Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
On 7/17/2026 at 8:11 PM, JimmySpeaks said:

I’ll use the angle the trans supporters use when a biological male plays girls sports……….

You found one example?  It’s such an anomaly it’s really not worth counting.   How’s that ? 

Thanks for your input. 

Anomalies can be used in a few ways. If an argument relies on 100% or 0% occurrences of that thing then one single anomaly proves it incorrect. 

Is the person bad or evil that they held a position and it was proven to be incorrect by an anomaly? No. 

If a topic is based more on averages like crime rates and background characteristics. Then an anomaly doesn't help your point one way or the other. 

You just need to know how an anomaly could help or hurt your argument. 

What if, when presented with information that proves their opinion to be wrong, they refuse to acknowledge it or to incorporate it into a new and different idea/opinion? 

At this point I would consider them a bad person or at the very least they are so traumatized that they don't realize how harmful they are being to themselves and those around them by continuing the practice. They should really consider getting help to unpack the reasons for not wanting to be smarter and be a better thinker.

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/17/2026 at 8:25 PM, Caveira said:

Individuals with pure Swyer syndrome (46,XY) cannot naturally conceive a child on their own.

Because their gonads do not develop into ovaries, they do not produce their own eggs (oocytes) or the natural hormones needed to trigger puberty and menstruation.   They need to have them medically implanted

However, the distinction between conception and pregnancy reveals a remarkable medical reality:

What Cannot Happen Naturally

No Egg Production: Because there are no ovaries, natural ovulation is impossible.

No Natural Conception: They cannot become pregnant through unassisted intercourse because they lack the female gametes (eggs) required for fertilization.

Thanks for the book report. What point are you trying to make? 

People with XY and XX chromosomes can get pregnant, carry to term, and deliver a healthy baby. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/19/2026 at 8:02 AM, Lipdrag said:

Yes.  Some people insist on remaining to be confused.  Seems like a thing. 

The discussions are very short when everyone agrees or no one cares.

100% agree. Say less. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/19/2026 at 6:15 PM, Simpleman424 said:

Identifying however you want and mandating others conform to your identity are two separate things. I don’t care what people identify either but when you bring it into the public sphere you are the one who has now made your private life public. Again, shouldn’t matter but if you’re not addressed to your satisfaction then you move on. No one’s trying to control these people they just don’t want to participate and that’s every persons right…

Also, not sure if you’ve been paying attention or not but pedophilia is getting cracked down on at levels we’ve never seen in this country before. We might not be seeing the people we’d like being held accountable yet but that’s out of our control…let’s be grateful there’s are literal thousands of people getting hemmed up for these heinous crimes. Saying “But Bill Clinton or Donald Trump haven’t gotten arrested so I’m going to be angry!” is silly…they're out there shutting down trafficking rings DAILY and people are complaining certain people or groups of people aren’t being held accountable…that’s just as disgusting.

Interesting take on the subject. 

What do you mean by 'bring it into the public sphere'? What is being brought out? 

I disagree that 'no one's trying to control these people'. I think that's exactly what is happening. Firstly, I don't think accidentally misgendering someone is the issue. That's happened since time immemorial. Its the active and sometimes aggressive misgendering that is the issue. We call each other by name sometimes. If we call someone by the wrong name, we get corrected, we apologize if you are decent human being, then we try to call that person by the name they have informed us that they prefer. Swap name for pronoun in that scenario. What's the problem? Why can't we all just try to not be assholes? 

Secondly, I think that trans issues and trans people make others feel icky. Similar to gay and lesbian people from decades ago. They offended people by flaunted their sexuality in public by holding hands or kissing their partner. This disgusted some people. So much so that it pushed them to become violent to gay and lesbian people. Similarly to trans individuals today. They can't cope with the fact that these people exist. They don't understand and don't want to understand their lives and what they go through on a daily basis. But find them disgusting and objectionable and offensive. They get on board with laws banning gender affirming care. Not because of the data or the science but on vibes. If they can't actively harm trans people they choose to passively harm them because they are icky and abnormal. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/19/2026 at 8:53 PM, Caveira said:

Every human on this forum has said.  Be called what you want.  No one cares.   
 

……. but you can’t force people to believe men can be women because they can’t.   

All evidence to the contrary. You even sited an example and proves this hypothesis wrong. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/20/2026 at 7:15 AM, Simpleman424 said:

The Trump administration has taken steps largely in part to protect children, and to a degree adults, affected by this mental health condition. Saying that they are forcing people into a certain set of beliefs because they’ve enacted some legislative orders to say “hey let’s put the breaks on putting kids under the knife or feeding them life altering medications” is a far cry from what people are trying to portray. What would be cool is if people cared about children as much as they pretend to…but I’ll hold my breath on that one.

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from what would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. As can be gleaned from this text from EO 14183 'Armed Forces have been afflicted with radical gender ideology to appease activists unconcerned with the requirements of military service like physical and mental health, selflessness, and unit cohesion.

So I would be hard pressed to agree that they are doing anything with, for, or to trans people out of concern for their wellbeing. 

The Secretary of Health and Human Services is decimating vaccine science and declared that gender-affirming care as being unsafe. They are not following science or their own procedures in order to harm trans people.  

Also there is no evidence that children are actively being harmed. If you have some, I would be interested to see it. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/20/2026 at 8:25 AM, Caveira said:

Men can dress like women.  Men can’t be women.  

Is this your version of 'I think I can'? Cuz that's what it seems like. If you keep saying that to yourself then it will be true? (spoiler alert) Its not. I have a feeling that you just living in a world that continues to prove you wrong on this issue(which it will) will be excruciating to you. So I am fine with you yelling at clouds because you are actively seeing how wrong you are on this subject, on a daily basis. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

On 7/21/2026 at 6:55 AM, Simpleman424 said:

Well they leave it to the states because the states already have plans, policies and programs in place to address a lot of the things you’re talking about. And what we’ve done is take that responsibility away from the states because we’ve forgotten the Federal Government is the backstop not the primary. I go to my parents if I have an issue before my grandparents type of deal…maybe not the best analogy but you get what I’m saying. Local communities, churches, state governments are all responsible before the federal government. 
 

And yes bombs, missiles and components of self defense should be one of if not the primary focus of the Federal Government because everyone else is doing their part. That’s something the states can’t handle on that scale.

Yes. States have the flexibility on some issues, sure. Some things should NOT be up to states. Living in different states should not offer you different freedoms. Everyone gets an education, yes. What that education entails, is up to the states. If you want a better or different education you can move or pay for private school. Commerce: similar rules to deter fraud across the board. Some are stricter than others. Health care: what is and is not allowed or offered should not vary state to state. The number of providers might vary or not exist due to lack of need but if procedures or medicines with proven efficacy are banned or criminalized. That is wrong. That is ignorant. That is purposefully harmful. Because rich people will always have the resources to get those things that are banned in different states. So that means we, as a society, have agreed to torture and punish poor people that can't move to a state to temporarily acquire what should be available to everyone. 

Not sure what you mean by 'responsible'. Do you mean paying for things? Because I don't think that's the issue. Having a federal law protecting the basic freedoms is the issue. 

BTW, churches or religious organizations own plenty of hospitals in states where certain medical procedures are free and legal yet still refuse to offer them to their patients. Many in the realm of child birth. I don't need to tell you that sometimes complications in this area have few treatments and they are quite time sensitive. 

Sorry I don't mean to yell at or make it seem like I'm attacking you. This subject is... a lot.

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

On 7/21/2026 at 5:46 PM, JimmySpeaks said:

Men can think they’re women but they’ll never keep the world going without real women. 

Old man, yells at clouds. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

On 7/22/2026 at 8:57 AM, JimmySpeaks said:

The simple fact is biological men can’t give birth to a child.  Hardly complicated. 

