Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

With no or limited criminal record should be given mass amnesty. It would benefit our country more than deporting people like ICE is doing today. 

People on the wait list are allowed in. 

Future immigrants can more easily enter and exit, seasonally if they wish, or obtain full citizenship ship. 
 

Pros and cons?

  • Replies 104
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Mass amnesty should not be given to any group of illegal aliens.

Be able to speak for five minutes in English about what they can do for the country and not what the country can do for them.  This is a sip test on language (fluency, integration), mindset (contributor, not consumer), values (gratitude, self-reliance, integration, patriotism) that go beyond the immeasurables regarding social trust and political polarization.   

Posted

Mass amnesty should not be given to any group of illegal aliens.
Be able to speak for five minutes in English about what they can do for the country and not what the country can do for them. Why is this necessary?  This is a sip test on language (fluency, integration), mindset (contributor, not consumer), values (gratitude, self-reliance, integration, patriotism) that go beyond the immeasurables regarding social trust and political polarization.   How will all these benefit the country? 
 
They should all leave on their own. Come back following the law.   Pretty simple.How does mass amnesty hurt the country? If you can't demonstrate a harm then by process of elimination it is beneficial and should therefore be carried out. 
Posted

why shouldn't it be necessary? what are they coming here for? themselves?

there once was a sane democrat who said: ask not.

mass amnesty encourages more. we already tried this with biden.

learning is fun.

Posted

If the illegal immigrants are here working for a living and have no criminal record I'm good with not only extending amnesty, but also offering citizenship (depending on skills, education, ability to function in an English dominated society, etc). God knows Okies aren't going to drag their fat, lazy asses out in the fields to pick crops for less than minimum wage (or even $15 an hour, let's be honest).  

For the record I think it's EMPLOYERS that should pay draconian penalties for using illegal labor, and the employers barely ever get even a slap on the wrist. But the politicians don't want to do anything to THEM, those are campaign contributors. 

 

Posted
4 hours ago, NM1965 said:

If the illegal immigrants are here working for a living and have no criminal record I'm good with not only extending amnesty, but also offering citizenship (depending on skills, education, ability to function in an English dominated society, etc). God knows Okies aren't going to drag their fat, lazy asses out in the fields to pick crops for less than minimum wage (or even $15 an hour, let's be honest).  

For the record I think it's EMPLOYERS that should pay draconian penalties for using illegal labor, and the employers barely ever get even a slap on the wrist. But the politicians don't want to do anything to THEM, those are campaign contributors. 

 

(Fire emoji)

Posted

For the nuanced conversation...so we...or rather you two, are saying it's okay for people to break the law and then be rewarded for it over people who are trying to do it the right way and have been waiting in line and paying the money??

Posted

And to follow up on that, I am for having a program for those that have been here contributing to our society and are a positive addition to our society to have to go through an abbreviated process, but not cut in line before those that have been trying to do it the right way, or rather doing it according to our current laws and policies.

Posted
5 hours ago, Scouts Honor said:

why shouldn't it be necessary? what are they coming here for? themselves?

there once was a sane democrat who said: ask not.

mass amnesty encourages more. we already tried this with biden.

learning is fun.

1. So you don’t have a reason. Got it. So it’s not necessary. 
2. They are moving to a country and by their very presence it is good. If you disagree, provide evidence that immigration is not beneficial to the USA. 

3a. Does more scare you? If so, why? If not, tell us why more(in the situation of adequately vetting immigrants) is bad?

3b. Did Biden offer mass amnesty? If not, then it’s not relevant. 
 

4. Are you familiar with Title 42? Can you give a quick explanation of who signed it and what it did and when it was set to lapse and why? 

Posted
5 hours ago, Scouts Honor said:

why shouldn't it be necessary? what are they coming here for? themselves?

there once was a sane democrat who said: ask not.

mass amnesty encourages more. we already tried this with biden.

learning is fun.

Ronald Reagan gave amnesty to 15 million illegal aliens. 

Posted
19 minutes ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

It seems being yourself is put above supporting harmony in a group.

Harmony is overrated. We need stress to evolve. 

Posted
5 minutes ago, Bigbrog said:

For the nuanced conversation...so we...or rather you two, are saying it's okay for people to break the law and then be rewarded for it over people who are trying to do it the right way and have been waiting in line and paying the money??

I understand your way of thinking about it. 
However, if they are someone that would, theoretically, qualify for amnesty. They have not committed a violent or bad crime. Jay walking or the like, I hope you would agree, is not an offense worthy of deportation. This person has committed a victimless crime. Someone without a social security number cannot qualify for enough assistance to completely live on government money. So likely as not they are paying more in taxes than they are taking. Making them a net benefit. Also, it makes them candidates for abuse by employers who prey on undocumented immigrants specifically because they don't have much recourse. Giving them power to not be victimized will result in more and better employment options. Which would help raise them to the point of not needing government assistance of any kind. 

Bad people don't/won't qualify and could be caught and deported. 
 
People waiting in line. Firstly, are not harmed by others cutting in this particular line. Sure they may be salty about it. But its not slowing the process down. Second, why does the process take so long? Vetting? This can be done almost instantly now. If not, we should help the governments update their infrastructure so that it can be done quicker. We make money from immigrants. Its in our best interest to get them in faster and with more credible information. Investing in this process will return a profit every time. Thirdly, why does it cost any money? It shouldn't. Again, we make money from the right people coming here. Get them in quicker and cheaper so that more people can do it. At that point we can start being more critical of their qualifications and turn people away unless they want to pay. 
 
Your second comment. 
Right?! Get the productive people that work and WANT to be here rolled into the system so they, we, and everyone can start benefiting from their work. Its not complicated. 
Posted (edited)

@ThreePointTakedownWell in my opinion those things you describe are not a "victimless" crime.  People being here illegally to begin with are costing resources that otherwise should be going towards us citizens...you can say jay walking is "victimless' however, it does take resources to process someone who has done that...and it is a crime...so that's two crimes that illegal person has now committed.  Again, I don't see a need to reward that person for that, but you obviously do which is your perogative.

As for "fixing the system", I don't think you will find anyone on here that disagrees with you that it needs to be fixed.  Where the disagreement happens is probably with the what and the how.  It should be easy and painless as possible.

Edited by Bigbrog
Posted
7 minutes ago, Bigbrog said:

@ThreePointTakedownWell in my opinion those things you describe are not a "victimless" crime.  People being here illegally to begin with are costing resources that otherwise should be going towards us citizens...you can say jay walking is "victimless' however, it does take resources to process someone who has done that...and it is a crime...so that's two crimes that illegal person has now committed.  Again, I don't see a need to reward that person for that, but you obviously do which is your perogative.

As for "fixing the system", I don't think you will find anyone on here that disagrees with you that it needs to be fixed.  Where the disagreement happens is probably with the what and the how.  It should be easy and painless as possible.

If your basis to say that undocumented immigrants being here is not a victimless crime, because they use resources that could/should be used to benefit citizens. I will remind you that undocumented immigrants pay into taxes MORE than they take. 
 
So they do help to provide for US citizens and US interests more so than could be if they weren't here. 
 
Simply, your point does not logically follow. 
 
Undocumented immigrants = more money for US taxes than if they weren't here = victimless
Posted
14 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

(Losing patience emoji)

which individual is getting priority and why?

what’s the common goal? 

I lost patience 😢😢    I thought this is subtle conversation not specific black and white. Don't you want to talk nuanced ideology.  I guess your just unserious and trolling  

a minority with its' own viewpoint exacerbating a previously adhered to written protocol. why because liberals are creating new laws for such issues

harmony and prosperity

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...