Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Freaking awesome event.  Love it.  Didn’t need PSU to be awesome.  Cael decided not to attend for some reason.  I expect that the reason or reasons doesn’t change next year or the year after.  If that is the case nothing changes.  So don’t attend.  Or he admits he was wrong … or something changes that removes a reason to not (or changes its weight) … and they do attend.  
 

Either way, awesome.  Definitely don’t need them.  Hoping no one bends over backward to try to get them in.  But if the reasons to not do it evaporate, all good.


As it stands, the optics look like they are a snob and stand aloof.  Just optics though.  Doesn’t make it true.  Their right.  Coach doing what he thinks is best for him and his team.

Posted

@Dark Energy your last two posts make me wish emoji’s were still here so I could tag them as 🔥!!!

Wasn’t Cael one of the reasons the previous National duals ended? I remember he was really against them back then, but don’t remember why. Their loss, as far as I’m concerned. Every coach in the NCAA should want to be a part of this.

Posted

Who cares if PSU is there or not. Literally all the top teams are there except PSU and ISU. You don’t ever see an event like this with so many top wrestlers except for B10’s and nationals. The event exceeded my expectations.

Posted (edited)

I am not sure where the disconnect is with the PSU not attending thing it feels like both sides are arguing two different things. Did PSU need to attend for it to be a good event absolutely not, nor should they have to. Did PSU not attending probably hurt the overall viewership and success of the event compared to if they were to have attended more than likely. That's not their job though and they've made it rather abundantly clear that anything sub optimal for winning in March is not in their best interest.

 

All that said it was still the best wrestling event I have seen outside of NCAA's in years.

Edited by Truzzcat

I am the personal property of VakAttack

Posted

I don’t think the event would have been better with Penn state bc they would have throttled everyone and they had a few valid reasons for not attending. 
 

1. 7 starters have been training and wrestling freestyle until a few weeks ago, Cael loves the all star match and wants his guys competing in that event but held everyone back this year because of U23 trainining

2. it’s way too early in the season ,true freshman just breaking in , guys just settling into weight cuts 

3. it’s a tournament hosted by the booster of Penn states new biggest rival in his backyard, who will use some of the money they bring in to build a team to beat Penn state . Why would Penn state help them in that process? If slumlord bob hosted a “national duals” in Iowa city I don’t think Penn state or Oklahoma state would go and if Penn state boosters held a “national duals” in happy valley Iowa and ok state probably wouldn’t go.

 I don’t think Penn state will go as long as ok state and its boosters are Quarterbacking the event, I think it would have to be run by a neutral party and maybe shift the venue every year to get penn state involved 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Truzzcat said:

I am not sure where the disconnect is with the PSU not attending thing it feels like both sides are arguing two different things. Did PSU need to attend for it to be a good event absolutely not, nor should they have to. Did PSU not attending probably hurt the overall viewership and success of the event compared to if they were to have attended more than likely. That's not their job though and they've made it rather abundantly clear that anything sub optimal for winning in March is not in their best interest.

 

All that said it was still the best wrestling event I have seen outside of NCAA's in years.

You think viewership was down because PSU didn’t attend? Genuine question. I wonder how many PSU fans are casual vs. wrestling fans that’ll watch good wrestling whether they’re there or not.

My only issue with PSU not attending is Cael’s rhetoric about growing the sport. To me, this seems like a major way to grow the sport. So it’s almost like talking out both sides of his mouth. Grow the sport as long as there’s not a chance that one of the top dogs loses early in the season.

Posted

Minus one of the runner ups, Penn State will wrestle the better teams in the event this year. Already on the schedule so you will all get to see them go head to head with these teams.

Posted

I actually think Cael might go next year (based on his comments in his season opening presser), but if he doesn't, here's what I would do if I were the organizers. 

I'd rename it the National Dual Meet Championships (not "Invitational"), do invites based on the tournament based on the prior year's top 16 teams, seed it based on those same 16 teams, showing all 16 teams on the bracket whether they choose to show up or not.  If a team doesn't show up, treat it as a forfeit.  So if PSU's the #1 seed, then the #16 team advances to the second round with a "forfeit" over PSU (even if the NCAA doesn't see it that way). 

Whoever wins is the national dual meet champion, including over PSU. And if PSU coaches/wrestlers cry foul, then hey, maybe show up next time instead of forfeiting.

 

Posted
3 minutes ago, BAC said:

I actually think Cael might go next year (based on his comments in his season opening presser), but if he doesn't, here's what I would do if I were the organizers. 

I'd rename it the National Dual Meet Championships (not "Invitational"), do invites based on the tournament based on the prior year's top 16 teams, seed it based on those same 16 teams, showing all 16 teams on the bracket whether they choose to show up or not.  If a team doesn't show up, treat it as a forfeit.  So if PSU's the #1 seed, then the #16 team advances to the second round with a "forfeit" over PSU (even if the NCAA doesn't see it that way). 

