Jump to content

Should Amit Elor wrestle in college?

Jimmy Cinnabon

By Jimmy Cinnabon
in College Wrestling

 Share

Recommended Posts

billyhoyle NCAA All-American

billyhoyle

Posted
Posted (edited)
  On 8/7/2024 at 7:52 PM, CHROMEBIRD said:

I figured with her BJJ background and ties to Sara McMann she'd go the Cejudo route after Paris. Probably more upside in terms of revenue opportunities and having a next big challenge to tackle. Hope I'm wrong, though. I wanna see Elor around for a few more cycles, at least.

Expand  

Going to MMA would be unwise.  Along with getting punched in the face, it's not as if women's MMA is hugely profitable in the days since Ronda Rousey. She would likely be the marquee wrestler competing in 2028 and to profit greatly from that (like JB did in 2016). 

Edited by billyhoyle
bnwtwg Big Brain

bnwtwg

Posted
Posted
  On 8/7/2024 at 10:59 PM, billyhoyle said:

Going to MMA would be unwise.  Along with getting punched in the face, it's not as if women's MMA is hugely profitable in the days since Ronda Rousey. She would likely be the marquee wrestler competing in 2028 and to profit greatly from that (like JB did in 2016). 

Expand  

Don't you put that Rio voodoo on Elor!

  • Bob 1

i am an idiot on the internet

CHROMEBIRD Big Brain

CHROMEBIRD

Posted
Posted
  On 8/7/2024 at 10:59 PM, billyhoyle said:

Going to MMA would be unwise.  Along with getting punched in the face, it's not as if women's MMA is hugely profitable in the days since Ronda Rousey. She would likely be the marquee wrestler competing in 2028 and to profit greatly from that (like JB did in 2016). 

Expand  

No argument here, I'd much rather see her rack up wrestling hardware. Rhonda Rousey has said that MMA can be a good stepping stone, not career destination, for women to get into the entertainment industry but I can't really think of many former MMA women who are now actresses or broadcasters. (I also don't follow MMA closely so idk)

1032004 Big Brain

1032004

Posted
Posted
  On 8/7/2024 at 1:39 PM, Wrestleknownothing said:

I am not sure if Iowa would the ones. They are already the prohibitive favorite to win the title every year. Perhaps an underdog with a rich, interested alum would step up. But I know so little about women's college wrestling that I have no idea who that would or could be.

Expand  

Sounds like a good opportunity for Penn State to start a women’s team 🙂

1032004 Big Brain

1032004

Posted
Posted
  On 8/7/2024 at 5:48 PM, CHROMEBIRD said:

They mentioned on the OTA broadcast that she's currently enrolled at Diablo Valley JC and wants to stay in the Bay Area. Would love to see Elor transfer to Stanford and get things going there. Maybe pull Adeline back over. It won't happen with all the conference realignment and other BS the athletic dept is dealing with, but one can dream.

Expand  

Interesting.  I know Ayres is a big proponent of women’s wrestling, so seems like not an impossibility.

GreenandGold Varsity

GreenandGold

Posted
Posted
  On 8/7/2024 at 9:53 PM, juniorvarsity said:

Who was Amit Elor coaches by in 2022. She dogged on that training situation in a recent Flo article. Wasn't it that guy who used to coach Pico?

Expand  

Yes, Valentin. He used to also coach Helen and has coached Frank Chamizo recently at NYAC. I was glad to see Elor dumped him, he appears to be in it for the wrong reasons.

juniorvarsity State Champion

juniorvarsity

Posted
Posted
  On 8/14/2024 at 6:25 PM, GreenandGold said:

Yes, Valentin. He used to also coach Helen and has coached Frank Chamizo recently at NYAC. I was glad to see Elor dumped him, he appears to be in it for the wrong reasons.

Expand  

She publicly dumped on him. He appears to be associated with some very good wrestlers. Sometimes it is personalities colliding, but to diminish a world champs skill and attribute it to strength to the point that the wrestler loses confidence is not good coaching/mentoring. If it works, it works.

There are skills, physical attributes, and tactics. They can all be pieces together in infinite ways. 

  • Brain 1
WrestlingRash State Champion

WrestlingRash

Posted
Posted
  On 8/19/2024 at 8:50 PM, FanOfPurdueWrestling said:

Her on the right program could transcend wrestling and grow her image and future earnings much more than “just” 3 world titles and an Olympic title in that same time. She could also do college and international. 
 

Iowa women’s wrestling with Amit would be a crazy draw. 

Expand  

no women's wrestler is a crazy draw. sorry to break it to you. 

