Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
2 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

We know. You’re a typical libtardo ticking time 💣 Btw it’s 4x.  

You idiot. Thats only for the electoral college. For the senate, its approximately 68× the power. Thats absolutely ludicrous. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
9 hours ago, Scouts Honor said:

it's islamophobia to ask where are the women and children refugees

 

It's invasion phobic to ask,  not islamophonic. 

Most invaders leave their wives and kids behind.  Refugees bring them.  Because it is unsafe for the wives and children back home.

  • Wrestle +1 4

People who tolerate me on a daily basis . . . they are the real heroes.

Posted
4 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

DC was never intended to be a state and never should be one.  Dems wouldn’t be pushing for it if it wasn’t predominantly blue.  

And Republicans wouldn’t be filibustering if it was red.  Essentially no one lived in DC when the constitution was ratified so unclear how relevant that is to the current situation.  I doubt it was the intention to leave 700,000 people unrepresented in congress. There is no other democracy that leaves residents of its capital city without representation in the national legislature.  

To me it’s pretty clear the right thing is to give DC representation in Congress. That could either be through statehood or joining an adjacent state.  Statehood is most likely because it would seem that neither DC residents nor Marylanders want DC to join Maryland.  The only argument against DC getting representation is the title of this thread - republicans don’t like how DC residents think.  

4 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

PR isnt much over 50% for it. 

In Puerto Rico there were three options in the referendum.  Just under 60% voted for statehood and just over 10% wanted total sovereignty with under 30% wanting the status quo.  Statehood was preferred 2-1 to the status quo.   DC has higher support for statehood (~80%), but breaking off to form a new country isn’t really an option like it is for PR.  If 80% of Puerto Ricans voted for statehood in the next referendum would you get behind the cause?

Posted
3 hours ago, red viking said:

You idiot. Thats only for the electoral college. For the senate, its approximately 68× the power. Thats absolutely ludicrous. 

Far from 1000x like your idiot ass claimed. 

  • Wrestle +1 1

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
2 hours ago, fishbane said:

And Republicans wouldn’t be filibustering if it was red.  Essentially no one lived in DC when the constitution was ratified so unclear how relevant that is to the current situation.  I doubt it was the intention to leave 700,000 people unrepresented in congress. There is no other democracy that leaves residents of its capital city without representation in the national legislature.  

To me it’s pretty clear the right thing is to give DC representation in Congress. That could either be through statehood or joining an adjacent state.  Statehood is most likely because it would seem that neither DC residents nor Marylanders want DC to join Maryland.  The only argument against DC getting representation is the title of this thread - republicans don’t like how DC residents think.  

In Puerto Rico there were three options in the referendum.  Just under 60% voted for statehood and just over 10% wanted total sovereignty with under 30% wanting the status quo.  Statehood was preferred 2-1 to the status quo.   DC has higher support for statehood (~80%), but breaking off to form a new country isn’t really an option like it is for PR.  If 80% of Puerto Ricans voted for statehood in the next referendum would you get behind the cause?

Those people in DC can easily be absorbed by the states they live in. AGAIN DC was never intended to be a state. You should look up why it’s where it is 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
2 hours ago, fishbane said:

In Puerto Rico there were three options in the referendum.  Just under 60% voted for statehood and just over 10% wanted total sovereignty with under 30% wanting the status quo.  Statehood was preferred 2-1 to the status quo.   DC has higher support for statehood (~80%), but breaking off to form a new country isn’t really an option like it is for PR.  If 80% of Puerto Ricans voted for statehood in the next referendum would you get behind the cause?

How many people voted ?  Hint. 20%. Why was that?

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
9 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Those people in DC can easily be absorbed by the states they live in. AGAIN DC was never intended to be a state. You should look up why it’s where it is 

DC should be bigger.  The original boundaries with an area south/west of the Potomac equal to the area north /east of the Potomac should be reestablished.

Also, not a state.

If the DC, PR should be a state then any sub portion of a state should bd able to be a state.   In fact, that's a good idea.  Let's let every county have a rep in the house and a senator for every group of 10 counties.  So long as we're trashing the constitution anyway. 

