I'm going to take a beating here but oh well.
1) Bruce
2)Smith
3) Snyder
4) JB
one of the two words in 'all-time' is 'time'. Bruce has as many olympic golds as anyone, and twice as many medals as john smith. I want to give more to JB for ten medals and competing in the minimal olympic weight/multi-ov era, but I can't put a guy with olympic gold and teched out of the olympics over three guys in two olympic finals and a hand full of gold medals. Yes one of Bruce's came in '84, but his longevity and medaling over and over and over again wins it for me. If Snyder wins Paris he jumps to 1 for me. Have to factor in Sadulaev.
5) David Taylor
6) Kyle Dake
7) Dave Schultz
8-Lee Kemp (I'm not making Lee pay for Carter's mistakes)
9)Kenny Monday
10) Chris Tayor.....come on, the guy medaled in FS, losing only to Medved on a call that got the ref dismissed from wrestling permanently...while also competing in Greco!!