Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

What Mohamed Atta Was Trying to Tell Us

After 25 years, it is time for the West to face the true cause of 9/11

BY
SEPTEMBER 08, 2026
 
 

In April 1996, more than five years before he steered American Airlines Flight 11 into the North Tower, Mohamed Atta sat in a small Hamburg apartment and wrote his last will and testament. He was 27, an architecture student at the Technical University, the son of a Cairo lawyer, fluent in German, and living comfortably in one of the most affluent societies on earth.

Nothing in his circumstances compelled him to dwell on death. Yet he gave detailed instructions for the handling of his corpse. “I don’t want any women to go to my grave at all during my funeral or on any occasion thereafter,” he wrote. He did not want a pregnant woman, or “a person who is not clean,” to come and say goodbye. The man who washed his body should wear gloves so as not to touch his genitals. He was to be wrapped in three white pieces of unadorned cloth, laid on his right side facing Mecca, and buried “next to good Muslims.” His money was to be divided “according to the Muslim religion as almighty God has asked us to do.”

There is no political program and no mention of foreign policy or economic grievances in the document. There is only a young Muslim man, in a German apartment, arranging to sacrifice his life to Allah in the confidence that Allah will reward his martyrdom in the life to come. The will was witnessed by fellow believers at the al-Quds mosque, where Atta prayed in Arabic, grew his beard, and where, four years later, he would meet the men he would die with.

The document is among the most neglected pieces of evidence from Sept. 11 because it contradicts the explanations of the attack that most Western commentators preferred. Atta was not poor. He was not radicalized by drone strikes that had not yet happened, nor by American support for Israel. He was not in any formal or organizational sense an “Islamist.” Rather, he had an uncompromising and militant commitment to Islam that he was ready to die for.

Yet for 25 years Western elites repeatedly insisted that men like Atta must have been driven by something other than the culture and the faith that provided him with a lens through which his actions seemed both sensible and necessary. After 9/11, intellectuals and policymakers asked “what went wrong?” as though the source of Atta’s animus toward the West was shrouded in some deep mystery. In the Western experience, men had not killed other men over religious questions en masse since the end of the great religious wars of the 17th century. Culture, a term that was once understood to encompass a great many facets of human identity, experience, and belonging—religion included—had also been ruled out. Saying that cultural differences exist and should be respected was a foundation of the multicultural order; the idea that some cultures might lead people to murder each other, for reasons that do not appear in the Western rationalist list of sane causes, struck many Western liberals as too close to racism to bother arguing the point.

Since then, each time the West collided with Islam, much of the Western intellectual class reached for explanations that made sense within its own secular humanist categories: grievance, humiliation, underdevelopment, alienation, foreign policy frustration, or the failure of Western states to properly integrate men like Atta, who were, or must be, inherently no different than immigrants of similar age, class, and educational attainments from Vietnam or Poland, or anyplace else. Since all conflicts are material in origin, it was assumed that they could be settled though material means. And given the obvious superiority of Western values, as measured through the superior material attainments of the West, conflicts over land, jobs, dignity, sovereignty, or redistribution should be negotiated with the generosity appropriate to those who occupy positions of immense privilege and power, thanks to the inequities of European colonialism. If Muslim populations suffered from a democracy deficit, elections would reveal and moderate those demands. In every case, theology and culture were translated into psychology, economics, development policy, or diplomacy.

American leaders then added a second layer of denial. President George W. Bush stood at the Islamic Center of Washington to insist that “the face of terror is not the true faith of Islam.” Following Bush’s lead, after later atrocities in Paris, Brussels, Manchester, and elsewhere, Western leaders repeatedly said that the killers had “nothing to do with Islam.” At the same time, the notion of “Abrahamic faiths” was revived or normalized, as though Judaism, Christianity, and Islam were merely variations within one spiritual family, separated by temperament more than by theology or civilizational ambition.


 
 
  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
5 hours ago, Offthemat said:

What Mohamed Atta Was Trying to Tell Us

After 25 years, it is time for the West to face the true cause of 9/11

BY
SEPTEMBER 08, 2026
 
 

In April 1996, more than five years before he steered American Airlines Flight 11 into the North Tower, Mohamed Atta sat in a small Hamburg apartment and wrote his last will and testament. He was 27, an architecture student at the Technical University, the son of a Cairo lawyer, fluent in German, and living comfortably in one of the most affluent societies on earth.

