GV4444
Members-
Posts
244 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Forums
Articles
Teams
College Commitments
Rankings
Authors
Jobs
Store
Everything posted by GV4444
-
Great list. You left off Swiderski and Figs on the stock down.
-
Hot take: Flo rankings are better than intermat
GV4444 replied to 1032004's topic in College Wrestling
This is a great hypothetical, since Ono has no folkstyle record. But, it isn't really a question of #1, it is whether the freestyle record should be considered in any degree. The choice isn't #1 or unranked, but rather if freestyle should be one of several factors in ranking. So, maybe he gets a ranking of #32 rather than nothing. Maybe Jax starts wrestling next semester and gets an immediate #15 because he has more good data points than Ono because of folkstyle record. I find the biggest issue in rankings is the head to head competition weighting vs. overall body of work. E.g. Schubert beats Wask. Must Schubert be ranked ahead of Wask? Intermat thinks yes, Flo thinks no. You can twist your mind into crazy contortions over-thinking head to head. Sometimes upsets are just upsets and not a demonstration of superiority. -
It was clear he wasn't capable dealing with BIG and GOOD. I see a lot of heavyweights he is going to lose to. I think he will need a favorable draw to AA.
-
Needed to break the cradle for reversal. It's easy to question in hindsight, but if you give him the reversal and then they guy rolls the cradle over, you look wrong for giving the reversal too soon. You would have had two reversals without anything actual changing.
-
It's not guaranteed. More like 80%, which is why you have to decide if it is worth the risk. You have to be convinced he will never win a championship. Everyone who gets fired is under contract. Coaches are paid all the time to just leave. It might be costly, but doable. PSU was willing to pay $50 million to get rid of their coach. That is now almost nothing as his new deal mitigates the buyout.
-
And so it begins again. Each year brings the call to fire Brands. Brands is the last coach not named Cael to win the NCAAs. He has 4 NCAA championships, 2nd most by three among active coaches. The question is always how long do you stay with guy with that kind of resume if it no longer looks like he can win the big one any more? If you compare it to other college sports, the thing that slips over time is recruiting. The magic allure starts to dip as other programs rise. Brands has really failed to recruit enough top 10 recruits in the last few years, but he has maintained the top echelon through great transfer portal pickups. Caliendo is their best wrestler right now. They've picked up Real Woods, Franek, Buchanan, et. al. to fill the shortcomings, but it's not the way to reach #1. It's a churn, since you aren't getting 4 seasons out of the transfers. tOSU has two transfers in their lineup, PSU has two transfers, Nebraska has one. Having said all that, Brands is in the middle of his best recruiting period in several years. He's got Deluca and Luddington from '25, Mocca in '26, Bachman, Kenny, Borge, Amato in '27, Bachman and Kenny in '28. If he had kept the Bassett clan, we'd be talking about the serious possibility of reaching #1. So, expect a lean year with '27 needing some more transfers, but a big uptick in '28.
-
To be fair, Iowa has the toughest dual schedule this year: tOSU x 2, Missouri, OSU x 2, Iowa State, PSU, plus the rest of their B1G foes. That's a potential 3 non-conference losses.
-
Agree Caliendo and Ferrari have the best shot, but you never know. In 2022 Eierman, Marinelli, and Kemerer were the best bets to reach the final, but it Jacob Warner who saved the day by reaching the finals to keep the streak alive. Seems like fewer dark horses this year, maybe Peterson, Kennedy, or Endeme.
-
My analogy is a baseball pitcher with a wicked splitter. The first few times you see it, you can't hit it, but every time you see it you get better at anticipating it. Drake has the best slide by in the country at this time, but everyone knows it now. It's not his only "pitch" in his arsenal, but it's his best attack. Once you neutralize that, he's still excellent top tier kind of guy, but beatable by other top tier guys.
-
Well that didn't age well. Caliendo is Iowa's best transfer. Peterson may be second.
-
Yes. He attended the Bartlett/Lewan folk style summer camp to perfect it. He was the exception being a D3 guy who is good enough to be a top D1 guy. You never know, but he was so dominate you knew if could be. Conversely, he probably didn't need reach his full potential to be undefeated in D3. I think his level jumped some just by being the Iowa room, but it was mostly there before he got to Iowa.