  • Wrestle +1 1

People who tolerate me on a daily basis . . . they are the real heroes.

Posted
Just now, Lipdrag said:

DC should be bigger.  The original boundaries with an area south/west of the Potomac equal to the area north /east of the Potomac should be reestablished.

Also, not a state.

If the DC, PR should be a state then any sub portion of a state should bd able to be a state.   In fact, that's a good idea.  Let's let every county have a rep in the house and a senator for every group of 10 counties.  So long as we're trashing the constitution anyway. 

This 💯.  85% of the counties in my state vote red and we’re still blue.  Every county gets its own vote.  Works for me. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted

States are often added in pairs with different political leans to maintain the power balance.

But if we're doing away with that, yea lets go with every county gets minimal representation.

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
10 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

AGAIN DC was never intended to be a state. You should look up why it’s where it is 

No need to look it up I know all about it.  Framers wanted the federal district independent from any state. It’s location was a compromise with the southern states.

The plan for DC statehood does not conflict with the constitution.  The constitution puts a maximum size on the federal district (10mi square) but there is no minimum.  DC statehood shrinks the federal district to the buildings in and around the mall that house the government (Capitol, White House, Supreme Court) and the remaining 60+ mi^2 where the 700,000+ residents live would be the 51st state.

10 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Those people in DC can easily be absorbed by the states they live in. 

I don’t know what you mean.  They don’t live in a state they live in the District of Columbia.  Are you suggesting Congress give the land outside of the reduced federal district back to Maryland?  As someone who doesn’t live there that seems like a solution, but neither DC nor Maryland want that solution.  It is undemocratic and untenable to have that many people unrepresented in the legislature.  Just give them representation like every other democracy already does - Brazil, Australia, etc.  It’s not like Philadelphians and New Yorkers didn’t have representation before the capital moved to DC.

Posted
1 hour ago, Lipdrag said:

DC should be bigger.  The original boundaries with an area south/west of the Potomac equal to the area north /east of the Potomac should be reestablished.

DC is about 68 square miles currently.  It used to be 100 square miles.  One hundred square miles is the maximum allowed by the constitution.  You are suggesting Virginia give back the 32 square miles?  That is ridiculous.  What is your reasoning?

1 hour ago, Lipdrag said:

Also, not a state.

If the DC, PR should be a state then any sub portion of a state should bd able to be a state.   In fact, that's a good idea.  Let's let every county have a rep in the house and a senator for every group of 10 counties.  So long as we're trashing the constitution anyway. 

Are there other counties that don’t have voting representation in Congress?  The ones discussed here are unique in that they do not.  I could understand if the proposed state was exceptionally small, but DC has more residents than two states and has a population about the size of the average congressional district.  Puerto Rico would be firmly a mid sized state in population and is larger than two in land area.  

How would giving the right to vote and a voting representative in Congress be “trashing the constitution?”

Posted
3 hours ago, fishbane said:

No need to look it up I know all about it.  Framers wanted the federal district independent from any state. It’s location was a compromise with the southern states.

The plan for DC statehood does not conflict with the constitution.  The constitution puts a maximum size on the federal district (10mi square) but there is no minimum.  DC statehood shrinks the federal district to the buildings in and around the mall that house the government (Capitol, White House, Supreme Court) and the remaining 60+ mi^2 where the 700,000+ residents live would be the 51st state.

I don’t know what you mean.  They don’t live in a state they live in the District of Columbia.  Are you suggesting Congress give the land outside of the reduced federal district back to Maryland?  As someone who doesn’t live there that seems like a solution, but neither DC nor Maryland want that solution.  It is undemocratic and untenable to have that many people unrepresented in the legislature.  Just give them representation like every other democracy already does - Brazil, Australia, etc.  It’s not like Philadelphians and New Yorkers didn’t have representation before the capital moved to DC.

