Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

 
There are more than two ways that 'sex' chromosomes present. https://genetic.org/variations/. So there is no definitive way to determine if someone is male or female just by looking at them and sometimes not even by genetically testing them. What 'sex' is someone that has chromosomes of; XXY, XXX, XYY, XXYY, XXXY, XXXX, XXXXY, OR XXXXX?
 
Also keep in mind that someone that may naturally present as one sex(male or female anatomy, without medication or surgical intervention) can, albeit rarely, be chromosomally a different sex. 
 
Any thoughts? 
  • Replies 80
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

You can be what you want, nature vs nurture. We can spin things all we want, we can take cornerstone cases or genetic exceptions, etc...

"An organism is defined by the type of gamete it is specialized to produce. Therefore, sex is binary: Male (sperm-producer) or Female (egg-producer). All individuals, regardless of other physical variations, are categorized based on the underlying biological system they developed from. This definition is clear, absolute, and applies to the vast majority of all sexually reproducing species." 

That is the most common and widely held position among evolutionary scientists. Including biologist Jerry Coyne, yes a liberal from the U of Chicago, he asserts that, despite rare exceptions, sex is functionally binary in humans due to evolution producing two distinct gamete types.

I want to be careful, but genetic mutations occur in all species. 

 

That’s to keep your whining ass shut. You want off this ranch, you got it. I’ll drive your ass to the train station myself.

Posted

The issue of transexualism as it is now being discussed in the nation has nothing to do with TPTDs point.   It is about a male saying he is a female and vice versa.   And the use of chemicals and surgery to try to make that happen, except it can't.   The chromosomes are what they are.   There are very few of the mutations TPTD is discussing.   

The further extension of this is to say that a trans woman who is really male, is a real woman and deserves to compete, dress with, and use the same lavatory and dressing room facilities as females.   And vice versa.  

Yes, there are mutations as V states, but this is not what is being argued about in America currently.   

mspart

Posted
1 hour ago, mspart said:

The issue of transexualism as it is now being discussed in the nation has nothing to do with TPTDs point.   It is about a male saying he is a female and vice versa.   And the use of chemicals and surgery to try to make that happen, except it can't.   The chromosomes are what they are.   There are very few of the mutations TPTD is discussing.   

The further extension of this is to say that a trans woman who is really male, is a real woman and deserves to compete, dress with, and use the same lavatory and dressing room facilities as females.   And vice versa.  

Yes, there are mutations as V states, but this is not what is being argued about in America currently.   

mspart

The issue of transexualism as it is now being discussed in the nation has nothing to do with TPTDs point. Yes and no.  It is about a male saying he is a female and vice versa. Nope, as was stated in the title sex and gender are different. No one is saying anyone can go from one SEX to another.   And the use of chemicals and surgery to try to make that happen, except it can't.Can't change sex, correct. But again, not really true to the point.  The chromosomes are what they are. Agreed. But there are more combinations than we previously thought. Agreed? What are they?   There are very few of the mutations TPTD is discussing.   
The further extension of this is to say that a trans woman who is really male,Well we haven't really decided on that, remember XXY, XYY, etc, what do we call people with those chromosomes? If not Male or Female then there is third.  is a real woman and deserves to compete, dress with, and use the same lavatory and dressing room facilities as females.   And vice versa.  I guess this is more to the point. Do you disagree? 
Why should trans athletes not be able to compete? 
Or use their preferred bathroom? 
Yes, there are mutations as V states, but this is not what is being argued about in America currently. I agree, it is being avoided. In my opinion these outliers are the turd in the punch bowl of the conservative argument. There are no definitive characteristics that makes men men and women women. Having to include all those anomalous people makes differentiating between the two functionally meaningless. Which doesn't bother me. But I imagine that is not the case for others.  
Posted

So, my agreeing with 99% of evolutionary scientists makes me the one ignoring science? ok.

That’s to keep your whining ass shut. You want off this ranch, you got it. I’ll drive your ass to the train station myself.

Posted

You are what you are. For the record gender dysphoria is a mental disorder. I don't care if people feel like they need to "right" nature's wrong, or whatever, but I don't want to hear any complaints after they get their plumbing rearranged. Also, not on the taxpayer's dime, but I'm pretty sure that's off the table already. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, NM1965 said:

You are what you are. For the record gender dysphoria is a mental disorder. I don't care if people feel like they need to "right" nature's wrong, or whatever, but I don't want to hear any complaints after they get their plumbing rearranged. Also, not on the taxpayer's dime, but I'm pretty sure that's off the table already. 

From what record are you referring?

Posted
2 hours ago, Viratas said:

You can be what you want, nature vs nurture. We can spin things all we want, we can take cornerstone cases or genetic exceptions, etc...