-
Exactly. His offense is weak. He lets people get in on his legs and then scrambles. Works fine against #30 or worse, but doesn't against top competition. Just like his double boot ride. He's only going to turn the lesser competition from that position. It's a great ride, but I think he's going to get some quick stall calls with it. The other issue with his double boot rides is that he can get too high. I think this weight is one of the two that PSU doesn't get an AA, with the other being 285. Nagao and Cole M. will need a very favorable draw to reach AA. PSU had 20 wrestlers at the event, 3 at 149 and 1 at 197.
-
I did notice that Manville gets no love in any of the rankings, but Vega has to be the favorite. The Larkin matches will definitely be the highlight of the dual. I think one of them wins.
-
Gene Bartow - UCLA Ray Perkins - Alabama Tough to follow a legend. The biggest change after the legend is a drop in recruitment. You lose a few blue chippers who wanted to play for Bear Bryant or John Wooden. After Gable, the allure is the Iowa program and you lose one or two recruits per year who would have chosen Iowa in order to wrestle for the legend Gable, but no longer see the allure of Iowa City.
-
I haven't been around here long, but I'm already seeing a pattern. It is the annual "Brands/Ryan need to be replaced". This thread starts with the Gable coaching tree trying to be too much like Gable. What I see is Brands being Brands. Is Ryan trying to be Gable? Schwab has a Gable problem? Dresser have a Gable problem? Or is it only a Gable problem because it is at Iowa? Once you get a dominate program like PSU in any sport, your guy becomes the guy who can't beat him. You can't accept that your coach because he can only be second or third. You start thinking you need to get someone else because second or third isn't good enough. The problem is that any replacement probably has a higher probably of being worse than what you have that exceeding the #1 guy. It's a big risk. One needs to remind oneself of the last two coaches to win the title not named Cael. The biggest problem I see with the Brands era has been poor recruiting. The replenishment rate is 3 guys a year with top 20 ability. He hasn't gotten it. But, he brought in top tier transfers to maintain top tier level and he just nabbed a great recruiting class (the first in several years). The big problem with using the portal is that portal guys typically don't have 4 years of eligibility left. OSU is taking their shot by replacing Smith with DT. I think it is going to work out really well. But is there a DT type to take over at Iowa? Big risk.
-
Your algorithm makes such an early season ranking pretty useless. It's not a reflection on your process, just that you are lacking data at this point.
-
I've just been triggered. You would thought 50 years would have erased the mental trauma, but it still haunts me.
-
I watched a lot of matches, but didn't listen to much commentary. Is Kueter injured or still recovering from hip surgery? He did wrestle the first dual against Bellarmine. Why didn't Iowa use one of their two backups?
-
Mendez and Davino were already at their high, so they can't go much further up. UP Endene Nininger Vega Cannon Robideau Webster Lockett Singleton Sasso Ohio State DOWN Nebraska Spratley Taylor Scoles Minto Allred Ryder
-
I really enjoyed the Penn State is the dual meet champions era
GV4444 replied to bnwtwg's topic in College Wrestling
I would have loved to see Penn State in the National Duals. Now that the season has started, I can rationalize why there they skipped. They had so many wrestlers at various worlds it would have been a quick transition to the college season. It's one of the reasons they had no one at the NWCA All-Star Classic. I hope Cael reconsiders for next year, if there is a next year. -
Great topic, especially after National Duals. I would add Jaxon Joy at 149, mostly because 149 is not very deep. Nininger is also good at 149. You knew Davino and Ferrari were contenders after their RS year. Robideau has really impressed. He looks like he would tech fall his high school senior version of himself from a year ago.
-
Just like huskerlucas' order, although you could scramble 5-8 any way you please. Welsh does not have enough body of work this year to rank any higher, but this a definitely a year for the top 4 guys to beat each other and cause confusion. If there is going to be a clear number 1, I think it will be Ferrari.
-
Seriosly ridiculous. Caliendo took one loss, not losses. Prior to this week, his only losses were to Mesenbrink, O'Toole, Carr, and Hamiti while wrestling for Iowa. Let us know when Endene matches that record.
-
That's it! Wait, if he didn't wrestle last night, won't he be in the same situation for his next match? Well, you can expect some ducking from Wrestlestat's 3rd ranked dual team.