Whoever wins is the national dual meet champion, including over PSU. And if PSU coaches/wrestlers cry foul, then hey, maybe show up next time instead of forfeiting.

 

 

I dont think Paycom can crown national champs. Paycom Champs, yes. National Champs is an ncaa thing.

Posted
2 minutes ago, The_KC_Godfather said:

That didn’t seem to hurt Ramirez, Vega, Robideau, or Lockett…

They are the home team, they are the only team at the event with fans in attendance, not quite the same as teams coming time zones away 

Posted
5 minutes ago, BAC said:

I actually think Cael might go next year (based on his comments in his season opening presser), but if he doesn't, here's what I would do if I were the organizers. 

I'd rename it the National Dual Meet Championships (not "Invitational"), do invites based on the tournament based on the prior year's top 16 teams, seed it based on those same 16 teams, showing all 16 teams on the bracket whether they choose to show up or not.  If a team doesn't show up, treat it as a forfeit.  So if PSU's the #1 seed, then the #16 team advances to the second round with a "forfeit" over PSU (even if the NCAA doesn't see it that way). 

Whoever wins is the national dual meet champion, including over PSU. And if PSU coaches/wrestlers cry foul, then hey, maybe show up next time instead of forfeiting.

 

I love this idea. But, you could do it based on the tourney this year because PSU wasn’t there. I’d do it based on NCAA tournament finish, which guarantees PSU the 1 seed.

Posted
1 minute ago, Pinnacle said:

 

I dont think Paycom can crown national champs. Paycom Champs, yes. National Champs is an ncaa thing.

Why? I’ve crowned myself beer drinking national champ and nobody is coming after me for it…

Posted
20 minutes ago, Kov88 said:

Who cares if PSU is there or not. Literally all the top teams are there except PSU and ISU. You don’t ever see an event like this with so many top wrestlers except for B10’s and nationals. The event exceeded my expectations.

You used to.  There was an event a few years back called the national duals.   Until Carl blew that one up.    Isu and psu both would have been required to attend.  It was also second semester at the time.  

From 1989 until 2009 again when Carl killed it 

https://www.wrestlingstats.com/NWCA/PDF/NWCA National Duals.pdf

 

 

Posted (edited)
22 minutes ago, Antitroll2828 said:

I don’t think the event would have been better with Penn state bc they would have throttled everyone and they had a few valid reasons for not attending. 
 

1. 7 starters have been training and wrestling freestyle until a few weeks ago, Cael loves the all star match and wants his guys competing in that event but held everyone back this year because of U23 trainining

2. it’s way too early in the season ,true freshman just breaking in , guys just settling into weight cuts 

3. it’s a tournament hosted by the booster of Penn states new biggest rival in his backyard, who will use some of the money they bring in to build a team to beat Penn state . Why would Penn state help them in that process? If slumlord bob hosted a “national duals” in Iowa city I don’t think Penn state or Oklahoma state would go and if Penn state boosters held a “national duals” in happy valley Iowa and ok state probably wouldn’t go.

 I don’t think Penn state will go as long as ok state and its boosters are Quarterbacking the event, I think it would have to be run by a neutral party and maybe shift the venue every year to get penn state involved 

Those may be valid reasons, but not the actual reason. Cael was sour on this tournament long before the U23 team was known. Every team has freshmen that need time to adjust, and PSU probably has fewer than others.  And Cael would probably not like it no matter where it was held.

I think Cael's big thing is not having duals impact or dilute the NCAA tournament in March, and he's suspicious that the National Duals will be used as a way to shoehorn them in.  Historically, the bigger the dual tournament gets, the louder the groundswell to either have a separate NCAA sanctioned dual championship or to use points from dual standings "count" toward March. You can agree or disagree with that, but I think that's his starting point.    

I do think he may reconsider as I don't think Taylor has an ulterior motive here. And, with the prize money and media attention, it's going to be harder to say no if his guys clamor to attend.

 

Edited by BAC
Posted
12 minutes ago, The_KC_Godfather said:

You think viewership was down because PSU didn’t attend? Genuine question. I wonder how many PSU fans are casual vs. wrestling fans that’ll watch good wrestling whether they’re there or not.

My only issue with PSU not attending is Cael’s rhetoric about growing the sport. To me, this seems like a major way to grow the sport. So it’s almost like talking out both sides of his mouth. Grow the sport as long as there’s not a chance that one of the top dogs loses early in the season.

I think PSU probably has the largest casual fan base in the sport. So I believe viewership was probably far less than if they were to have been there.

