Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

In all of the documentaries I have watched,  prisoners view having a job in prison as a privilege because they can do something other than stare at walls. If I am not mistaken they still get paid too.

Posted
31 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Remove the verbiage that allows for slavery of incarcerated people. 
 
Also, prisons should never be a for-profit industry. 

Don’t commit crimes would be a good start 

Posted

i agree with what everyone, including tpt, has said.

shawshank is great watch.

the only statement i disagree with is the very first one

slavery of imprisoned people.

punishments come in many forms

i mean there are alternatives. losing a hand. an eye. a life.

 

Posted

Just to be clear, you’re fine with slavery still existing in this country and that the justice system sentences black and brown people to dramatically longer sentences than whites? 
And the only coherent response is akin to ‘play stupid games win stupid prizes’. Lest we forget the ‘game’ you mean is being born black or brown in this country. 

Posted
45 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

Just to be clear, you’re fine with slavery still existing in this country and that the justice system sentences black and brown people to dramatically longer sentences than whites? 
And the only coherent response is akin to ‘play stupid games win stupid prizes’. Lest we forget the ‘game’ you mean is being born black or brown in this country. 

Stop committing crimes.  That’s a good start 

Posted

TPTPTPTPTPTPTP., 

You just changed the goal posts.   Blacks should not get longer sentences than anyone else for the same crime.   I'm know it happened in the past but not so sure it is still happening.   But maybe it is.   Is it fair that a person goes to jail.   Not for them it isn't.   Was it fair when they robbed someone, assaulted someone, raped someone, killed someone, kidnapped someone, tortured someone, etc?  Not for the victims they victimized.  If they don't want to go to jail, don't do those things.   It is quite simple.   

For me, justice should be blind and only extenuating circumstances should be considered when sentencing which is how some sentences are longer.   But other than that, they should be equal for all races.   As for slavery, prison is not a fun place.   Making them contribute is not much to ask.   I'm not overly concerned with making prisoners work, and usually it comes with special privileges, just like it does on the outside.   

What are you advocating for?   No more prisons?  If that is what you want, then vigilantism is what you will get, where justice is swift and often wrong, but there you go.   No one's rights are preserved with this system.   Rights are preserved in our justice system for both victims and perps, at least it used to be.   Now victims are not given justice and the perps are not made to pay for what they did.   

mspart

Posted
17 hours ago, mspart said:

TPTPTPTPTPTPTP., 

You just changed the goal posts.   Blacks should not get longer sentences than anyone else for the same crime.   I'm know it happened in the past but not so sure it is still happening.   But maybe it is.   Is it fair that a person goes to jail.   Not for them it isn't.   Was it fair when they robbed someone, assaulted someone, raped someone, killed someone, kidnapped someone, tortured someone, etc?  Not for the victims they victimized.  If they don't want to go to jail, don't do those things.   It is quite simple.   

For me, justice should be blind and only extenuating circumstances should be considered when sentencing which is how some sentences are longer.   But other than that, they should be equal for all races.   As for slavery, prison is not a fun place.   Making them contribute is not much to ask.   I'm not overly concerned with making prisoners work, and usually it comes with special privileges, just like it does on the outside.   

What are you advocating for?   No more prisons?  If that is what you want, then vigilantism is what you will get, where justice is swift and often wrong, but there you go.   No one's rights are preserved with this system.   Rights are preserved in our justice system for both victims and perps, at least it used to be.   Now victims are not given justice and the perps are not made to pay for what they did.   

mspart., 

*Read my last line, I mean that. Truly. 

You just changed the goal posts.   Blacks should not get longer sentences than anyone else for the same crime.   I'm know it happened in the past but not so sure it is still happening. 
Why not become SURE before typing this out?  But maybe it is.   Is it fair that a person goes to jail.   Not for them it isn't.   Was it fair when they robbed someone, assaulted someone, raped someone, killed someone, kidnapped someone, tortured someone, etc?  Not for the victims they victimized.  If they don't want to go to jail, don't do those things.   It is quite simple.  Seriously? Talking about moving the goal posts. You started the paragraph by not knowing the accuracy of my claim. Then seemingly tried to invalidate the claim by disregarding obvious injustice and racism in the criminal justice system by saying that "because they're criminals they shouldn't expect equal treatment under the law". Is that right? A black criminal shouldn't expect to be treated equally as a white criminal? Can you please clarify that for me? 

For me, justice should be blind and only extenuating circumstances should be considered when sentencing which is how some sentences are longer. Agreed  But other than that, they should be equal for all races. Agreed.  As for slavery, prison is not a fun place.   Making them contribute is not much to ask. No one should be forced to work for free, ever. They can just sit in a cell or in the yard or whatever. No one should do labor of any kind without compensation. Because once someone starts to profit from others' work. They start to become dependent on that free handout and will only work to maintain the status quo so they don't have to work hard to lift themselves up. DID YOU SEE HOW I DID THAT? Now the prisons are receivers of handouts. But you don't seem to care that they are taking money rather than working for it.  I'm not overly concerned with making prisoners work, and usually it comes with special privileges, just like it does on the outside.  This is a claim you should at least try to substantiate. Its not Shawshank. You'll need some evidence. 