"An organism is defined by the type of gamete it is specialized to produce. Therefore, sex is binary: Male (sperm-producer) or Female (egg-producer). All individuals, regardless of other physical variations, are categorized based on the underlying biological system they developed from. This definition is clear, absolute, and applies to the vast majority of all sexually reproducing species." 

That is the most common and widely held position among evolutionary scientists. Including biologist Jerry Coyne, yes a liberal from the U of Chicago, he asserts that, despite rare exceptions, sex is functionally binary in humans due to evolution producing two distinct gamete types.

I want to be careful, but genetic mutations occur in all species. 

 

Not sure what you’re getting at here care to elaborate?

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

The issue of transexualism as it is now being discussed in the nation has nothing to do with TPTDs point. Yes and no.  It is about a male saying he is a female and vice versa. Nope, as was stated in the title sex and gender are different. No one is saying anyone can go from one SEX to another.   Yes they are and that is what the whole controversy is about.  And the use of chemicals and surgery to try to make that happen, except it can't.Can't change sex, correct. But again, not really true to the point.  If your point is just that there are more cohromosome combinations, I agree.   But that is not what the issue of transgenderism is about right now.   It is not about intersex individuals, it is about XX and XY individuals wanting to change their sex.   The chromosomes are what they are. Agreed. But there are more combinations than we previously thought. Agreed? What are they?   There are very few of the mutations TPTD is discussing.   
The further extension of this is to say that a trans woman who is really male,Well we haven't really decided on that, remember XXY, XYY, etc, what do we call people with those chromosomes? If not Male or Female then there is third.  Perhaps, but that is a different situation than what is discussed as transgenderism today.  is a real woman and deserves to compete, dress with, and use the same lavatory and dressing room facilities as females.   And vice versa.  I guess this is more to the point. Do you disagree?  It is the point I am making.
Why should trans athletes not be able to compete?  Because there are mens and womens sports for a reason.   A trans woman is not a woman or a trans girl is not a girl.  They are males pretending to be something they are not and demanding everyone else comply.  
Or use their preferred bathroom?  See above. 
Yes, there are mutations as V states, but this is not what is being argued about in America currently. I agree, it is being avoided. In my opinion these outliers are the turd in the punch bowl of the conservative argument. There are no definitive characteristics that makes men men and women women. Having to include all those anomalous people makes differentiating between the two functionally meaningless. Which doesn't bother me. But I imagine that is not the case for others.  If you were not using these outliers as a case to accept transgenderism, then I read too much into your post.   But I don't think so based on the responses you gave.  

Response is in Green above.   If all you were trying to say was there is other chromosome combinations, I agree.   But most people that go down this path are trying to explain transgenderism as we are now discussing in the nation.   That a man can feel like a woman and must therefore be a woman and therefore must be allowed all the rights and privileges afforded to women.   The college swimmer being a perfect example.   

mspart

 

Edited by mspart
Posted
25 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Wokesters hate science 

Lmfao. Almost every scientist I know is anti Trump. Anti lies. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted (edited)
41 minutes ago, mspart said:

Response is in Green above.   If all you were trying to say was there is other chromosome combinations, I agree.   But most people that go down this path are trying to explain transgenderism as we are now discussing in the nation.   That a man can feel like a woman and must therefore be a woman and therefore must be allowed all the rights and privileges afforded to women.   The college swimmer being a perfect example.   

mspart

 

I don’t wanna make this on mile long by copying your your text as well. 
 

No one is suggesting that a person can change their chromosomes. As stated in the title sex and gender are different. Until and unless that point is adequately refuted there is no controversy on that part of this topic. 
Sex and gender are different things. Please refute this point going forward because we're going to get bogged down in minutia if you continue to argue a point that is not being debated. No one is changing their SEX. 
Different chromosomal pairings are, if not at the heart of the conversation its pretty close, as to how to determine who is or is not a certain gender. How can we tell? By looking at anatomy? Cisgender people have been stopped and forced to prove, via showing parts of their anatomy(which we can all agree is abhorrent, right?) , that they are the gender that appears on the bathroom sign. Is that an adequate or humane way to determine who belongs in a bathroom? Really? 
 You do disagree, why?
Men's and women's sports: you know we just made these up, right? But we finally got to your thesis.. You feel that you know the thoughts and feelings of every person in this situation AND that they are all the same. Did I get that right? 
Why not accept trans people as the people they claim to be because they tell you? How does it harm you?
What is a man and what is a woman? These questions are not attacks. But to try to get you to understand that there is not set criteria. We're all shooting from the hip. Men wore wigs and heels 200 years ago. Marginalized communities, like the trans community, face higher rates of violence and self un-aliving. 
 
If anyone has a hard time following, I could try to point you in the right direction of what I’m responding to
Edited by ThreePointTakedown
Posted
25 minutes ago, red viking said:

Lmfao. Almost every scientist I know is anti Trump. Anti lies. 

So you’re admitting you’re woke and love scientists.   GOT IT 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...