Interesting take. 

How are you using the phrase 'biological men'?

Are we talking about chromosomes or visible physical features or what? 

And please don't say 'its common sense' or 'you already know what I mean'. Because that means you don't know and if you don't know then your first statement translates to 'The simple fact is a thing I can't explain can't give birth to a child'. Which I totally agree with. But is not really useful in conversation. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

On 7/22/2026 at 9:23 AM, Simpleman424 said:

In no world did I think someone would take that as me saying we should care less about kids. In fact I said more people actually involved with the kids, aware of their individual needs and close to the situation aren’t living up to their part and relying on big government. This was mostly in response to you mentioning meal programs and medical coverage. It was in fact an advocation that people care more…while saying the Federal Government needs to primarily protect the people from external influences/dangers. That has no connection to not caring about kids…

Ok. That's fair. 

What do you mean by 'aren't living up to their part'? 

How are you determining what their 'part' is?

And at what point would you say someone is 'relying' on big government? Is it total funds or time or something else?

People do care. But they are also bias. Too many people refuse to help the whole group because a few MIGHT, in their mind, get something they don't deserve. As if they get to determine who deserves what. Where the counter idea is that the benefit of helping everyone is worth a small percentage possibly taking advantage. One is born out of ignorance, intolerance, and bigotry. The other is born out of compassion, empathy, and understanding.

Take health care for instance. Who takes advantage of universal health care? Poor people? No. They tend to fall into the group that is 'undeserving' of nice things. Its rich people that take advantage, so far as we've seen in our system today. Insurance fraud happens a lot. Sometimes on a massive scale. A senator from FL was CEO of a company that was fined a huge amount for committing insurance fraud for years. Its not poor people scamming EBT or food stamps that make up the bulk of fraud.   
 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

Posted
35 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

 

What if, when presented with information that proves their opinion to be wrong, they refuse to acknowledge it or to incorporate it into a new and different idea/opinion?  In a controlled laboratory much is possible. To classify them as woman is also is also incorrect as you have explained they are an anomaly.

At this point I would consider them a bad person At this point I consider this your opinion.  or at the very least they are so traumatized that they don't realize how harmful they are being to themselves and those around them by continuing the practice. They should really consider getting help to unpack the reasons for not wanting to be smarter and be a better thinker.

Thanks for the book report. What point are you trying to make? 

People with XY and XX chromosomes can get pregnant, carry to term, and deliver a healthy baby. 

Because you received medical assistance to carry a fetus, it does not make you a biological woman

100% agree. Say less. 

You should try this

Interesting take on the subject. 

I disagree that 'no one's trying to control these people'. I think that's exactly what is happening. At this point I consider this your opinion.

Secondly, I think that trans issues and trans people make others feel icky. At this point I consider this your opinion.

All evidence to the contrary. You even sited an example and proves this hypothesis wrong. An anomaly that needs scientific medical interference to happen does not give you membership to the group.

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from That would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. At this point I consider this your opinion.

Is this your version of 'I think I can'? Cuz that's what it seems like. If you keep saying that to yourself then it will be true? (spoiler alert) Its not. I have a feeling   No emotional outbursts please

Yes. States have the flexibility on some issues, sure. Some things should NOT be up to states. At this point I consider this your opinion. Living in different states should not offer you different freedoms. States still have to abide by federal law

 Having a federal law protecting the basic freedoms is the issue. Democracy will decide not your choice!

BTW, churches or religious organizations own plenty of hospitals in states where certain medical procedures are free and legal yet still refuse to offer them to their patients. You can start a hospital too

Old man, yells at clouds.     Not nice to fool with mother nature.

How are you using the phrase 'biological men'? 

How are you using the phrase Woman, when you take it upon yourself to include non-biological women and anomalies?

. Children don't know what's best for them always. each case is different. Statewide and community-wide systems with federal overlook can assimilate and adjust easier than a federal mandate.

 

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

 

Posted
2 hours ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

 

All evidence to the contrary. You even sited an example and proves this hypothesis wrong. An anomaly that needs scientific medical interference to happen does not give you membership to the group. Yes, this is your opinion. Without evidence to back it up it is as easily dismissed as you've tried to dismiss my 'opinions' that I, however, did back up with facts. See the difference?

Because you received medical assistance to carry a fetus, it does not make you a biological woman

And you feel this is true because...? 

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from That would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. At this point I consider this your opinion. Why is it you conveniently left out the language from the EO that highlights how disgusted the administration is with regard to trans people? Could it be that it made my point in a way that you can't refute? I think it is. 

How are you using the phrase Woman, when you take it upon yourself to include non-biological women and anomalies?

There is no such thing as 'biological woman'. If I am wrong please correct me by offering your working definition of woman that would include all others you consider 'biological women' and exclude the sited anomaly? If you cannot then by default they fall under the umbrella of 'woman'. How long do you require to complete this assignment? Remember if you fail to do it or even attempt it, then by default you agree with me. Trans men and women ARE men and women! 

. Children don't know what's best for them always. each case is different. Statewide and community-wide systems with federal overlook can assimilate and adjust easier than a federal mandate. 

I believe that's what we had. Dislike it as much as you wanted. If you didn't believe it should be done or offered then you are under no obligation to participate with the treatment yourself. You would likely be a horrible steward to a child suffering from something that could be treated. There was no mandate that people be given treatment. Just that it was available as an option and that if doctors, guardians, and patients agreed to the treatment that they could receive the treatment. Now, it seems, there are some states that refuse to make these treatments available. THAT. IS. WRONG! It will lead to harm and death among their constituents. But they will be, almost exclusively, within one small group. That group, they have decided, is not deserving(there's that word again) of being treated with equality, dignity, or compassion. Because they are looked on as less-than or abnormal. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 
i look forward to your response. This could be promising. 

Posted

All evidence to the contrary. You even sited an example and proves this hypothesis wrong. An anomaly that needs scientific medical interference to happen does not give you membership to the group. Yes, this is your opinion. Without evidence to back it up it is as easily dismissed as you've tried to dismiss my 'opinions' that I, however, did back up with facts. See the difference?      We all know the dna is different. An anomaly is a deviation. facts

 

Because you received medical assistance to carry a fetus, it does not make you a biological woman

And you feel this is true because...? Again this person has dna that is in cells that are growing internals that produce testerone extremely elevated to an XX woman. This person does not have ovaries and never had or will have eggs and does not menstruate. Facts 

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from That would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. At this point I consider this your opinion. Why is it you conveniently left out the language from the EO that highlights how disgusted the administration is with regard to trans people? Could it be that it made my point in a way that you can't refute? I think it is. Because the EO highlights proper decisions as disgusting is their opinion and yours. See the difference? 

How are you using the phrase Woman, when you take it upon yourself to include non-biological women and anomalies?

There is no such thing as 'biological woman'. If I am wrong please correct me by offering your working definition of woman that would include all others you consider 'biological women' and exclude the sited anomaly? If you cannot then by default they fall under the umbrella of 'woman'. How long do you require to complete this assignment? Remember if you fail to do it or even attempt it, then by default you agree with me. Trans men and women ARE men and women! 

XX chromosomes thats it 2 seconds. 

. Children don't know what's best for them always. each case is different. Statewide and community-wide systems with federal overlook can assimilate and adjust easier than a federal mandate. 

I believe that's what we had. Dislike it as much as you wanted.At this point I consider this your opinion. If you didn't believe it should be done or offered then you are under no obligation to participate with the treatment yourself. You would likely be a horrible steward to a child suffering from something that could be treated. There was no mandate that people be given treatment. Just that it was available as an option and that if doctors, guardians, and patients agreed to the treatment that they could receive the treatment. Now, it seems, there are some states that refuse to make these treatments available. THAT. IS. WRONG! It will lead to harm and death among their constituents. But they will be, almost exclusively, within one small group. That group, they have decided, is not deserving(there's that word again) of being treated with equality, dignity, or compassion. Because they are looked on as less-than or abnormal. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

Posted
9 hours ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Thanks for your input. 

