You are correct.... Ayers isn't going to burn shirts for four guys in the same weight class ... from an earlier post...
Since most of us are blocked by Thumper NearFall Bronco, he won't see this, but...The redshirt status is based on dates not matches.... They get 5 attached dates and they cannot wrestle unattached first semester.
Rule from NCAA: "Men's Wrestling. In men's wrestling, a student-athlete representing a Division I institution may compete in up to five dates of competition during the student-athlete's initial year of collegiate enrollment without using a season of competition. "
Montiero has preserved his redshirt...he only has 5 dates even though he has a lot of matches .... 2 tournaments, one that was unattached, and three duals were on the same date. Lorenzo also has kept his redshirt - he only has 5 dates on his record total. He wrestled attached at the Scuffle and Montiero did not. So Stanford fans have nothing to worry about, they are good.