. Perhaps Comey is that cost. However, he has a right to write out any hateful thoughts that come to him on his walks on the beach.

A true threat requires “statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals.” Virginia v. Black, 538 U.S. 343, 359 (2003).

It is certainly true that the threat can be implied. However, “The ‘true’ in that term distinguishes what is at issue from jests, ‘hyperbole,’ or other statements that when taken in context do not convey a real possibility that violence will follow.” Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66, 74 (2023).

At the time, Comey quickly deleted the post and said that it never occurred to him that it would be interpreted as being violent.

In a subsequent Instagram post, Comey said he assumed the shells that he saw on a beach walk were “a political message” and that he “did not realize some folks associate those numbers with violence.”

We will have to wait to see if the administration has a “smoking shell” allegation that makes Comey’s shell speech more menacing as a willful and knowing threat. I cannot imagine what that would be beyond a sleeper surfer hit squad waiting for a shell signal.

Absent such new evidence, it appears to be yet another Comey posting that makes his Beyoncé renditions seem professional in comparison.

Ironically, the indictment is unlikely to survive a challenge, but it is likely to fulfill Comey’s narrative about the administration. It will undermine the legitimate objections to the lawfare waged under Comey.

Comey’s shell speech should not be celebrated, but it should be protected.

Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the New York Times best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.”

For those that think Turley is a tool of the right, here you go.   This sounds like a very unhinged man of the right!!!  🙂 

mspart

 

 

He is a tool of the right. Stating the obvious doesn't make it less so.

Posted
1 hour ago, Doublehalf said:

He is a tool of the right. Stating the obvious doesn't make it less so.

How is this article evidence of him being a tool of the right?

mspart

Posted
On 4/29/2026 at 10:03 AM, Doublehalf said:

Could the right be any more sensitive... Arguing about seashells as a serious threat on someone's life is hilarious. Who are the snowflakes?

Could you be any more disingenuous...like him or hate him, Trump has had three attempts on his life (only ones we know of)...that is WRONG no matter what way you vote.  So YES, people are going to be sensitive when people say things like Comey said.  

I just don't get people...so partisan that just common decency is thrown out the window all for party line.  I dislike Hillary, Kamala, Ilhan, AOC, etc. but purely for their policies and their lack of common sense, but never in a million years would I ever want someone to kill them because of those things.  For crying out loud these people are fathers, mothers, sons, daughters, human freaking beings!!

  • Wrestle +1 3
Posted
20 hours ago, Bigbrog said:

common decency

Again- MAGA trying to argue they have any common decency whatsoever is a joke. Trump ushered in the political age of removing common decency from political discourse to the point everything is ad hominem attacks now. 
 

Bro- you gotta take a look in the mirror or at least think about what you're saying before you type it...

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
On 4/29/2026 at 6:51 PM, mspart said:

How is this article evidence of him being a tool of the right?

mspart

Great try at a redirect- I didn't state the article was evidence- Just that Turley is a tool of the right.

Posted
Just now, Doublehalf said:

Again- MAGA trying to argue they have any common decency whatsoever is a joke. Trump ushered in the political age of removing common decency from political discourse to the point everything is ad hominem attacks now. 
 

Bro- you gotta take a look in the mirror or at least think about what you're saying before you type it...

This has been disproven multiple times. Trump was the first to tell the left to STFU after their lies and rhetoric. Find a new lie to lie.

  • Wrestle +1 2
Posted
1 minute ago, Doublehalf said:

Great try at a redirect- I didn't state the article was evidence- Just that Turley is a tool of the right.

When you can't refute the information , attack the source. 

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
Just now, El Luchador said:

When you can't refute the information , attack the source. 

I'm not trying to refute- I agree Turley is correct in summary saying there is no case against Comey-I agree with him- the Comey indictment is a joke. 
 

You're really struggling today, drink too many beers last night?

Posted
47 minutes ago, Doublehalf said:

Again- MAGA trying to argue they have any common decency whatsoever is a joke. Trump ushered in the political age of removing common decency from political discourse to the point everything is ad hominem attacks now. 
 

Bro- you gotta take a look in the mirror or at least think about what you're saying before you type it...

😂  Are you insinuating I am "MAGA" (whatever "MAGA" means)?  I assume you mean a Trump supporter so we will stick with that...you clearly have not been paying attention if you think I support Trump, and you must have missed the endless times I have indicated that I didn't vote for him and I think he is a loudmouth a$$.  Do I like some of his policies, absolutely...do I dislike some of his policies, absolutely...just like every other president before him no matter what letter is after their name.

Anyway, now on to the more important part, you follow up my post about your illogical comparison of what Comey said versus what the speaker of the house said, along with me explaining why it is a terrible comparison, and the bigger point, how trying to take the life of someone because of how they say things and their policies is completely insane no matter what letter is after their name politically...you ramble attacking Trump about decency??  Seriously?!?!  Amd you consider the conclusion someone clearly would come to based on what you posted, and more importantly didn't post, an "ad hominem attack"??  These "attacks" are so bad that you think death is the answer??  Kill anyone you disagree with because they are "attacking" you??  

What was that "look in a mirror" thing again??

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Bigbrog said:

😂  Are you insinuating I am "MAGA" (whatever "MAGA" means)?  I assume you mean a Trump supporter so we will stick with that...you clearly have not been paying attention if you think I support Trump, and you must have missed the endless times I have indicated that I didn't vote for him and I think he is a loudmouth a$$.  Do I like some of his policies, absolutely...do I dislike some of his policies, absolutely...just like every other president before him no matter what letter is after their name.

Anyway, now on to the more important part, you follow up my post about your illogical comparison of what Comey said versus what the speaker of the house said, along with me explaining why it is a terrible comparison, and the bigger point, how trying to take the life of someone because of how they say things and their policies is completely insane no matter what letter is after their name politically...you ramble attacking Trump about decency??  Seriously?!?!  Amd you consider the conclusion someone clearly would come to based on what you posted, and more importantly didn't post, an "ad hominem attack"??  These "attacks" are so bad that you think death is the answer??  Kill anyone you disagree with because they are "attacking" you??  

What was that "look in a mirror" thing again??

Dude... what the hell are you talking about? I never made any comparison between comey and the speaker of the house? You are making zero sense and the second half of your post is almost pure gibberish. You just sound like someone screaming red faced into the ether in a language that doesn't exist.
 

Are all your guys' brains fried or something?

Edited by Doublehalf
Posted
6 hours ago, Doublehalf said:

Are all your guys' brains fried or something?

Wingerism is a disease. Yes, their brains are fried. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
Sure. The admin is very honest. Judge will throw it out. You're an idiot if u think he'll be convicted. 

I’m hoping the burn bags they found are full of evidence.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Eli Gabrielson

    Archbishop Spalding, Maryland
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Maryland
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Jackson McLees

    Travelers Rest, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to The Citadel
    Projected Weight: 149

    Gunnar Gossett

    Union Local, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 165

    Dylan Frass

    Olentangy Liberty, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 285

    Emma Bacon

    Wyoming Seminary, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State (Women)
    Projected Weight: 131
×
×
  • Create New...