At least in the US...I'm not familiar with international sports. Penn State wrestling's current run (11 out of the last 13 contested championships) is better than the Tom Brady Patriots, the Golden State Warriors, the late 90s-2000 Yankees, etc.
Our only data points are the Soldier Salute where he narrowly won (lost) to Zach Glazier who ended up going 1-2 at NCAAs. Would he have won 197 or HWT?
The most impressive stats here are the fact that lower seeded Penn State wrestlers are more likely to win than their higher seeded opponents in the semis and finals. This means in-match coaching and gameplanning are making the difference.
What will never happen again? I'm a Penn State fan and I think someone else will have a 4x undefeated career just like Cael. I certainly think someone else can win 4x titles at 4 weights (especially since there's no requirement to be undefeated).
What evidence is there that Dake wasn't at his natural weight? He grew throughout his 4 years of college and hence bumped up weight classes. It's not like he shrunk down to his "natural" weight after he finished competing in college. He wrestled the optimal weight for his body as he grew.
It's shocking to me that he hasn't been poached to be a head coach. Listen to any interview with former Penn State wrestlers, or watch who a Penn State wrestler hugs first after winning a NCAA title. There's a reason Penn State's most successful weights have been middleweights 157-184 over the last decade. If Iowa wants to retake the mountain making Cunningham their new HC would be the biggest, fastest and most effective move to make.
Assuming Bartlett, Starocci and Kerkvliet don't come back.
125 Lillledahl
133 Davis
141 Kasak
149 SVN
157 Mesenbrink
165 Haines
174 [transfer - how about Dean Hamiti?]
184 [transfer - how about Parker Keckeisen?]
197 [transfer - does Michael Beard want to come home?]
HWT [Kerk seems like he may come back. If not, Nathan Taylor from Lehigh?]
Perhaps we can tier them by dominance at their peak in college
Tier S - these guys make their opponents look silly; winning is so easily they just experiment with new moves during matches
Ruth
Taylor
Zain
Nolf
Nickal
Tier A - very dominant where the outcome is never in doubt and almost always bonus
Brooks
Starocci
Tier B
RBY
Joseph
Wright
Lee
Haines
Kerk
Tier C
Hall
Cassar
Dean
Brown
Megaludis
Molinaro
Davis
Agree, and Dake was HUGE in each of those weight classes. He never looked small for the weight he was in. For example, Frank Molinaro was a hulk at 149 and Dake made him look 20 pounds lighter. Dake must have bird bones.