Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
19 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

If your basis to say that undocumented immigrants being here is not a victimless crime, because they use resources that could/should be used to benefit citizens. I will remind you that undocumented immigrants pay into taxes MORE than they take. 
 
So they do help to provide for US citizens and US interests more so than could be if they weren't here. 
 
Simply, your point does not logically follow. 
 
Undocumented immigrants = more money for US taxes than if they weren't here = victimless

So I see based on what you wrote you read half of the full picture and just stuck with that as your opinion, you failed to keep reading or chose to not believe it or just blatantly disregard it.  You left out education and emergency services costs, the fact that they have a much lower income which means their contribution doesn't cover their per capita cost, left out specific studies such as the Heritage Foundations study.  There is actually no consensus on what is true.  Based on what I know, there is a cost, and that is cost we shouldn't be paying for as tax payers.

  • Replies 104
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
42 minutes ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

We are evolving uncontrollably into some crazy ends of the spectrum I'm afraid.

You need to fix your avatar to reflect Gene's classic 70's porn stashe. 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Bigbrog said:

For the nuanced conversation...so we...or rather you two, are saying it's okay for people to break the law and then be rewarded for it over people who are trying to do it the right way and have been waiting in line and paying the money??

Sneaking over the border to do a shit job to feed your family isn't really much of a crime is it, especially since the REAL criminals are the shady employers hiring illegal labor (and who rarely get punished) ? Sneaking over the border to do work to feed one's family seems like about as much of a crime, to me, as Jean Valjean stealing a loaf of bread to feed his sister's starving children.  At least the illegal aliens offer their cheap labor (which American farmers are missing!) while taking practically nothing from the US "kitty" (except for lifesaving emergency care, care which cost a tiny fraction of the money in the US budget), unlike the native US citizen welfare queens who contribute exactly jack shit and take EVERYTHING from the kitty: healthcare, SNAP, etc. Frankly, I'd rather KEEP the illegals and ship all the welfare queens to Mexico. We'd definitely come out on top in that deal but some US states, like Oklahoma, would practically be depopulated!! 

So...I'm curious....would you let your family starve if you could steal to keep them alive, or sneak over a border to make money to feed them? Would you consider yourself a hardened criminal for doing so? 

Edited by NM1965
Posted
4 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

Sneaking over the border to do a shit job to feed your family isn't really much of a crime is it, especially since the REAL criminals are the shady employers hiring illegal labor (and who rarely get punished) ? Sneaking over the border to do work to feed one's family seems like about as much of a crime, to me, as Jean Valjean stealing a loaf of bread to feed his sister's starving children.  At least the illegal aliens offer their cheap labor (which American farmers are missing!) while taking practically nothing from the US "kitty" (except for lifesaving emergency care, care which cost a tiny fraction of the money in the US budget), unlike the native US citizen welfare queens who contribute exactly jack shit and take EVERYTHING from the kitty: healthcare, SNAP, etc. Frankly, I'd rather KEEP the illegals and ship all the welfare queens to Mexico. We'd definitely come out on top in that deal but some US states, like Oklahoma, would practically be depopulated!! 

So...I'm curious....would you let your family starve if you could steal to keep them alive, or sneak over a border to make money to feed them? Would you consider yourself a hardened criminal for doing so? 

Well I think we can agree on the part of getting rid of those who abuse our welfare systems.  As to those who just innocently sneak over the boarder (love how it is being described now..LOL), it is an absolute drain on our society and our resources, that is what I don't like.  And guess what, that is okay I don't like it (noticed I didn't say I didn't like them, but rather the act).  I also value that we are a sovereign nation with boarders, laws, and freedom.  I feel if we don't have that it erodes us as a country and quite frankly, we would then no longer be a country.  All the effort and money should be put towards having safe and secure boarder AND fixing the process for bringing in legal immigrants (notice I am all for immigrants and immigration). 

As for the part of the farmers not having workers to do the work, I don't listen to that as it is just a talking point with no validity.  Fields are not going to go unworked...you think farmers are going to be like, well, no illegals to work the fields so I am just going to let everything rot and going to go bankrupt??  Seriously??  Come on man.

Posted
13 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

Sneaking over the border to do a shit job to feed your family isn't really much of a crime is it, especially since the REAL criminals are the shady employers hiring illegal labor (and who rarely get punished) ? Sneaking over the border to do work to feed one's family seems like about as much of a crime, to me, as Jean Valjean stealing a loaf of bread to feed his sister's starving children.  At least the illegal aliens offer their cheap labor (which American farmers are missing!) while taking practically nothing from the US "kitty" (except for lifesaving emergency care, care which cost a tiny fraction of the money in the US budget), unlike the native US citizen welfare queens who contribute exactly jack shit and take EVERYTHING from the kitty: healthcare, SNAP, etc. Frankly, I'd rather KEEP the illegals and ship all the welfare queens to Mexico. We'd definitely come out on top in that deal but some US states, like Oklahoma, would practically be depopulated!! 