Independent from the STATES. BINGO!!!!!     Those that choose to live there know the rules before they decide to live there.  If anything they should be allowed to vote in the closet state. Nobody said anything about it conflicting with the constitution.  Just that it was never intended to be a state and shouldn’t ever become one.  Especially not for the political purposes Dems want to use it for.  

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
3 hours ago, fishbane said:

No need to look it up I know all about it.  Framers wanted the federal district independent from any state. It’s location was a compromise with the southern states.

The plan for DC statehood does not conflict with the constitution.  The constitution puts a maximum size on the federal district (10mi square) but there is no minimum.  DC statehood shrinks the federal district to the buildings in and around the mall that house the government (Capitol, White House, Supreme Court) and the remaining 60+ mi^2 where the 700,000+ residents live would be the 51st state.

I don’t know what you mean.  They don’t live in a state they live in the District of Columbia.  Are you suggesting Congress give the land outside of the reduced federal district back to Maryland?  As someone who doesn’t live there that seems like a solution, but neither DC nor Maryland want that solution.  It is undemocratic and untenable to have that many people unrepresented in the legislature.  Just give them representation like every other democracy already does - Brazil, Australia, etc.  It’s not like Philadelphians and New Yorkers didn’t have representation before the capital moved to DC.

Again, they can have representation in the closet state to them.  Other than that they knew when they decided to live there what the rules were. Nobody forced them there. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted (edited)
14 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

How many people voted ?  Hint. 20%. Why was that?

@fishbane  still waiting for your response as to why only 20% voted.  You skipped this one for some reason 

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
6 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

@fishbane  still waiting for your response as to why when only 20% voted.  You skipped this one for so,e reason 

Sorry I had intended to respond to this.  I think you are mixing up the various referendums over the years, which is easy because there have been many.  There was a referendum in 2017 which only had ~22% voter turnout but the results were overwhelming for statehood ~97%.  More recent referendums had statehood support between 50-60% with much higher turnout.  See the below table from wikipedia. 

The one I had been quoting is the 2024 referendum.  It is the most relevant temporally and 63% voter turnout.  This is the one with the 58/29/12% results that I had quoted earlier.  There was not a referendum with both voter turnout in the 20-30% range and support for statehood in the 50-60% range.

 

Screenshot 2026-11-13 145634.png

Posted
22 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

This 💯.  85% of the counties in my state vote red and we’re still blue.  Every county gets its own vote.  Works for me. 

Thats most if not every every state in the country you idiot. 110% unconstitutional to give disproportionate power to the big rural landowners at state and local levels. President is the only election not decided by popular vote but we gonna change that!!

Lots of work needs to get done in next few years. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
46 minutes ago, Scouts Honor said:

so you are thinking more assassinations? 

You wingers only think about violence.

States can allocate their electoral votes however they want. The way they're being allocated now is complete BS. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
2 hours ago, red viking said:

Thats most if not every every state in the country you idiot. 110% unconstitutional to give disproportionate power to the big rural landowners at state and local levels. President is the only election not decided by popular vote but we gonna change that!!

Lots of work needs to get done in next few years. 

You woke idiots sure are slow.  And willing to remove all the checks and balances to secure total power.  Then on to communism.  

  • Wrestle +1 1

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
21 minutes ago, red viking said:

You wingers only think about violence.

States can allocate their electoral votes however they want. The way they're being allocated now is complete BS. 

Red violence telling someone else violence is all they think about.  Oh. The. Irony. 

  • Wrestle +1 1

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
52 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

You woke idiots sure are slow.  And willing to remove all the checks and balances to secure total power.  Then on to communism.  

Checks and balances have nothing to do with popular vote u idiot. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Bryson Galloway

    North East HS, Pennsylvania
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Slippery Rock
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Joe Constable

    Fort Dodge, Iowa
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State
    Projected Weight: 285

    Konner Larkin

    Valiant Prep, Arizona
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Arizona State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Adan Castillo

    Clovis, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Little Rock
    Projected Weight: 285

    Sy Strobel

    West-Oak, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Appalachian State
    Projected Weight: 184
×
×
  • Create New...