What are you advocating for? Not having slaves anymore. No more prisons? Not as they currently exist, no. The criminal justice system is horribly flawed. but that's a discussion for a different time.   If that is what you want, then vigilantism is what you will get, where justice is swift and often wrong, but there you go. I get that your mind can only think of a few 'worst case' scenarios when you contemplate the status quo changing even a bit. But in the history of ever, when the status quo has tilted a bit has there ever been the catastrophe that you fear? No. Things get upset a bit. Then they settle back to normalcy and we learn to fix the broken bits little by little. That is when we are motivated to do so. There are plenty of broken parts of this country. Systemic issues that many in the country, many on this site, and yourself included EITHER refuse to see, admit, or address. Yes, addressing these problems will be difficult, maybe even painful. So I can understand the hesitation but it doesn't make them any less real. And we owe it to ourselves and the future generations to not saddle them with the pain of at least starting the process.     No one's rights are preserved with this system. People can still be locked away. Just not EXACTLY the way we are doing it today.  Rights are preserved in our justice system for both victims and perps, at least it used to be. That doesn't need to change but stricter enforcement of the rights of 'perps' wouldn't hurt. If a cop treats the criminal as badly as the criminal treated the victim what would you call the cop? Either a criminal themselves or a state sanctioned vigilante. So either way we kind of already have versions of your scenario. They just wear badges and are 'sworn' to serve and protect. Serve who and protect who is the question? When you can't be sure of who they will serve and/or protect then you must assume its no one but themselves.   Now victims are not given justice and the perps are not made to pay for what they did.  In what scenario was that ever an option or a claim that was made?

Seriously. Thank you for the comments. They were helpful. I hope my answers were too. 

Posted
5 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

*Read my last line, I mean that. Truly. 

your last line says being born black.

how racist do you have to be to think that being born black makes you predestined to commit crime

Posted
12 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

. They start to become dependent on that free handout and will only work to maintain the status quo so they don't have to work hard to lift themselves up. DID YOU SEE HOW I DID THAT?

Seriously. Thank you for the comments. They were helpful. I hope my answers were too. 

Wow you are really starting to see the light!!      This answer is very helpful

Posted
18 hours ago, Caveira said:

Stop committing crimes.  That’s a good start 

 

 I have a feeling this will fall on deaf ears because you have refused to live in reality with the rest of us with regards to systemic oppression and what that leads to and how we might combat it.
You can't keep resources from groups of people for generations. Then expect them to succeed by following the same rules and paths of the privileged class. Just the fact that you feel a few exceptions accurately represent the potential of the whole group denotes a fundamental lack of understanding of averages and how groups work. If everyone could do it then why doesn't everyone? Because in our system, there are people and groups actively suppressing the success of other groups. Those groups that, LIKE YOU, insist that the oppressed groups only use conventional levers of power to rise above their station. Levers that they have limited access to at the best of times.  Oppression happens through wages and hiring practices(blacks and irish need not apply). Housing, via city zoning. Banking laws and practices. Not loaning to certain people wanting to buy a home or start a business in a certain area. Forcing them into certain redlined areas(I forget what those were called again). Couple the HOUSING and BANKING practices into the funding of education and you get the 'less desirable' members of our country concentrated into economically poor areas. And conveniently we passed laws so that we don't have to fund their schools equally because the property we forced them to live on isn't worth as much. Policing and sentencing, government organizations admitting to purposefully introducing crack into black and brown neighborhoods in the 60's and 70's in the hopes of destabilizing the population. They had just won the right to vote and we couldn't have them coalescing around one party or candidate. So we passed gun reform laws in California so that blacks couldn't carry guns in public. Sentenced black and brown people to much higher prison sentences for possessing crack vs the same amount of powder cocaine. Which group of people bought, sold, and used powder cocaine as much or more than black people used crack? Oh ya, whitey. I wonder who benefitted from that provision. 
Again, you can't honestly object to anything I've written because its all true. i know you'll do your due diligence and research it all because we expect everyone else to do our homework for us on this site. So good luck. I can't wait to see your 4 word rebuttal attesting to everything I've said and confessing to your change of heart.    
 

 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Scouts Honor said:

no. i hit the nail on the head.

Are you really refusing to consider that you got it wrong and that the writer of the message understands the instruction better than you? 
Thank you for providing evidence of just how big of a jackass you are or want to be portrayed as. 
The last line which Gene included was to convey my genuine appreciation to the comments that I was responding to. 
I get that you feel you need to be contentious at every turn with regards to me and people you perceive as your enemy. 
Let it never be said that I didn’t try and that it was met with heartfelt and genuine contempt on your part. 

Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

Yep. You are as big a jackass as I thought. I feel bad for you and everyone you interact with. 
But you nailed the 4 words.

Congrats!

Moron!

Systemic oppression doesn’t exist. 

Edited by Caveira
Posted
13 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

 

  Which group of people bought, sold, and used powder cocaine as much or more than black people used crack? Oh ya, whitey. I wonder who benefitted from that provision. 
 
 So good luck. I can't wait to see your 4 word rebuttal attesting to everything I've said 
 

 

You win can't do it in four. but here's my best shot:

powder sniffers are white and crack users are black

Posted
54 minutes ago, Scouts Honor said:

dont try to call me patton

but again, i ask

how racist do you have to be to believe that black people are predisposed to commit crime.

Is that what I said? Can you provide the exact wording? I'd love to see it. 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

What is the point you are making or responding to?

Crack was not around until the mid 80's. It was a dealers advantage because it is less volatile form.  It was a derivative of freebasing that, that privileged abusers were the larger demographic. All cocaine users had the ability to buy it in either form or change the form if buying powder.   But you are saying only black people use it and the laws were changed to oppress the black people. Wrong, it is a highly more addictive hi and the come down increases addiction and it was evident it was destroying society all over the world.  thats why laws were changed for crack.  

 

Edited by Gene Mills Fan

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...