Actually your source has more data available, with the most recent (2023) leaning red:
https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/04/09/partisanship-in-rural-suburban-and-urban-communities/
But according to that it’s pretty even, although I’d still bet it’s skewed by a few bigger metros where the suburbs do lean blue, but many don’t.
Also to your earlier point about farmers or whatever, there is a middle ground between suburban and rural, towns that are like an hour or so from bigger cities, and the further from the city you get the more red they generally lean. If I had to guess I’d bet many top wrestlers are from exurban areas like that. For example looking at this year’s champs based on the hometown listed on their roster, I would probably only count one as being from a rural area.
Robinson: Chicago (urban)
Byrd: Cincinnati (urban/maybe suburban)
Mendez: Crown Point, IN (suburban/maybe exurban depending on your definition)
Lovett: Post Falls, ID (suburban/maybe exurban depending on your definition)
Taylor: Millard, NE (suburban)
Mesenbrink: Hartland, WI (suburban)
Hamiti: Joliet, IL (exurban)
Starocci: Erie, PA (urban)
Buchanan: Loyal, WI (rural)
Hendrickson: Newton, KS (exurban)