Nothing in his circumstances compelled him to dwell on death. Yet he gave detailed instructions for the handling of his corpse. “I don’t want any women to go to my grave at all during my funeral or on any occasion thereafter,” he wrote. He did not want a pregnant woman, or “a person who is not clean,” to come and say goodbye. The man who washed his body should wear gloves so as not to touch his genitals. He was to be wrapped in three white pieces of unadorned cloth, laid on his right side facing Mecca, and buried “next to good Muslims.” His money was to be divided “according to the Muslim religion as almighty God has asked us to do.”

There is no political program and no mention of foreign policy or economic grievances in the document. There is only a young Muslim man, in a German apartment, arranging to sacrifice his life to Allah in the confidence that Allah will reward his martyrdom in the life to come. The will was witnessed by fellow believers at the al-Quds mosque, where Atta prayed in Arabic, grew his beard, and where, four years later, he would meet the men he would die with.

The document is among the most neglected pieces of evidence from Sept. 11 because it contradicts the explanations of the attack that most Western commentators preferred. Atta was not poor. He was not radicalized by drone strikes that had not yet happened, nor by American support for Israel. He was not in any formal or organizational sense an “Islamist.” Rather, he had an uncompromising and militant commitment to Islam that he was ready to die for.

Yet for 25 years Western elites repeatedly insisted that men like Atta must have been driven by something other than the culture and the faith that provided him with a lens through which his actions seemed both sensible and necessary. After 9/11, intellectuals and policymakers asked “what went wrong?” as though the source of Atta’s animus toward the West was shrouded in some deep mystery. In the Western experience, men had not killed other men over religious questions en masse since the end of the great religious wars of the 17th century. Culture, a term that was once understood to encompass a great many facets of human identity, experience, and belonging—religion included—had also been ruled out. Saying that cultural differences exist and should be respected was a foundation of the multicultural order; the idea that some cultures might lead people to murder each other, for reasons that do not appear in the Western rationalist list of sane causes, struck many Western liberals as too close to racism to bother arguing the point.

Since then, each time the West collided with Islam, much of the Western intellectual class reached for explanations that made sense within its own secular humanist categories: grievance, humiliation, underdevelopment, alienation, foreign policy frustration, or the failure of Western states to properly integrate men like Atta, who were, or must be, inherently no different than immigrants of similar age, class, and educational attainments from Vietnam or Poland, or anyplace else. Since all conflicts are material in origin, it was assumed that they could be settled though material means. And given the obvious superiority of Western values, as measured through the superior material attainments of the West, conflicts over land, jobs, dignity, sovereignty, or redistribution should be negotiated with the generosity appropriate to those who occupy positions of immense privilege and power, thanks to the inequities of European colonialism. If Muslim populations suffered from a democracy deficit, elections would reveal and moderate those demands. In every case, theology and culture were translated into psychology, economics, development policy, or diplomacy.

American leaders then added a second layer of denial. President George W. Bush stood at the Islamic Center of Washington to insist that “the face of terror is not the true faith of Islam.” Following Bush’s lead, after later atrocities in Paris, Brussels, Manchester, and elsewhere, Western leaders repeatedly said that the killers had “nothing to do with Islam.” At the same time, the notion of “Abrahamic faiths” was revived or normalized, as though Judaism, Christianity, and Islam were merely variations within one spiritual family, separated by temperament more than by theology or civilizational ambition.


 
 

F u c k I n g psycho

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted (edited)
6 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

F u c k I n g psycho

They’re monsters and the radical left all of a sudden support them 

what atta wanted 

  • Exclusion of Women: He explicitly stated that no women—especially pregnant women—should attend his funeral or ever visit his grave.
  • Bodily Purity: He required that the person washing his corpse wear gloves so as not to directly touch his genitals, and forbid anyone who was "not clean" from saying goodbye.
  • Sharia Wealth Distribution: He ordered that his money be divided strictly according to Islamic law (Sharia).
  • Religious Martyrdom: He wanted to sacrifice his life to Allah, operating under the absolute confidence that he would be rewarded in the afterlife.
Edited by Caveira
Posted

Benjamin Weingarten on X  @bhweingarten
 

The rational domestic response to 9/11 would have been for the federal government to engage in an extensive study of Islam, Sharia, the ideology and practices of both violent jihadist organizations and "civilizational jihadist" organizations, and then to calibrate a whole-of-government response to neutralize the threat posed by those animated by that ideology, and prevent it from coming to our shores and metastasizing to the greatest extent possible under the law.

