I think there are people on here that don't provide anything to the topic at hand or the argument except to try and nitpick peoples post.
If you don't feel like UB and the new guy are being antisemitic then say it and explain why.
To me, if someone constantly bashes Israel without any sort of shade thrown at the terrorist organization who started this whole mess, yes, that person could be considered an antisemite. It'd be like someone constantly bashing the law enforcement groups that raided a bunch of KKK compounds after the KKK did horrific acts of violence to innocent minorities and then got in a shootout where innocent woman and kids were killed, and that person said nothing about what the KKK cowards did to deserve the raid. Would you think that is fine, and the person bashing law enforcement isn't a racist POS?
Funny part is in theory I agree with what you said.