Anomalies can be used in a few ways. If an argument relies on 100% or 0% occurrences of that thing then one single anomaly proves it incorrect. 

Is the person bad or evil that they held a position and it was proven to be incorrect by an anomaly? No. 

If a topic is based more on averages like crime rates and background characteristics. Then an anomaly doesn't help your point one way or the other. 

You just need to know how an anomaly could help or hurt your argument. 

What if, when presented with information that proves their opinion to be wrong, they refuse to acknowledge it or to incorporate it into a new and different idea/opinion? 

At this point I would consider them a bad person or at the very least they are so traumatized that they don't realize how harmful they are being to themselves and those around them by continuing the practice. They should really consider getting help to unpack the reasons for not wanting to be smarter and be a better thinker.

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

Thanks for the book report. What point are you trying to make? 

People with XY and XX chromosomes can get pregnant, carry to term, and deliver a healthy baby. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

100% agree. Say less. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

Interesting take on the subject. 

What do you mean by 'bring it into the public sphere'? What is being brought out? 

I disagree that 'no one's trying to control these people'. I think that's exactly what is happening. Firstly, I don't think accidentally misgendering someone is the issue. That's happened since time immemorial. Its the active and sometimes aggressive misgendering that is the issue. We call each other by name sometimes. If we call someone by the wrong name, we get corrected, we apologize if you are decent human being, then we try to call that person by the name they have informed us that they prefer. Swap name for pronoun in that scenario. What's the problem? Why can't we all just try to not be assholes? 

Secondly, I think that trans issues and trans people make others feel icky. Similar to gay and lesbian people from decades ago. They offended people by flaunted their sexuality in public by holding hands or kissing their partner. This disgusted some people. So much so that it pushed them to become violent to gay and lesbian people. Similarly to trans individuals today. They can't cope with the fact that these people exist. They don't understand and don't want to understand their lives and what they go through on a daily basis. But find them disgusting and objectionable and offensive. They get on board with laws banning gender affirming care. Not because of the data or the science but on vibes. If they can't actively harm trans people they choose to passively harm them because they are icky and abnormal. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

All evidence to the contrary. You even sited an example and proves this hypothesis wrong. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from what would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. As can be gleaned from this text from EO 14183 'Armed Forces have been afflicted with radical gender ideology to appease activists unconcerned with the requirements of military service like physical and mental health, selflessness, and unit cohesion.

So I would be hard pressed to agree that they are doing anything with, for, or to trans people out of concern for their wellbeing. 

The Secretary of Health and Human Services is decimating vaccine science and declared that gender-affirming care as being unsafe. They are not following science or their own procedures in order to harm trans people.  

Also there is no evidence that children are actively being harmed. If you have some, I would be interested to see it. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

Is this your version of 'I think I can'? Cuz that's what it seems like. If you keep saying that to yourself then it will be true? (spoiler alert) Its not. I have a feeling that you just living in a world that continues to prove you wrong on this issue(which it will) will be excruciating to you. So I am fine with you yelling at clouds because you are actively seeing how wrong you are on this subject, on a daily basis. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

 

Yes. States have the flexibility on some issues, sure. Some things should NOT be up to states. Living in different states should not offer you different freedoms. Everyone gets an education, yes. What that education entails, is up to the states. If you want a better or different education you can move or pay for private school. Commerce: similar rules to deter fraud across the board. Some are stricter than others. Health care: what is and is not allowed or offered should not vary state to state. The number of providers might vary or not exist due to lack of need but if procedures or medicines with proven efficacy are banned or criminalized. That is wrong. That is ignorant. That is purposefully harmful. Because rich people will always have the resources to get those things that are banned in different states. So that means we, as a society, have agreed to torture and punish poor people that can't move to a state to temporarily acquire what should be available to everyone. 

Not sure what you mean by 'responsible'. Do you mean paying for things? Because I don't think that's the issue. Having a federal law protecting the basic freedoms is the issue. 

BTW, churches or religious organizations own plenty of hospitals in states where certain medical procedures are free and legal yet still refuse to offer them to their patients. Many in the realm of child birth. I don't need to tell you that sometimes complications in this area have few treatments and they are quite time sensitive. 

Sorry I don't mean to yell at or make it seem like I'm attacking you. This subject is... a lot.

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

 

Old man, yells at clouds. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

 

Interesting take. 

How are you using the phrase 'biological men'?

Are we talking about chromosomes or visible physical features or what? 

And please don't say 'its common sense' or 'you already know what I mean'. Because that means you don't know and if you don't know then your first statement translates to 'The simple fact is a thing I can't explain can't give birth to a child'. Which I totally agree with. But is not really useful in conversation. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

 

Ok. That's fair. 

What do you mean by 'aren't living up to their part'? 

How are you determining what their 'part' is?

And at what point would you say someone is 'relying' on big government? Is it total funds or time or something else?

People do care. But they are also bias. Too many people refuse to help the whole group because a few MIGHT, in their mind, get something they don't deserve. As if they get to determine who deserves what. Where the counter idea is that the benefit of helping everyone is worth a small percentage possibly taking advantage. One is born out of ignorance, intolerance, and bigotry. The other is born out of compassion, empathy, and understanding.

Take health care for instance. Who takes advantage of universal health care? Poor people? No. They tend to fall into the group that is 'undeserving' of nice things. Its rich people that take advantage, so far as we've seen in our system today. Insurance fraud happens a lot. Sometimes on a massive scale. A senator from FL was CEO of a company that was fined a huge amount for committing insurance fraud for years. Its not poor people scamming EBT or food stamps that make up the bulk of fraud.   
 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

Interesting take on the subject. 

What do you mean by 'bring it into the public sphere'? What is being brought out? 

The OP made specific reference to “wingers” (I believe it was) trying to control people’s “personal lives”. I am not sure exactly what that means but my response was a generalized statement that these wingers weren’t making your private life a big deal before and they certainly didn’t bring it to the public. This also had some context to previous statements of theirs that I don’t recall at the moment.

I disagree that 'no one's trying to control these people'. I think that's exactly what is happening. Firstly, I don't think accidentally misgendering someone is the issue. That's happened since time immemorial. Its the active and sometimes aggressive misgendering that is the issue. We call each other by name sometimes. If we call someone by the wrong name, we get corrected, we apologize if you are decent human being, then we try to call that person by the name they have informed us that they prefer. Swap name for pronoun in that scenario. What's the problem? Why can't we all just try to not be assholes? 

I completely agree that people should treat everyone with love, care and decency while not controlling how they identify or interact with the world. However, what you just did there is the equal half of the issue I referenced. “If you don’t address me by the pronouns I’ve designated for you use then you’re an asshole.” The only one controlling anyone in this scenario is that person. I’m willing to meet you half way and say this is an equal parts problem…both sides can/have handled it poorly at times and to horrible degrees.

Secondly, I think that trans issues and trans people make others feel icky. Similar to gay and lesbian people from decades ago. They offended people by flaunted their sexuality in public by holding hands or kissing their partner. This disgusted some people. So much so that it pushed them to become violent to gay and lesbian people. Similarly to trans individuals today. They can't cope with the fact that these people exist. They don't understand and don't want to understand their lives and what they go through on a daily basis. But find them disgusting and objectionable and offensive. They get on board with laws banning gender affirming care. Not because of the data or the science but on vibes. If they can't actively harm trans people they choose to passively harm them because they are icky and abnormal. 