So...I'm curious....would you let your family starve if you could steal to keep them alive, or sneak over a border to make money to feed them? Would you consider yourself a hardened criminal for doing so? 

if I had to maybe I would. But I would know I was unlawful or I wouldn't be sneaking.

Posted
1 minute ago, Bigbrog said:

Well I think we can agree on the part of getting rid of those who abuse our welfare systems.  As to those who just innocently sneak over the boarder (love how it is being described now..LOL), it is an absolute drain on our society and our resources, that is what I don't like.  And guess what, that is okay I don't like it (noticed I didn't say I didn't like them, but rather the act).  I also value that we are a sovereign nation with boarders, laws, and freedom.  I feel if we don't have that it erodes us as a country and quite frankly, we would then no longer be a country.  All the effort and money should be put towards having safe and secure boarder AND fixing the process for bringing in legal immigrants (notice I am all for immigrants and immigration). 

As for the part of the farmers not having workers to do the work, I don't listen to that as it is just a talking point with no validity.  Fields are not going to go unworked...you think farmers are going to be like, well, no illegals to work the fields so I am just going to let everything rot and going to go bankrupt??  Seriously??  Come on man.

As a matter of fact fields ARE going unworked, but let's skip that entirely. I'm curious as to what "resources drain" the immigrants put on our society. Tell me what you think those drained resources are? 

Posted
Just now, NM1965 said:

As a matter of fact fields ARE going unworked, but let's skip that entirely. I'm curious as to what "resources drain" the immigrants put on our society. Tell me what you think those drained resources are? 

Customs and Border Patrol and other law enforcement, Emergency Services, education, housing, some social programs, etc.

Posted (edited)
18 minutes ago, Bigbrog said:

Customs and Border Patrol and other law enforcement, Emergency Services, education, housing, some social programs, etc.

First off, we'd have customs, border patrol and Emergency services even without illegal immigration. Secondly, illegal aliens get NO housing assistance from the Feds and NO "social program" money from the Fed's either. Illegals don't qualify for welfare or Social Security. Their kids may attend US public schools, but those schools and teachers are already paid for. The only expense incurred by illegal aliens is that lifesaving emergency room care cannot be refused. That's literally state law in, I think, ALL states. Plus the bill is chump change, at least compared to the huge tax cuts we just gave to people like Elon Musk (AGAIN!). Depending on who you believe the bill is $3.9 billion a year, or $9.1 billion a year if you believe the lies of the Trump White House. Even at the $9.1 billion price tag, that still works out to slightly more than 1% of the federal budget, at the more believable $3.9 billion figure it's less than 0.5%. They sure try to make out that it's bankrupting the USA, and not the massive multi- trillion tax giveaways to the 1% and corporations, don't they? 

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/us-taxpayers-pay-bill-illegal-111500957.html

 

Edited by NM1965
Posted
6 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

Their kids may attend US public schools, but those schools and teachers are already paid ...

 

Not exactly.  If the student to teacher ratio is already at max and you add 5 more illegals to the class then what do you do?

.

Posted (edited)
14 minutes ago, ionel said:

Not exactly.  If the student to teacher ratio is already at max and you add 5 more illegals to the class then what do you do?

@NM1965

Chicago public schools get funding … tax payer funding … for each kid that attends school.  I think it’s around ~$5100 per kid.    Some are reporting that up to 20,000 new illegal Aliens enrolled in cps in the last few years.  

illegals can also get supplemental funds …. Tax payer funds …. For free lunches, special education, English language teachers.

Tax payers shouldn’t pay for any of that.  

Edited by Caveira
Posted
6 minutes ago, ionel said:

Not exactly.  If the student to teacher ratio is already at max and you add 5 more illegals to the class then what do you do?

Well if my childhood in Oklahoma was any indicator, they'd just move more chairs and desks into the room. Problem solved. 

Posted
5 hours ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Mass amnesty should not be given to any group of illegal aliens.
Be able to speak for five minutes in English about what they can do for the country and not what the country can do for them. Why is this necessary?  This is a sip test on language (fluency, integration), mindset (contributor, not consumer), values (gratitude, self-reliance, integration, patriotism) that go beyond the immeasurables regarding social trust and political polarization.   How will all these benefit the country? 
 
They should all leave on their own. Come back following the law.   Pretty simple.How does mass amnesty hurt the country? If you can't demonstrate a harm then by process of elimination it is beneficial and should therefore be carried out. 