I am the personal property of VakAttack

Posted
9 minutes ago, BAC said:

I actually think Cael might go next year (based on his comments in his season opening presser), but if he doesn't, here's what I would do if I were the organizers. 

I'd rename it the National Dual Meet Championships (not "Invitational"), do invites based on the tournament based on the prior year's top 16 teams, seed it based on those same 16 teams, showing all 16 teams on the bracket whether they choose to show up or not.  If a team doesn't show up, treat it as a forfeit.  So if PSU's the #1 seed, then the #16 team advances to the second round with a "forfeit" over PSU (even if the NCAA doesn't see it that way). 

Whoever wins is the national dual meet champion, including over PSU. And if PSU coaches/wrestlers cry foul, then hey, maybe show up next time instead of forfeiting.

 

I like emoji 

Posted
7 minutes ago, The_KC_Godfather said:

That didn’t seem to hurt Ramirez, Vega, Robideau, or Lockett…

Burton,Mendoza,Denny,Deluca I think every TF I saw wrestle scored a top 25ish caliber win.

I am the personal property of VakAttack

Posted
2 minutes ago, Antitroll2828 said:

They are the home team, they are the only team at the event with fans in attendance, not quite the same as teams coming time zones away 

So Blaze and Duke would struggle with not having their home crowd? That seems far fetched.

Excuses like that, and that they’re just coming off freestyle season, and that they’re trying to somehow avoid a donor, only makes their lack of attendance seem worse. When I don’t think it’s any of those at all.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Pinnacle said:

 

I dont think Paycom can crown national champs. Paycom Champs, yes. National Champs is an ncaa thing.

The NWCA crowned national dual meet champions for years.

They can call it whatever they want.

Posted
7 minutes ago, The_KC_Godfather said:

I love this idea. But, you could do it based on the tourney this year because PSU wasn’t there. I’d do it based on NCAA tournament finish, which guarantees PSU the 1 seed.

Yes, that's what I mean by prior year's tournament finish -- NCAAs, not National Duals. I wasn't very clear.

Posted
Just now, BAC said:

Yes, that's what I mean by prior year's tournament finish -- NCAAs, not National Duals. I wasn't very clear.

And I wasn’t either with my auto correct lol. But I still absolutely love the idea to “force” PSU in by dangling a forfeit/loss in their face.

Posted
15 minutes ago, Caveira said:

You used to.  There was an event a few years back called the national duals.   Until Carl blew that one up.    Isu and psu both would have been required to attend.  It was also second semester at the time.  

From 1989 until 2009 again when Carl killed it 

https://www.wrestlingstats.com/NWCA/PDF/NWCA National Duals.pdf

 

 

You forgot Tom Brands in this story teaming up with Cael to end it but that doesn't fit your narrative. 

I Don't Agree With What I Posted

Posted
2 minutes ago, PortaJohn said:

You forgot Tom Brands in this story teaming up with Cael to end it but that doesn't fit your narrative. 

Ok.   I think brands will be on espn2 any min now.   Will Carl?

The question of "who killed the NWCA National Duals" is a topic of debate within the wrestling community, but a common perspective is that 
Cael Sanderson, the head coach of Penn State, played a significant role by declining to participate with his highly-ranked team, thereby diminishing the event's stature. 
The NWCA National Duals are still held for various divisions (NCAA DII, DIII, NAIA, women's divisions, etc.). However, the premier NCAA Division I men's event that included all top teams in the past is often considered defunct in its original form. 
Here's an explanation of the situation:
  • Historical Context: The NWCA National Duals for Division I men were a prominent event for many years, running from 1989 until about 2009 in their original format.
  • The "Killing": Over time, scheduling conflicts and differing priorities for top-tier programs led to a decline in participation from some elite teams. The primary argument in forum discussions is that when Cael Sanderson's powerhouse Penn State team, which is consistently one of the top teams in the nation, began skipping the event, it lost its status as a true "national championship" for dual meets. Other top teams also occasionally opted out.
  • Reasons for Skipping: Cael Sanderson cited reasons such as the timing of the event (November date) conflicting with the team's preparation and international competition schedules. Some forum users also speculated that business/rivalry reasons were a factor, as the event could generate revenue for rival programs.
  • Current Status: A new event, the National Duals Invitational sponsored by Paycom, was launched to try to bring top Division I teams back together. This event is an invitational rather than an official NCAA championship, and while many top teams like Iowa, Oklahoma State, and Nebraska compete, Penn State has still declined to participate in recent years. 
In essence, it wasn't a single person who unilaterally "killed" the event, but rather a culmination of scheduling issues, programmatic priorities, and the specific decision of a dominant program (Penn State under Sanderson) to stop attending that led to the original Division I tournament's decline and subsequent reformatting into an invitational event.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...