I don’t think the majority of people think that trans people are “icky”. I think the two most likely scenarios are they are uncomfortable in a situation that they don’t understand and the mental health stigma associated with it. We’ve come a long way since gay and lesbians hit the scene so to say “icky”…I’m not buying that. It discredits just how much progress has been made as a society.

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from what would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. As can be gleaned from this text from EO 14183 'Armed Forces have been afflicted with radical gender ideology to appease activists unconcerned with the requirements of military service like physical and mental health, selflessness, and unit cohesion.

So I would be hard pressed to agree that they are doing anything with, for, or to trans people out of concern for their wellbeing. 

I commented specifically on the claims that the administration does not care about kids…however the OP contextualized that I don’t remember but as far as children go the administration has enacted executive orders and things to protect children from like I said…going under the knife, taking life altering medicines etc. As far as the EO, if that is in fact a direct quotation, I think that is poorly worded to say the least. With that said the intent of that EO was not to address the health and well being of trans or whether the government cares about its citizens within that grouping. It was to say their focus is the organizations and hot button societal issues won’t be entertained in this space. We can agree or disagree about their reasoning but it does not say they don’t care about those individuals.

The Secretary of Health and Human Services is decimating vaccine science and declared that gender-affirming care as being unsafe. They are not following science or their own procedures in order to harm trans people.  

Also there is no evidence that children are actively being harmed. If you have some, I would be interested to see it. 

We have testimonies for days about the negative impacts gender affirming care has had in detransitioned people, there is a lot of evidence in the mental health field that indicates problems with treatment and/or whether that treatment was even necessary. Honestly you educated on a lot of these things so to outright evidence exist is a bit shocking and disingenuous.

Yes. States have the flexibility on some issues, sure. Some things should NOT be up to states. Living in different states should not offer you different freedoms. Everyone gets an education, yes. What that education entails, is up to the states. If you want a better or different education you can move or pay for private school. Commerce: similar rules to deter fraud across the board. Some are stricter than others. Health care: what is and is not allowed or offered should not vary state to state. The number of providers might vary or not exist due to lack of need but if procedures or medicines with proven efficacy are banned or criminalized. That is wrong. That is ignorant. That is purposefully harmful. Because rich people will always have the resources to get those things that are banned in different states. So that means we, as a society, have agreed to torture and punish poor people that can't move to a state to temporarily acquire what should be available to everyone. 

Not sure what you mean by 'responsible'. Do you mean paying for things? Because I don't think that's the issue. Having a federal law protecting the basic freedoms is the issue. 

BTW, churches or religious organizations own plenty of hospitals in states where certain medical procedures are free and legal yet still refuse to offer them to their patients. Many in the realm of child birth. I don't need to tell you that sometimes complications in this area have few treatments and they are quite time sensitive. 

See this is something that blows my mind….the people that criticize the Federal government the most want to give the most power to the government and not the states. While I from time to time criticize Big Brother but am relatively resigned to see things as they are want nothing more than the states to have as much power, control and abilities as they can. That is why we elect locally and have representatives in the first place right? Why shouldn’t we expect all these people we elect to ACTUALLY do their jobs to the best of their abilities, represent our interest as we voted and address the needs we have (and they are intimately aware of) so that we don’t need to rely on a government that should be primarily concerned with keeping us safe from external threats? All the things you’re addressing CAN be addressed by good local leadership. Not sure if I addressed everything but my reasoning behind my statements…

Posted
21 hours ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

All evidence to the contrary. You even sited an example and proves this hypothesis wrong. An anomaly that needs scientific medical interference to happen does not give you membership to the group. Yes, this is your opinion. Without evidence to back it up it is as easily dismissed as you've tried to dismiss my 'opinions' that I, however, did back up with facts. See the difference?      We all know the dna is different. An anomaly is a deviation. facts

 

Because you received medical assistance to carry a fetus, it does not make you a biological woman

And you feel this is true because...? Again this person has dna that is in cells that are growing internals that produce testerone extremely elevated to an XX woman. This person does not have ovaries and never had or will have eggs and does not menstruate. Facts 

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from That would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. At this point I consider this your opinion. Why is it you conveniently left out the language from the EO that highlights how disgusted the administration is with regard to trans people? Could it be that it made my point in a way that you can't refute? I think it is. Because the EO highlights proper decisions as disgusting is their opinion and yours. See the difference? 

How are you using the phrase Woman, when you take it upon yourself to include non-biological women and anomalies?

There is no such thing as 'biological woman'. If I am wrong please correct me by offering your working definition of woman that would include all others you consider 'biological women' and exclude the sited anomaly? If you cannot then by default they fall under the umbrella of 'woman'. How long do you require to complete this assignment? Remember if you fail to do it or even attempt it, then by default you agree with me. Trans men and women ARE men and women! 

XX chromosomes thats it 2 seconds. 

. Children don't know what's best for them always. each case is different. Statewide and community-wide systems with federal overlook can assimilate and adjust easier than a federal mandate. 

I believe that's what we had. Dislike it as much as you wanted.At this point I consider this your opinion. If you didn't believe it should be done or offered then you are under no obligation to participate with the treatment yourself. You would likely be a horrible steward to a child suffering from something that could be treated. There was no mandate that people be given treatment. Just that it was available as an option and that if doctors, guardians, and patients agreed to the treatment that they could receive the treatment. Now, it seems, there are some states that refuse to make these treatments available. THAT. IS. WRONG! It will lead to harm and death among their constituents. But they will be, almost exclusively, within one small group. That group, they have decided, is not deserving(there's that word again) of being treated with equality, dignity, or compassion. Because they are looked on as less-than or abnormal. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

XX chromosomes thats it 2 seconds. Sorry, but not even close. What about people with XX+Y or XXX or XYY or XXYY(they have two X's, do they count) or XXXY(they have an extra X, are they even more of a 'woman'?) or XXXX(same question) or XXXXY or XXXXX. Can any of these be 'women'? (btw the answer is Yes. If you say 'No' its just you wanting to not admit to losing. You're in a corner and I think you know it. That's why you are running away as quickly as you can.)  Your definition is shit. Your opinions on this topic are shit. You are not a very good thinker. No wonder why you run away as soon as you can. 

These things all happen. And if you are going to say, 'They are an anomaly, they don't count.' Then you need a reason. Not just, 'Nu uh.' Because that's what a toddler says. Are you smarter than a toddler? Then chromosomes were never your criteria. Because they disprove your 'chromosomes' argument. 

This is lazy thinking. You were convinced or tricked, probably by someone you respect or revere. You trusted them without actually looking into it much if at all. But still refuse to believe they and you could be wrong. You are. You are going about in a world with a wrong and harmful idea. I have given you the correct information. You should take some time to think on it. Read about it. Do a little bit more than scratch the surface. Because this idea and the actions that it empowers are actively harming people. You might not care about the group that it is harming and I have a feeling that is true. I do care about this group of people. But you should really consider holding ideas that don't harm people. Just a thought. 

21 hours ago, Gene Mills Fan said:

TPT I wont be answering paragraphs anymore  My time is valuable. 

I’d runaway too if I made such embarrassing comments as you’ve made. 
Scurry away. 
I’ll start the clock for when you just can’t help yourself and jump back into another conversation you are ill equipped to finish. Again. 

Posted (edited)
17 hours ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

XX chromosomes thats it 2 seconds. Sorry, but not even close. What about people with XX+Y or XXX or XYY or XXYY(they have two X's, do they count) or XXXY(they have an extra X, are they even more of a 'woman'?) or XXXX(same question) or XXXXY or XXXXX. Can any of these be 'women'? (btw the answer is Yes. If you say 'No' its just you wanting to not admit to losing. You're in a corner and I think you know it. That's why you are running away as quickly as you can.)  Your definition is shit. Your opinions on this topic are shit. You are not a very good thinker. No wonder why you run away as soon as you can. 