Ethnic diversity damages social trust amongst local neighbors.  In this setting, people hunker down and lose trust in people that differ and in people that share common backgrounds. - https://cis.org/Wahala/Immigration-and-Social-Trust

Speaking English well allows for communication, increases wages, impacts social services, and accelerates integration into our English primary culture.  Without clear communication, there is conflict and bad outcomes (health, wealth, community, etc.).

America exists to serve its citizens and illegal aliens are not its people!

America grants rights, protections, and opportunities.  In return it has historically expected loyalty, effort, and contribution.  It is the social contract of American citizenship.

The burden of proof falls on you as the amnesty advocate because mass amnesty is a radical departure from the constitutional status quo.

Posted
1 hour ago, Bigbrog said:

So I see based on what you wrote you read half of the full picture and just stuck with that as your opinion, you failed to keep reading or chose to not believe it or just blatantly disregard it.  You left out education and emergency services costs, the fact that they have a much lower income which means their contribution doesn't cover their per capita cost, left out specific studies such as the Heritage Foundations study.  There is actually no consensus on what is true.  Based on what I know, there is a cost, and that is cost we shouldn't be paying for as tax payers.

Thank you for having this conversation. Btw. 
 

Rather than assuming my motivation you can just include the information the informed your opinion. What about your post did I not read or respond to? 
 
The Heritage Foundation is incredibly conservative and I believe, and correct me if I'm wrong, the education cost included in that study includes the cost to publicly fund the education of children(US citizens) of undocumented immigrants so as to pad the stats. 
 
Undocumented immigrants pay upwards of $100B in taxes. If I'm wrong correct me. They use, less than that in social services, emergency services and the like. If the number of $ contributed is bigger than the $ used then immigration is a benefit. Full stop. 
 
You must refute that point to have any ground to stand on. 
 
If your argument is, 'we don't have accurate data to determine how much they actually contribute.' Then you cannot hold a stance that immigration even law abiding albeit undocumented immigrants are negative across the board. 
 
If you don't know the number, then find the number. 
 
 
How much do undocumented immigrants contribute in taxes based on the Heritage Foundation study? 
How often in the Heritage Foundation report does a paragraph begin with, 'Many (fill in the blank) believe'? 
This whole thing reeks of bias and deception. Its shameful. But its well funded and a means to an end. 
Posted
5 minutes ago, jross said:

Ethnic diversity damages social trust amongst local neighbors.  In this setting, people hunker down and lose trust in people that differ and in people that share common backgrounds. - https://cis.org/Wahala/Immigration-and-Social-Trust

Speaking English well allows for communication, increases wages, impacts social services, and accelerates integration into our English primary culture.  Without clear communication, there is conflict and bad outcomes (health, wealth, community, etc.).

America exists to serve its citizens and illegal aliens are not its people!

America grants rights, protections, and opportunities.  In return it has historically expected loyalty, effort, and contribution.  It is the social contract of American citizenship.

The burden of proof falls on you as the amnesty advocate because mass amnesty is a radical departure from the constitutional status quo.

Reagan did it. Did the country explode? Nope. 

Posted
7 minutes ago, Caveira said:

Chicago public schools get funding … tax payer funding … for each kid that attends school.  I think it’s around ~$5100 per kid.    Some are reporting that up to 20,000 new illegal Aliens enrolled in cps in the last few years.  

illegals can also get supplemental funds …. Tax payer funds …. For free lunches, special education, English language teachers.

Tax payers shouldn’t pay for any of that.  

Yes they should drastically increase the education budget. Pay teachers more then you’ll have to beat them away with a stick. Problem solved. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

I lost patience 😢😢    I thought this is subtle conversation not specific black and white. Don't you want to talk nuanced ideology.  I guess your just unserious and trolling  

a minority with its' own viewpoint exacerbating a previously adhered to written protocol. why because liberals are creating new laws for such issues

harmony and prosperity

Haha

Posted
2 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

Yes they should drastically increase the education budget. Pay teachers more then you’ll have to beat them away with a stick. Problem solved. 

They’ve been increasing the funding for schools since the 70s and grades haven’t gone up. Boss.   Tossing $$ at everything isn’t the solution.   Teachers do fine.   Their pensions are bankrupting cities.  They get summers off.   It’s one of the kushiest jobs out there.  

Posted (edited)
39 minutes ago, Caveira said:

Chicago public schools get funding … tax payer funding … for each kid that attends school.  I think it’s around ~$5100 per kid.    Some are reporting that up to 20,000 new illegal Aliens enrolled in cps in the last few years.  

illegals can also get supplemental funds …. Tax payer funds …. For free lunches, special education, English language teachers.

