Yeah, the right thing to do would have been to post the criteria when I referenced them.
Here you go:
Bad losses (Under .500% win percentage).
Outside the top 30 Coaches Rank and/or top 30 RPI.
Conference champion. (I assume this refers to regular season, as the conference tournament champ gets the AQ)
Performance in last five matches (including conference tournament).
Number of injury default or medical forfeit wins/losses.
Best quality win.
Wrestler availability (Injured or medically unable to compete).
I assume that last one was meant to address the Suriano situation. Last year they obviously felt that Starocci/Sanderson was telling the truth when he said he could go.