These things all happen. And if you are going to say, 'They are an anomaly, they don't count.' Then you need a reason. Not just, 'Nu uh.' Because that's what a toddler says. Are you smarter than a toddler? Then chromosomes were never your criteria. Because they disprove your 'chromosomes' argument. 

This is lazy thinking. You were convinced or tricked, probably by someone you respect or revere. You trusted them without actually looking into it much if at all. But still refuse to believe they and you could be wrong. You are. You are going about in a world with a wrong and harmful idea. I have given you the correct information. You should take some time to think on it. Read about it. Do a little bit more than scratch the surface. Because this idea and the actions that it empowers are actively harming people. You might not care about the group that it is harming and I have a feeling that is true. I do care about this group of people. But you should really consider holding ideas that don't harm people. Just a thought. 

I’d runaway too if I made such embarrassing comments as you’ve made. 
Scurry away. 
I’ll start the clock for when you just can’t help yourself and jump back into another conversation you are ill equipped to finish. Again. 

 yawn!!    get real    If you had a fact you wouldn't need to write all your bullshit.

Edited by Gene Mills Fan
  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted (edited)
18 hours ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

XX chromosomes thats it 2 seconds. Sorry, but not even close. What about people with XX+Y or XXX or XYY or XXYY(they have two X's, do they count) or XXXY(they have an extra X, are they even more of a 'woman'?) or XXXX(same question) or XXXXY or XXXXX. Can any of these be 'women'? (btw the answer is Yes. If you say 'No' its just you wanting to not admit to losing. You're in a corner and I think you know it. That's why you are running away as quickly as you can.)  Your definition is shit. Your opinions on this topic are shit. You are not a very good thinker. No wonder why you run away as soon as you can. 

These things all happen. And if you are going to say, 'They are an anomaly, they don't count.' Then you need a reason. Not just, 'Nu uh.' Because that's what a toddler says. Are you smarter than a toddler? Then chromosomes were never your criteria. Because they disprove your 'chromosomes' argument. 

This is lazy thinking. You were convinced or tricked, probably by someone you respect or revere. You trusted them without actually looking into it much if at all. But still refuse to believe they and you could be wrong. You are. You are going about in a world with a wrong and harmful idea. I have given you the correct information. You should take some time to think on it. Read about it. Do a little bit more than scratch the surface. Because this idea and the actions that it empowers are actively harming people. You might not care about the group that it is harming and I have a feeling that is true. I do care about this group of people. But you should really consider holding ideas that don't harm people. Just a thought. 

I’d runaway too if I made such embarrassing comments as you’ve made. 
Scurry away. 
I’ll start the clock for when you just can’t help yourself and jump back into another conversation you are ill equipped to finish. Again. 

Men cannot get pregnant. Nor can they be real women.    They can cross dress all they like and ask people to call them by the wrong pronouns.   (They can’t make you call them the wrong pronoun)  
 

#wonderwoman

Edited by Caveira
Posted
On 7/23/2026 at 8:07 PM, Simpleman424 said:

 

Interesting take on the subject. 

What do you mean by 'bring it into the public sphere'? What is being brought out? 

The OP made specific reference to “wingers” (I believe it was) trying to control people’s “personal lives”. I am not sure exactly what that means but my response was a generalized statement that these wingers weren’t making your private life a big deal before and they certainly didn’t bring it to the public. This also had some context to previous statements of theirs that I don’t recall at the moment.

I disagree that 'no one's trying to control these people'. I think that's exactly what is happening. Firstly, I don't think accidentally misgendering someone is the issue. That's happened since time immemorial. Its the active and sometimes aggressive misgendering that is the issue. We call each other by name sometimes. If we call someone by the wrong name, we get corrected, we apologize if you are decent human being, then we try to call that person by the name they have informed us that they prefer. Swap name for pronoun in that scenario. What's the problem? Why can't we all just try to not be assholes? 

I completely agree that people should treat everyone with love, care and decency while not controlling how they identify or interact with the world. However, what you just did there is the equal half of the issue I referenced. “If you don’t address me by the pronouns I’ve designated for you use then you’re an asshole.” The only one controlling anyone in this scenario is that person. I’m willing to meet you half way and say this is an equal parts problem…both sides can/have handled it poorly at times and to horrible degrees.

Secondly, I think that trans issues and trans people make others feel icky. Similar to gay and lesbian people from decades ago. They offended people by flaunted their sexuality in public by holding hands or kissing their partner. This disgusted some people. So much so that it pushed them to become violent to gay and lesbian people. Similarly to trans individuals today. They can't cope with the fact that these people exist. They don't understand and don't want to understand their lives and what they go through on a daily basis. But find them disgusting and objectionable and offensive. They get on board with laws banning gender affirming care. Not because of the data or the science but on vibes. If they can't actively harm trans people they choose to passively harm them because they are icky and abnormal. 

I don’t think the majority of people think that trans people are “icky”. I think the two most likely scenarios are they are uncomfortable in a situation that they don’t understand and the mental health stigma associated with it. We’ve come a long way since gay and lesbians hit the scene so to say “icky”…I’m not buying that. It discredits just how much progress has been made as a society.

Those things in a vacuum, I would agree, could be interpreted as trying to 'protect' people. Protecting them from what would be the question. Because they don't like trans people as a whole. As can be gleaned from this text from EO 14183 'Armed Forces have been afflicted with radical gender ideology to appease activists unconcerned with the requirements of military service like physical and mental health, selflessness, and unit cohesion.

So I would be hard pressed to agree that they are doing anything with, for, or to trans people out of concern for their wellbeing. 

I commented specifically on the claims that the administration does not care about kids…however the OP contextualized that I don’t remember but as far as children go the administration has enacted executive orders and things to protect children from like I said…going under the knife, taking life altering medicines etc. As far as the EO, if that is in fact a direct quotation, I think that is poorly worded to say the least. With that said the intent of that EO was not to address the health and well being of trans or whether the government cares about its citizens within that grouping. It was to say their focus is the organizations and hot button societal issues won’t be entertained in this space. We can agree or disagree about their reasoning but it does not say they don’t care about those individuals.

The Secretary of Health and Human Services is decimating vaccine science and declared that gender-affirming care as being unsafe. They are not following science or their own procedures in order to harm trans people.  

Also there is no evidence that children are actively being harmed. If you have some, I would be interested to see it. 

We have testimonies for days about the negative impacts gender affirming care has had in detransitioned people, there is a lot of evidence in the mental health field that indicates problems with treatment and/or whether that treatment was even necessary. Honestly you educated on a lot of these things so to outright evidence exist is a bit shocking and disingenuous.

Yes. States have the flexibility on some issues, sure. Some things should NOT be up to states. Living in different states should not offer you different freedoms. Everyone gets an education, yes. What that education entails, is up to the states. If you want a better or different education you can move or pay for private school. Commerce: similar rules to deter fraud across the board. Some are stricter than others. Health care: what is and is not allowed or offered should not vary state to state. The number of providers might vary or not exist due to lack of need but if procedures or medicines with proven efficacy are banned or criminalized. That is wrong. That is ignorant. That is purposefully harmful. Because rich people will always have the resources to get those things that are banned in different states. So that means we, as a society, have agreed to torture and punish poor people that can't move to a state to temporarily acquire what should be available to everyone. 

Not sure what you mean by 'responsible'. Do you mean paying for things? Because I don't think that's the issue. Having a federal law protecting the basic freedoms is the issue. 

BTW, churches or religious organizations own plenty of hospitals in states where certain medical procedures are free and legal yet still refuse to offer them to their patients. Many in the realm of child birth. I don't need to tell you that sometimes complications in this area have few treatments and they are quite time sensitive. 