Tax payers shouldn’t pay for any of that.  

A whopping $5k per kid? 20,000 new illegal kids each year? Wow, that works out to a whole whopping $100 million a year. It sounds like a lot, but that's chump change. Elon Musk's tax breaks from this year alone could cover much, if not most, of that. Chicago's public schools cost $9.4 billion last year, so that $100 million is just a touch over 1% of the budget. That $100 million, if equally distributed among all Americans, cost you 30 cents last year!! Not exactly bank-breaking, huh? 

For the record I disagree with you. TAX PAYERS SHOULD PAY FOR THAT IN PARTICULAR. Why? Because those kids will be working in the USA someday, too. For the relatively cheap price, it's a good investment for their future employers in the USA. 

 

Edited by NM1965
Posted

Reagan's 80's amnesty increased illegal immigration, fraud, chain immigration, education/health costs, the legal immigration approval backlog, welfare use, and more.  Native citizens had no job protection.  Within a few years, government trust significantly reduced in high-immigration states.  "Immigrants are a burden" mentality increased in California and America.

Views from 2015 - https://www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2015/09/28/chapter-4-u-s-public-has-mixed-views-of-immigrants-and-immigration

  • Positive
    • 49% say immigrants are making food, music, and the arts better
    • 70% say immigrants are coming for economic opportunity and 10% for home conflict
  • Negative
    • Top word comes to mind for immigrant - "Illegal"
    • 66% say immigrants are not assimilating to the American way of life
    • 59% say immigrants do not learn English in a reasonable amount of time
    • 50% say immigrants are making crime and the economy worse
    • 41% say immigrants are making schools worse
    • 36% say immigrants are making job opportunities worse for citizens
    • 34% say immigrants are making social and moral values worse

83% say immigration levels should remain the same (34%) or decreased (49%)

Posted
19 minutes ago, Caveira said:

They’ve been increasing the funding for schools since the 70s and grades haven’t gone up. Boss.   Tossing $$ at everything isn’t the solution.   Teachers do fine.   Their pensions are bankrupting cities.  They get summers off.   It’s one of the kushiest jobs out there.  

Go to Oklahoma and make a living on a teacher's wage. 

I DOUBLE DOG DARE YOU. 

Posted
1 minute ago, jross said:

Reagan's 80's amnesty increased illegal immigration, fraud, chain immigration, education/health costs, the legal immigration approval backlog, welfare use, and more.  Native citizens had no job protection.  Within a few years, government trust significantly reduced in high-immigration states.  "Immigrants are a burden" mentality increased in California and America.

Views from 2015 - https://www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2015/09/28/chapter-4-u-s-public-has-mixed-views-of-immigrants-and-immigration

  • Positive
    • 49% say immigrants are making food, music, and the arts better
    • 70% say immigrants are coming for economic opportunity and 10% for home conflict
  • Negative
    • Top word comes to mind for immigrant - "Illegal"
    • 66% say immigrants are not assimilating to the American way of life
    • 59% say immigrants do not learn English in a reasonable amount of time
    • 50% say immigrants are making crime and the economy worse
    • 41% say immigrants are making schools worse
    • 36% say immigrants are making job opportunities worse for citizens
    • 34% say immigrants are making social and moral values worse

83% say immigration levels should remain the same (34%) or decreased (49%)

People's opinions don't carry the same weight as facts. For example, "50% say immigrants are making crime and the economy worse", yet illegal aliens have a lower crime rate than native Americans. It tracks, they don't want to bring attention to themselves. Plus it can't be discounted that a lot of people replying may well have just been plain old bigots. 

Posted
40 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

Well if my childhood in Oklahoma was any indicator, they'd just move more chairs and desks into the room. Problem solved. 

You're heard of teacher's union correct?  Didn't have that back in my day either.  Its a new world.  

.

Posted
4 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

Go to Oklahoma and make a living on a teacher's wage. 

I DOUBLE DOG DARE YOU. 

Avg. Oklahoma Teacher Salary: $55K

In order to maintain your current Oklahoma City standard of living ($55K) in San Francisco, you would need $105K.

Avg. California Teacher Salary: $95K

So the money goes further in OK than CA?  

Whelp?  Not good either way but the cost of living is much higher in some states than LCOL Oklahoma.

Posted
23 hours ago, jross said:

Mass amnesty should not be given to any group of illegal aliens.

Be able to speak for five minutes in English about what they can do for the country and not what the country can do for them.  This is a sip test on language (fluency, integration), mindset (contributor, not consumer), values (gratitude, self-reliance, integration, patriotism) that go beyond the immeasurables regarding social trust and political polarization.   

100 percent. Full Stop!!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...