Even if you think Mesenbrink was more dominant (I’d disagree of course), it’s not by much, and that’s just one of the criteria. Hendrickson’s quality of competition was far superior. Schultz took third, and that was his third best win, yet he has a better resume than anyone Mesenbrink beat. Mesenbrink’s “B1G schedule” included Maryland’s starter that was 2-16, and Michigan State’s that was 9-14, plus non conference duals with traditional powers like Drexel and American. The only NQ’s from the B1G that he wrestled prior to conferences were Caliendo, Mantanona, and Scoles. And he only wrestled 2 other NQ’s in total before conferences. Hendrickson beat 5 NQ’s (by tech, first period pin or injury default) at CKLV alone.
But, I will say it’s kinda cool for him that he received multiple forfeits from teams that had guys at his weight, and basically even got one from Ohio State in the B1G tournament, which is evidence of his dominance.