See this is something that blows my mind….the people that criticize the Federal government the most want to give the most power to the government and not the states. While I from time to time criticize Big Brother but am relatively resigned to see things as they are want nothing more than the states to have as much power, control and abilities as they can. That is why we elect locally and have representatives in the first place right? Why shouldn’t we expect all these people we elect to ACTUALLY do their jobs to the best of their abilities, represent our interest as we voted and address the needs we have (and they are intimately aware of) so that we don’t need to rely on a government that should be primarily concerned with keeping us safe from external threats? All the things you’re addressing CAN be addressed by good local leadership. Not sure if I addressed everything but my reasoning behind my statements…

Thank you for your honest and measured responses my comments. 

The OP made specific reference to “wingers” (I believe it was) trying to control people’s “personal lives”. I am not sure exactly what that means but my response was a generalized statement that these wingers weren’t making your private life a big deal before and they certainly didn’t bring it to the public. This also had some context to previous statements of theirs that I don’t recall at the moment.

 

I completely agree that people should treat everyone with love, care and decency while not controlling how they identify or interact with the world. However, what you just did there is the equal half of the issue I referenced. “If you don’t address me by the pronouns I’ve designated for you use then you’re an asshole.” The only one controlling anyone in this scenario is that person. I’m willing to meet you half way and say this is an equal parts problem…both sides can/have handled it poorly at times and to horrible degrees. 

It seems as if you're saying that the social repercussions, like being called out as insensitive or an asshole, for purposefully ignoring the pronoun correction someone has offered is the fault of the trans person for insisting that they be referred to by the correct pronoun(s). If that is the case. I'm having a hard time squaring that circle. 

If someone tells you that you've called them by the wrong name and corrects you. You ARE an asshole by maliciously calling them by the wrong name moving forward. If that bothers you then just don't do it or you will get a reputation as being an asshole. Sucks to suck but you literally brought it on yourself. Ignorance is no longer a viable excuse. (again not YOU necessarily just a generic person that doesn't seem very nice)

I don’t think the majority of people think that trans people are “icky”. I think the two most likely scenarios are they are uncomfortable in a situation that they don’t understand and the mental health stigma associated with it. We’ve come a long way since gay and lesbians hit the scene so to say “icky”…I’m not buying that. It discredits just how much progress has been made as a society.

I agree, but a minority of people DO think trans people are 'icky'. Or more accurately they have contempt for trans people or feel disgusted by them. They are taught to feel these things by friends, family, and their algorithm, towards trans people in addition to other groups. That they are less deserving of dignity and gov't resources. Making it easier to see them as less than human and to justify treating them as problems to be fixed rather than people to be supported. Building is harder than destroying. They feel threatened. Trans people call into question many norms in society. Anticipating even tiny changes in what is considered 'normal' are considered threats to the status quo. The status quo has worked well for conservatives and they are not interested, even scared of, changing things because they might not have it so well on the other side. Change is inherently painful and conservatives tend to vehemently resist change of any kind. Especially social change. Seriously, who does it hurt to call someone by the pronouns they prefer? No one. So why push back so hard

 

I commented specifically on the claims that the administration does not care about kids…however the OP contextualized that I don’t remember but as far as children go the administration has enacted executive orders and things to protect children from like I said…going under the knife, taking life altering medicines etc. As far as the EO, if that is in fact a direct quotation, I think that is poorly worded to say the least. With that said the intent of that EO was not to address the health and well being of trans or whether the government cares about its citizens within that grouping. It was to say their focus is the organizations and hot button societal issues won’t be entertained in this space. We can agree or disagree about their reasoning but it does not say they don’t care about those individuals.

It does not say that out right. But the actions that follow the order DOES. Firing members of the military that are trans gender and cancelling gender affirming care for veterans on a whim does say tell me that they DO NOT care about these people or what they have done in service to the country. Those are not children. They should be allowed to receive the health care they've earned with their service. 

Kids going under the knife is exactly the same argument as voter ID. The numbers of 'children' getting gender affirming surgery is vanishingly small to begin with. But always in consultation with one or more doctors over quite a long period of time leading up to it. They are not sudden decisions. Let alone the regret rate. Everything has a regret rate. Winning the lottery has a regret rate. That is not how we determine necessary health care initiatives. These bans will not effect rich people. So we have decided to torture poor kids and their parents by not allowing them to get the health care that they need. Kids will die and parents will lose their children because the people that find trans people 'icky' are ok with these laws because they can rationalize it but do not consider how desperate some families are for this care. 

 

We have testimonies for days about the negative impacts gender affirming care has had in detransitioned people, there is a lot of evidence in the mental health field that indicates problems with treatment and/or whether that treatment was even necessary. Honestly you educated on a lot of these things so to outright evidence exist is a bit shocking and disingenuous.

A fraction of a fraction of a still smaller fraction of people feel they may have been misdiagnosed and now have trauma. That is tragic. Of a group that is made up of <4% of the population(<100% of THAT group feel they need gender affirming care) <3% of those that seek out gender affirming care have regrets. Which means 1/10th of 1% of the whole population has regretted gender affirming care. That is not a good enough reason for me to prevent the option for this care. I'm curious if you are ok with such a tiny population affecting the whole? 

I don't think there is 'a lot of evidence... indicates problems with treatment.... even necessary'. Every professional medical association in the country agrees that this care IS necessary and effective. 

Here and Here

Not that evidence doesn't exist. Of course there is evidence against it. But its not reliable. That is the issue. If the evidence is not reliable there is no reason to believe it. My links should outweigh any anecdotal evidence you might find. If it doesn't I would love to know why? 

 

See this is something that blows my mind….the people that criticize the Federal government the most want to give the most power to the government and not the states. While I from time to time criticize Big Brother but am relatively resigned to see things as they are want nothing more than the states to have as much power, control and abilities as they can. That is why we elect locally and have representatives in the first place right? Why shouldn’t we expect all these people we elect to ACTUALLY do their jobs to the best of their abilities, represent our interest as we voted and address the needs we have (and they are intimately aware of) so that we don’t need to rely on a government that should be primarily concerned with keeping us safe from external threats? All the things you’re addressing CAN be addressed by good local leadership. Not sure if I addressed everything but my reasoning behind my statements…

I think the point is that health care treatment options shouldn't change from state to state. Health care is too important to individual and societal health to allow for such varieties. Whether or not an area as the need or financial ability to provide certain care is one thing. But to BAN anything in the realm of health care is wrong. The process by which science based health care options are developed helps to ensure the efficacy, effectiveness, and necessity of the treatments. To ban something that has been tested and retested and retested again because 'its just common sense' is ignorant and cruel. But they don't see it as cruel because they have rationalized doing it because the group is too small to really matter and are made up of people they feel is ok to mistreat in such a way.

Posted
10 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Thank you for your honest and measured responses my comments. 

The OP made specific reference to “wingers” (I believe it was) trying to control people’s “personal lives”. I am not sure exactly what that means but my response was a generalized statement that these wingers weren’t making your private life a big deal before and they certainly didn’t bring it to the public. This also had some context to previous statements of theirs that I don’t recall at the moment.

 

I completely agree that people should treat everyone with love, care and decency while not controlling how they identify or interact with the world. However, what you just did there is the equal half of the issue I referenced. “If you don’t address me by the pronouns I’ve designated for you use then you’re an asshole.” The only one controlling anyone in this scenario is that person. I’m willing to meet you half way and say this is an equal parts problem…both sides can/have handled it poorly at times and to horrible degrees. 

It seems as if you're saying that the social repercussions, like being called out as insensitive or an asshole, for purposefully ignoring the pronoun correction someone has offered is the fault of the trans person for insisting that they be referred to by the correct pronoun(s). If that is the case. I'm having a hard time squaring that circle. 