WrestlingRash State Champion

WrestlingRash

Posted
Posted
  On 8/7/2024 at 10:59 PM, billyhoyle said:

Going to MMA would be unwise.  Along with getting punched in the face, it's not as if women's MMA is hugely profitable in the days since Ronda Rousey. She would likely be the marquee wrestler competing in 2028 and to profit greatly from that (like JB did in 2016). 

Expand  

MMA is the pinnacle of combat sports and I would wager good money she makes her way over there in the near future. Women's MMA is actually quite profitable. Here's an article about Kayla Harrison, a Judo Olympic gold medalist and her career earnings for fighting. She was pulling in 1M per year with PFL. 

 

https://www.essentiallysports.com/ufc-mma-news-kayla-harrison-s-career-earnings-how-much-did-the-ufc-star-earn-at-pfl/

  • Bob 1
1032004 Big Brain

1032004

Posted
Posted
  On 8/19/2024 at 8:50 PM, FanOfPurdueWrestling said:

Her on the right program could transcend wrestling and grow her image and future earnings much more than “just” 3 world titles and an Olympic title in that same time. She could also do college and international. 
 

Iowa women’s wrestling with Amit would be a crazy draw. 

Expand  

I assume by “right program” you mean one that doesn’t exist yet?  Iowa is the only one people currently care about and considering they already have Blades coming I’m not sure adding Elor would really “transcend wrestling.”

billyhoyle NCAA All-American

billyhoyle

Posted
Posted
  On 8/20/2024 at 1:40 AM, WrestlingRash said:

MMA is the pinnacle of combat sports and I would wager good money she makes her way over there in the near future. Women's MMA is actually quite profitable. Here's an article about Kayla Harrison, a Judo Olympic gold medalist and her career earnings for fighting. She was pulling in 1M per year with PFL. 

 

https://www.essentiallysports.com/ufc-mma-news-kayla-harrison-s-career-earnings-how-much-did-the-ufc-star-earn-at-pfl/

Expand  

MMA is not the pinnacle of combat sports, at least not the MMA that exists today in UFC and is modeled more after WWE than actual sport. 

  • Confused 2
WrestlingRash State Champion

WrestlingRash

Posted
Posted
  On 8/20/2024 at 3:00 AM, billyhoyle said:

MMA is not the pinnacle of combat sports, at least not the MMA that exists today in UFC and is modeled more after WWE than actual sport. 

Expand  

Okay, then what is? They have the most eyeballs on their events. They have replaced boxing in the culture and that is a good thing. Wrestlers dominate. Its accurate as to who the best fighter really is. 

  • Bob 1
  • Fire 1
billyhoyle NCAA All-American

billyhoyle

Posted
Posted (edited)
  On 8/21/2024 at 8:15 PM, WrestlingRash said:

Okay, then what is? They have the most eyeballs on their events. They have replaced boxing in the culture and that is a good thing. Wrestlers dominate. Its accurate as to who the best fighter really is. 

Expand  

The idea that MMA is accurate as to "who the best fighter really is" is nonsense. There are tons of arbitrary rules in MMA, just like there are in boxing, kickboxing, and slapfighting. Not to mention that the way UFC is set up in pay and how they advance contenders incentivizes their "fighters" to put on a show ahead of anything else. Fight with a boring, yet effective style? Good luck advancing in the sport.  Fight like an entertaining idiot and you will get an easy path to a title shot. Obviously, I'm not criticizing that approach from a business standpoint, but the fact that UFC was purchased by WWE is not a coincidence. You are watching a show, not a combat sport that is any more legitimate than any of the others.

 

As to what the pinnacle of combat sports is...The answer is obviously boxing in the 70s. But even MMA 15-20 years ago was 10X the product that UFC is today. 

 

Edited by billyhoyle
Bigbrog Big Brain

Bigbrog

Posted
Posted
  On 8/22/2024 at 6:33 AM, billyhoyle said:

The idea that MMA is accurate as to "who the best fighter really is" is nonsense. There are tons of arbitrary rules in MMA, just like there are in boxing, kickboxing, and slapfighting. Not to mention that the way UFC is set up in pay and how they advance contenders incentivizes their "fighters" to put on a show ahead of anything else. Fight with a boring, yet effective style? Good luck advancing in the sport.  Fight like an entertaining idiot and you will get an easy path to a title shot. Obviously, I'm not criticizing that approach from a business standpoint, but the fact that UFC was purchased by WWE is not a coincidence. You are watching a show, not a combat sport that is any more legitimate than any of the others.

 

As to what the pinnacle of combat sports is...The answer is obviously boxing in the 70s. But even MMA 15-20 years ago was 10X the product that UFC is today. 

 

Expand  

Terrible take

  • Bob 1
  • Fire 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...