Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I was bored last night and was wondering if I could put together a roster I would pay to see, and that was loaded with some just bad arse dudes. This would be my line-up.

125 pounds: Tom Brands
133 pounds: Joey Gilbert
141 pounds: Dan Gable
149 pounds: Tim Krieger
157 pounds: Dave Schulz
165 pounds: Royce Alger
174 pounds: Chuck Jean
184 pounds: Mark Schultz
197 pounds: Eric Voelker
285 pounds: Lou Banach 

That’s to keep your whining ass shut. You want off this ranch, you got it. I’ll drive your ass to the train station myself.

Posted (edited)
24 minutes ago, Viratas said:

I was bored last night and was wondering if I could put together a roster I would pay to see, and that was loaded with some just bad arse dudes. This would be my line-up.

125 pounds: Tom Brands
133 pounds: Joey Gilbert
141 pounds: Dan Gable
149 pounds: Tim Krieger
157 pounds: Dave Schulz
165 pounds: Royce Alger
174 pounds: Chuck Jean
184 pounds: Mark Schultz
197 pounds: Eric Voelker
285 pounds: Lou Banach 

Tom Brands would have been a 133lber in today's weigh-in rules.

Joey Gilbert would have been a 141lber in today's weigh-in rules.

Dan Gable is the right pick at 141lbs.

Tim Krieger would have been 157lbs with today's rules.

Dave Schultz as a 150lb Frosh was not the badass he grew in to at 158/167lbs.  I might put him at the 174lbs for today's weigh-in rules (no offense Chuck).

I am okay with Rocye Alger at 165lbs.  I know he went up to 177lbs his senior season, but I knew him pretty well.  He wasn't cutting weight that year, which tells me 165lbs is fine.

Chuck Jean (sorry, not sorry) - not the BA Schultz was.

Mark Schultz is the guy at 184lbs.

I would go with Ed Banach at 197lbs, myself.  I get Eric Voelker, but Ed was as badass as they come.

285lbs actually has a lot of badasses.  Because Ed's here, I would be okay with Lou, as well.  Him Brucey or Neal would be okay for me.

So here is my actual list, if I would have done it:

125 - Terry Brands
133 - Tom Brands
141 - Dan Gable
149 - Brent Metcalf
157 - Lincoln McIlravy
165 - Dan Hodge
174 - Dave Schultz
184 - Mark Schultz
197 - Ed Banach
285 - Lou Banach

I almost went Sam Henson at 125lbs.  Hodge was at 177lbs, but because of his era, I think he would have been 165lbs in today's world.  I could have seen Terry at 133 and Tom at 141 - that makes it interesting between him and Gable, with Henson at 125lbs.

Imagine that room.  Nobody is making it to February with all their appendages. 

Edited by nhs67

"I know actually nothing.  It isn't even conjecture at this point." - me

 

 

Posted

 

23 minutes ago, Viratas said:

 This would be my line-up.

125 pounds: Tom Brands
133 pounds: Joey Gilbert
141 pounds: Dan Gable
149 pounds: Tim Krieger
157 pounds: Dave Schulz
165 pounds: Royce Alger
174 pounds: Chuck Jean
184 pounds: Mark Schultz
197 pounds: Eric Voelker
285 pounds: Lou Banach 

Love seeing Alger in there. Randleman and Coleman could be additions...

.

Posted
8 minutes ago, nhs67 said:

Tom Brands would have been a 133lber in today's weigh-in rules.

Joey Gilbert would have been a 141lber in today's weigh-in rules.

Dan Gable is the right pick at 141lbs.

Tim Krieger would have been 157lbs with today's rules.

Dave Schultz as a 150lb Frosh was not the badass he grew in to at 158/167lbs.  I might put him at the 174lbs for today's weigh-in rules (no offense Chuck).

I am okay with Rocye Alger at 165lbs.  I know he went up to 177lbs his senior season, but I knew him pretty well.  He wasn't cutting weight that year, which tells me 165lbs is fine.

Chuck Jean (sorry, not sorry) - not the BA Schultz was.

Mark Schultz is the guy at 184lbs.

I would go with Ed Banach at 197lbs, myself.  I get Eric Voelker, but Ed was as badass as they come.

285lbs actually has a lot of badasses.  Because Ed's here, I would be okay with Lou, as well.  Him Brucey or Neal would be okay for me.

So here is my actual list, if I would have done it:

125 - Terry Brands
133 - Tom Brands
141 - Dan Gable
149 - Brent Metcalf
157 - Lincoln McIlravy
165 - Dan Hodge
174 - Dave Schultz
184 - Mark Schultz
197 - Ed Banach
285 - Lou Banach

I almost went Sam Henson at 125lbs.  Hodge was at 177lbs, but because of his era, I think he would have been 165lbs in today's world.  I could have seen Terry at 133 and Tom at 141 - that makes it interesting between him and Gable, with Henson at 125lbs.