If someone tells you that you've called them by the wrong name and corrects you. You ARE an asshole by maliciously calling them by the wrong name moving forward. If that bothers you then just don't do it or you will get a reputation as being an asshole. Sucks to suck but you literally brought it on yourself. Ignorance is no longer a viable excuse. (again not YOU necessarily just a generic person that doesn't seem very nice)

I don’t think the majority of people think that trans people are “icky”. I think the two most likely scenarios are they are uncomfortable in a situation that they don’t understand and the mental health stigma associated with it. We’ve come a long way since gay and lesbians hit the scene so to say “icky”…I’m not buying that. It discredits just how much progress has been made as a society.

I agree, but a minority of people DO think trans people are 'icky'. Or more accurately they have contempt for trans people or feel disgusted by them. They are taught to feel these things by friends, family, and their algorithm, towards trans people in addition to other groups. That they are less deserving of dignity and gov't resources. Making it easier to see them as less than human and to justify treating them as problems to be fixed rather than people to be supported. Building is harder than destroying. They feel threatened. Trans people call into question many norms in society. Anticipating even tiny changes in what is considered 'normal' are considered threats to the status quo. The status quo has worked well for conservatives and they are not interested, even scared of, changing things because they might not have it so well on the other side. Change is inherently painful and conservatives tend to vehemently resist change of any kind. Especially social change. Seriously, who does it hurt to call someone by the pronouns they prefer? No one. So why push back so hard

 

I commented specifically on the claims that the administration does not care about kids…however the OP contextualized that I don’t remember but as far as children go the administration has enacted executive orders and things to protect children from like I said…going under the knife, taking life altering medicines etc. As far as the EO, if that is in fact a direct quotation, I think that is poorly worded to say the least. With that said the intent of that EO was not to address the health and well being of trans or whether the government cares about its citizens within that grouping. It was to say their focus is the organizations and hot button societal issues won’t be entertained in this space. We can agree or disagree about their reasoning but it does not say they don’t care about those individuals.

It does not say that out right. But the actions that follow the order DOES. Firing members of the military that are trans gender and cancelling gender affirming care for veterans on a whim does say tell me that they DO NOT care about these people or what they have done in service to the country. Those are not children. They should be allowed to receive the health care they've earned with their service. 

Kids going under the knife is exactly the same argument as voter ID. The numbers of 'children' getting gender affirming surgery is vanishingly small to begin with. But always in consultation with one or more doctors over quite a long period of time leading up to it. They are not sudden decisions. Let alone the regret rate. Everything has a regret rate. Winning the lottery has a regret rate. That is not how we determine necessary health care initiatives. These bans will not effect rich people. So we have decided to torture poor kids and their parents by not allowing them to get the health care that they need. Kids will die and parents will lose their children because the people that find trans people 'icky' are ok with these laws because they can rationalize it but do not consider how desperate some families are for this care. 

 

We have testimonies for days about the negative impacts gender affirming care has had in detransitioned people, there is a lot of evidence in the mental health field that indicates problems with treatment and/or whether that treatment was even necessary. Honestly you educated on a lot of these things so to outright evidence exist is a bit shocking and disingenuous.

A fraction of a fraction of a still smaller fraction of people feel they may have been misdiagnosed and now have trauma. That is tragic. Of a group that is made up of <4% of the population(<100% of THAT group feel they need gender affirming care) <3% of those that seek out gender affirming care have regrets. Which means 1/10th of 1% of the whole population has regretted gender affirming care. That is not a good enough reason for me to prevent the option for this care. I'm curious if you are ok with such a tiny population affecting the whole? 

I don't think there is 'a lot of evidence... indicates problems with treatment.... even necessary'. Every professional medical association in the country agrees that this care IS necessary and effective. 

Here and Here

Not that evidence doesn't exist. Of course there is evidence against it. But its not reliable. That is the issue. If the evidence is not reliable there is no reason to believe it. My links should outweigh any anecdotal evidence you might find. If it doesn't I would love to know why? 

 

See this is something that blows my mind….the people that criticize the Federal government the most want to give the most power to the government and not the states. While I from time to time criticize Big Brother but am relatively resigned to see things as they are want nothing more than the states to have as much power, control and abilities as they can. That is why we elect locally and have representatives in the first place right? Why shouldn’t we expect all these people we elect to ACTUALLY do their jobs to the best of their abilities, represent our interest as we voted and address the needs we have (and they are intimately aware of) so that we don’t need to rely on a government that should be primarily concerned with keeping us safe from external threats? All the things you’re addressing CAN be addressed by good local leadership. Not sure if I addressed everything but my reasoning behind my statements…

I think the point is that health care treatment options shouldn't change from state to state. Health care is too important to individual and societal health to allow for such varieties. Whether or not an area as the need or financial ability to provide certain care is one thing. But to BAN anything in the realm of health care is wrong. The process by which science based health care options are developed helps to ensure the efficacy, effectiveness, and necessity of the treatments. To ban something that has been tested and retested and retested again because 'its just common sense' is ignorant and cruel. But they don't see it as cruel because they have rationalized doing it because the group is too small to really matter and are made up of people they feel is ok to mistreat in such a way.

Sex change health care should not be paid for by our tax dollars.  It should be purely elective and on the person with the mental health issue to pay for it. 

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
21 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

https://www.kttc.com/2026/07/29/us-department-education-opens-inquiry-into-minnesota-schools-over-mygenderdolls-complaint/
 

my gender dolls with removable and replacement parts will be available in Minnesota schools down to age four.  Sick f u k I n g groomers.  

Once again you are assigning a strawman motive that you still have no evidence for. 
Why can't you make your case before attempting to deliver the verdict? 
 
Shaming kids about this subject makes it less likely they will tell someone about possible 'grooming' from the people in their lives that are most likely to do it... a relative. 
 
 
All history aside, if you really cared about this topic you would try to educate yourself and not give the same knee jerk reaction you have to everyone that you feel is a perceived enemy. No one wants to hurt kids. At least there is no evidence to make that point clear and making outlandish claims don't really help if there really was a problem. Abstinence-only sex ed doesn't work. Its harmful. It leads to higher rates of teen pregnancy, later unwanted pregnancy, and higher rates of STI's. None of these are good. 
Not to mention that kids are more likely to communicate questionable behavior, and adults are more likely to take it serious, if they can do so using the correct terminology and are not shamed into thinking it was their fault.  
 
Yelling 'groomer' at the top of your lungs does nothing to help kids if that is your real intent. Yes, it helps politically if THAT is your goal. But we can both agree its a pretty shitty thing to do if you are not 100% sure. 
 
Some resources for you:
 
I know this might be beating a dead horse but I would strongly encourage you to reconsider where and from whom you get your information and why you have so much trust in the sources that you do. Because your opinions on this and many other topics are not only wrong and outdated but harmful. They seem based in bias or worse and if you really do want to help, that's great but try not to let your need/want to help let you get twisted around into doing the opposite. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

Posted
36 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Once again you are assigning a strawman motive that you still have no evidence for. 
Why can't you make your case before attempting to deliver the verdict? 
 
Shaming kids about this subject makes it less likely they will tell someone about possible 'grooming' from the people in their lives that are most likely to do it... a relative. 
 
 
All history aside, if you really cared about this topic you would try to educate yourself and not give the same knee jerk reaction you have to everyone that you feel is a perceived enemy. No one wants to hurt kids. At least there is no evidence to make that point clear and making outlandish claims don't really help if there really was a problem. Abstinence-only sex ed doesn't work. Its harmful. It leads to higher rates of teen pregnancy, later unwanted pregnancy, and higher rates of STI's. None of these are good. 
Not to mention that kids are more likely to communicate questionable behavior, and adults are more likely to take it serious, if they can do so using the correct terminology and are not shamed into thinking it was their fault.  
 
