You said the amount was paid. Which I’d be confident in interpreting means the wrestler actually transferred.
There are 2 wrestlers who meet the criteria you listed (finalist last year that transferred for their final season of eligibility). Both of them attended the same school. And you wouldn’t even need the “not at PSU or Iowa” qualifier unless you wanted to nitpick and say “I only said the amount was for one season, not that they only had one year left.” But the only other transfers to make the finals were Mesenbrink and Kerk.