Imagine that room.  Nobody is making it to February with all their appendages. 

Totally get what you are saying and your additions, I was of course trying to fit them, well, to fit my team lol.. I would take Krieger over Lincoln, one BA dude.

I left many dudes I know to be flat out BA.

Voelker was quiet, but that dude was one mean SOB on the mat. Kevin Jackson was also one mean dude (note: when I say 'mean,' it's a compliment). 

Some other dudes that would fall in the BA Category...

Don Whipp (dude was a trip)
Rico was a BA
Tom Erickson (see Whipp)
The Cowboy Dennis Hall
Chris Short on the mat....


Just a few
 

That’s to keep your whining ass shut. You want off this ranch, you got it. I’ll drive your ass to the train station myself.

Posted
2 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

I'm surprised nobody mentioned Andre Metzger. 

He was on my list and I should have added him as (Additional) a BA no doubt.

That’s to keep your whining ass shut. You want off this ranch, you got it. I’ll drive your ass to the train station myself.

Posted (edited)

I'm in my 30s, so I'll do the guys I remember watching in my lifetime. My criteria was dudes that were intimidating, dudes that would not hesitate to fight anyone at any point and time, or dudes that battled injuries and still had success. Just dudes that exemplified toughness I suppose.

125: Kyle Ott

133: Tony Ramos/Cody Brewer/Cory Clark

141: Josh Koderhandt

149: Brent Metcalf/Lance Palmer/Frank Molinaro

157: James Fleming

165: Andrew Howe

174: Jay Borschel

184: Trent Hidlay

197: Dustin Kilgore

285: Steve Mocco/Cole Konrad

Edited by Winners Circle
Posted
5 minutes ago, Winners Circle said:

I'm in my 30s, so I'll do the guys I remember watching in my lifetime. My criteria was dudes that were intimidating, dudes that would not hesitate to fight anyone at any point and time, or dudes that battled injuries and still had success. Just dudes that exemplified toughness I suppose.

125: Kyle Ott

133: Tony Ramos/Cody Brewer/Cory Clark

141: Josh Koderhandt

149: Brent Metcalf/Lance Palmer/Frank Molinaro

157: James Fleming

165: Andrew Howe

174: Jay Borschel

184: Trent Hidlay

197: Dustin Kilgore

285: Steve Mocco/Cole Konrad

Nice

That’s to keep your whining ass shut. You want off this ranch, you got it. I’ll drive your ass to the train station myself.

Posted

Jason Kelber was a BAMF for Nebraska as were Brad Vering and Craig Brester.  Tough dudes. It also had to suck to wrestle the Dardanes twins from Minnesota.  Doug Schwab is a household name (among wrestling people) because of his motivational coaching style, but ppl forget what an animal he was.  Leather lungs.

Posted
5 hours ago, Winners Circle said:

I'm in my 30s, so I'll do the guys I remember watching in my lifetime. My criteria was dudes that were intimidating, dudes that would not hesitate to fight anyone at any point and time, or dudes that battled injuries and still had success. Just dudes that exemplified toughness I suppose.

125: Kyle Ott

133: Tony Ramos/Cody Brewer/Cory Clark

141: Josh Koderhandt

149: Brent Metcalf/Lance Palmer/Frank Molinaro

157: James Fleming

165: Andrew Howe

174: Jay Borschel

184: Trent Hidlay

197: Dustin Kilgore

285: Steve Mocco/Cole Konrad

May swap Jesse for Koderhandt but and matt brown for Borschel. Never got to watch Mocco live but from what I have heard seems like the pick.

I am the personal property of VakAttack

Posted
On 11/21/2025 at 10:58 AM, Winners Circle said:

I'm in my 30s, so I'll do the guys I remember watching in my lifetime. My criteria was dudes that were intimidating, dudes that would not hesitate to fight anyone at any point and time, or dudes that battled injuries and still had success. Just dudes that exemplified toughness I suppose.

125: Kyle Ott

133: Tony Ramos/Cody Brewer/Cory Clark

141: Josh Koderhandt

149: Brent Metcalf/Lance Palmer/Frank Molinaro

157: James Fleming

165: Andrew Howe

174: Jay Borschel

184: Trent Hidlay

197: Dustin Kilgore

285: Steve Mocco/Cole Konrad

No one has thrown more punches during and after wrestling matches than Trent Hidlay.  Thankfully, they were almost always at his own face.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Eli Gabrielson

    Archbishop Spalding, Maryland
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Maryland
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Jackson McLees

    Travelers Rest, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to The Citadel
    Projected Weight: 149

    Gunnar Gossett

    Union Local, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 165

    Dylan Frass

    Olentangy Liberty, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 285

    Emma Bacon

    Wyoming Seminary, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State (Women)
    Projected Weight: 131
×
×
  • Create New...