Yelling 'groomer' at the top of your lungs does nothing to help kids if that is your real intent. Yes, it helps politically if THAT is your goal. But we can both agree its a pretty shitty thing to do if you are not 100% sure. 
 
Some resources for you:
 
I know this might be beating a dead horse but I would strongly encourage you to reconsider where and from whom you get your information and why you have so much trust in the sources that you do. Because your opinions on this and many other topics are not only wrong and outdated but harmful. They seem based in bias or worse and if you really do want to help, that's great but try not to let your need/want to help let you get twisted around into doing the opposite. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

I 110% knew that would draw our resident groomer out from under his rock. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
37 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Once again you are assigning a strawman motive that you still have no evidence for. 
Why can't you make your case before attempting to deliver the verdict? 
 
Shaming kids about this subject makes it less likely they will tell someone about possible 'grooming' from the people in their lives that are most likely to do it... a relative. 
 
 
All history aside, if you really cared about this topic you would try to educate yourself and not give the same knee jerk reaction you have to everyone that you feel is a perceived enemy. No one wants to hurt kids. At least there is no evidence to make that point clear and making outlandish claims don't really help if there really was a problem. Abstinence-only sex ed doesn't work. Its harmful. It leads to higher rates of teen pregnancy, later unwanted pregnancy, and higher rates of STI's. None of these are good. 
Not to mention that kids are more likely to communicate questionable behavior, and adults are more likely to take it serious, if they can do so using the correct terminology and are not shamed into thinking it was their fault.  
 
Yelling 'groomer' at the top of your lungs does nothing to help kids if that is your real intent. Yes, it helps politically if THAT is your goal. But we can both agree its a pretty shitty thing to do if you are not 100% sure. 
 
Some resources for you:
 
I know this might be beating a dead horse but I would strongly encourage you to reconsider where and from whom you get your information and why you have so much trust in the sources that you do. Because your opinions on this and many other topics are not only wrong and outdated but harmful. They seem based in bias or worse and if you really do want to help, that's great but try not to let your need/want to help let you get twisted around into doing the opposite. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

No one wants to hurt kids.  Bahahahahahhahahahahahah.  Hacking off body parts isn’t helping them soooooooo

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
39 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Once again you are assigning a strawman motive that you still have no evidence for. 
Why can't you make your case before attempting to deliver the verdict? 
 
Shaming kids about this subject makes it less likely they will tell someone about possible 'grooming' from the people in their lives that are most likely to do it... a relative. 
 
 
All history aside, if you really cared about this topic you would try to educate yourself and not give the same knee jerk reaction you have to everyone that you feel is a perceived enemy. No one wants to hurt kids. At least there is no evidence to make that point clear and making outlandish claims don't really help if there really was a problem. Abstinence-only sex ed doesn't work. Its harmful. It leads to higher rates of teen pregnancy, later unwanted pregnancy, and higher rates of STI's. None of these are good. 
Not to mention that kids are more likely to communicate questionable behavior, and adults are more likely to take it serious, if they can do so using the correct terminology and are not shamed into thinking it was their fault.  
 
Yelling 'groomer' at the top of your lungs does nothing to help kids if that is your real intent. Yes, it helps politically if THAT is your goal. But we can both agree its a pretty shitty thing to do if you are not 100% sure. 
 
Some resources for you:
 
I know this might be beating a dead horse but I would strongly encourage you to reconsider where and from whom you get your information and why you have so much trust in the sources that you do. Because your opinions on this and many other topics are not only wrong and outdated but harmful. They seem based in bias or worse and if you really do want to help, that's great but try not to let your need/want to help let you get twisted around into doing the opposite. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

You can preach all you want. It won’t change the fact that groomers are sick f u k s. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted (edited)
43 minutes ago, ThreePointTakedown said:

 

Once again you are assigning a strawman motive that you still have no evidence for. 
Why can't you make your case before attempting to deliver the verdict? 
 
Shaming kids about this subject makes it less likely they will tell someone about possible 'grooming' from the people in their lives that are most likely to do it... a relative. 
 
 
All history aside, if you really cared about this topic you would try to educate yourself and not give the same knee jerk reaction you have to everyone that you feel is a perceived enemy. No one wants to hurt kids. At least there is no evidence to make that point clear and making outlandish claims don't really help if there really was a problem. Abstinence-only sex ed doesn't work. Its harmful. It leads to higher rates of teen pregnancy, later unwanted pregnancy, and higher rates of STI's. None of these are good. 
Not to mention that kids are more likely to communicate questionable behavior, and adults are more likely to take it serious, if they can do so using the correct terminology and are not shamed into thinking it was their fault.  
 
Yelling 'groomer' at the top of your lungs does nothing to help kids if that is your real intent. Yes, it helps politically if THAT is your goal. But we can both agree its a pretty shitty thing to do if you are not 100% sure. 
 
Some resources for you:
 
I know this might be beating a dead horse but I would strongly encourage you to reconsider where and from whom you get your information and why you have so much trust in the sources that you do. Because your opinions on this and many other topics are not only wrong and outdated but harmful. They seem based in bias or worse and if you really do want to help, that's great but try not to let your need/want to help let you get twisted around into doing the opposite. 

And once again....  

HAPPY PRIDE XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX 

But your sources are correct huh???    🤦‍♂️ My source is a local Minnesota tv station.   

Edited by JimmySpeaks

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted

Christian PA Fired Over Transgender Referrals, Pronouns Wins $410K Settlement as Hospital Adopts New Policy

FIRST ON THE DAILY SIGNAL—A Christian physician assistant fired after refusing to participate in transgender procedures and use preferred pronouns has reached a settlement with the University of Michigan Health-West, which agreed to adopt new religious freedom protections for employees and pay $410,000.

“All I wanted to do was provide the best care possible to my patients without being forced to violate my Christian beliefs,” Valerie Kloosterman, who received positive reviews while working at the hospital for 17 years before getting fired in 2021, said in a statement first provided to the Daily Signal.

Kloosterman and the hospital reached a settlement Tuesday, which requires the hospital to create a religious accommodation policy and pay $410,000 to Kloosterman and her attorneys. The presiding judge dismissed the case after the settlement.

The settlement marks a dramatic reversal from the hospital’s alleged position in 2021. According to the lawsuit, hospital officials told Kloosterman she could not exercise her religious beliefs at work, labeled her “evil,” blamed her for gender-related suicides, and terminated her after she sought a religious accommodation.

“Title VII [of the Civil Rights Act of 1964] prohibits employers from discriminating against and punishing employees for their faith,” Kayla Toney, counsel at First Liberty, which represented Kloosterman, said in a statement. “Valerie is an exceptional physician assistant who cares for each of her patients.”

“Employers cannot drive out people like Valerie just because of their sincere religious beliefs,” Toney added. “We are grateful to have resolved this matter with University of Michigan Health-West.”

https://www.dailysignal.com/2026/07/29/christian-pa-fired-over-pronouns-transgender-referrals-wins-410k-settlement-hospital-adopts-new-policy/

 

Posted
21 hours ago, JimmySpeaks said:

No one wants to hurt kids.  Bahahahahahhahahahahahah.  Hacking off body parts isn’t helping them soooooooo

How about Trump assaulting kids at Epstein Island? 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
4 minutes ago, red viking said:

How about Trump assaulting kids at Epstein Island? 

Show your proof. Oh wait you can’t.  More lies from skippy. 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
56 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

Show your proof. Oh wait you can’t.  More lies from skippy. 

Dont need proof unless its for a conviction idiot. It likely happened though. He's a pedo p.o.s  just like many wingers are. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
1 hour ago, red viking said:

Dont need proof unless its for a conviction idiot. It likely happened though. He's a pedo p.o.s  just like many wingers are. 

You sure use the word likely a lot.  Nothing but your opinion Skippy 

  • Wrestle +1 1

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...