They had three finalists - Mesenbrink, O'Toole, and Keckeisen, and only one of them won. That's a 33% success rate. That doesn't even count the Mirasolas and Sinclair who weren't even in their respective starting line-ups. If I ran an abortion clinic with a 33% success rate, I'd be out of business in a week.
Is AWA a failure that should be shut down? Controversial take, but I say no. I say we give them a few more years to right the ship.