Authorities would have surmised that our foes' primary goal was to spread Islam over the world; that they would impose their totalitarian system using any and all means necessary; that that system was inherently incompatible with America, posed an existential threat to our republican system, and that its adherents would seek to exploit all of our freedoms -- including our commitment to religious liberty -- to advance their antithetical political and social project under banner of religion. 

They would have acknowledged, in short, that our commitment to religious (and all other) freedom requires us to prevent threats to that freedom clad in religious garb -- including from those seeking to overthrow our nation with a hostile, totalitarian, theopolitical ideology in the name of Allah.

Our response would have included closing the borders, a total freeze on immigration only to thaw once policies had been implemented to mitigate the threat, the rolling up and eliminating of Islamic supremacist support networks, deporting non-citizen promoters of such subversive and revolutionary ideology, likely a related denaturalization effort, eliminating foreign funding mechanisms of such activities to all relevant public and private institutions, etc. -- anything and everything possible under the law to prevent Islamic supremacists from operating in or coming to the U.S., influencing let alone coercing us, and advancing their subversive cause in our body politic.

The Constitution is not a suicide pact and no one has a constitutional right to use our freedoms against us by working to overthrow the U.S. with a totalitarian political system in the name of a faith.

Instead, what has our domestic response been?

Its primary feature, beyond the mushrooming of the security state and imbuing of it with awesome new authorities -- sometimes turned on law-abiding Americans in violation of our rights -- and the imposing of a slew of inconveniences and costs on all Americans, has been to abide if not encourage mass Islamic immigration and integration into every aspect of American society.

Is that rational?

Posted
20 hours ago, Offthemat said:

What Mohamed Atta Was Trying to Tell Us

After 25 years, it is time for the West to face the true cause of 9/11

BY
SEPTEMBER 08, 2026
 
 

In April 1996, more than five years before he steered American Airlines Flight 11 into the North Tower, Mohamed Atta sat in a small Hamburg apartment and wrote his last will and testament. He was 27, an architecture student at the Technical University, the son of a Cairo lawyer, fluent in German, and living comfortably in one of the most affluent societies on earth.

Nothing in his circumstances compelled him to dwell on death. Yet he gave detailed instructions for the handling of his corpse. “I don’t want any women to go to my grave at all during my funeral or on any occasion thereafter,” he wrote. He did not want a pregnant woman, or “a person who is not clean,” to come and say goodbye. The man who washed his body should wear gloves so as not to touch his genitals. He was to be wrapped in three white pieces of unadorned cloth, laid on his right side facing Mecca, and buried “next to good Muslims.” His money was to be divided “according to the Muslim religion as almighty God has asked us to do.”

There is no political program and no mention of foreign policy or economic grievances in the document. There is only a young Muslim man, in a German apartment, arranging to sacrifice his life to Allah in the confidence that Allah will reward his martyrdom in the life to come. The will was witnessed by fellow believers at the al-Quds mosque, where Atta prayed in Arabic, grew his beard, and where, four years later, he would meet the men he would die with.

The document is among the most neglected pieces of evidence from Sept. 11 because it contradicts the explanations of the attack that most Western commentators preferred. Atta was not poor. He was not radicalized by drone strikes that had not yet happened, nor by American support for Israel. He was not in any formal or organizational sense an “Islamist.” Rather, he had an uncompromising and militant commitment to Islam that he was ready to die for.

Yet for 25 years Western elites repeatedly insisted that men like Atta must have been driven by something other than the culture and the faith that provided him with a lens through which his actions seemed both sensible and necessary. After 9/11, intellectuals and policymakers asked “what went wrong?” as though the source of Atta’s animus toward the West was shrouded in some deep mystery. In the Western experience, men had not killed other men over religious questions en masse since the end of the great religious wars of the 17th century. Culture, a term that was once understood to encompass a great many facets of human identity, experience, and belonging—religion included—had also been ruled out. Saying that cultural differences exist and should be respected was a foundation of the multicultural order; the idea that some cultures might lead people to murder each other, for reasons that do not appear in the Western rationalist list of sane causes, struck many Western liberals as too close to racism to bother arguing the point.

Since then, each time the West collided with Islam, much of the Western intellectual class reached for explanations that made sense within its own secular humanist categories: grievance, humiliation, underdevelopment, alienation, foreign policy frustration, or the failure of Western states to properly integrate men like Atta, who were, or must be, inherently no different than immigrants of similar age, class, and educational attainments from Vietnam or Poland, or anyplace else. Since all conflicts are material in origin, it was assumed that they could be settled though material means. And given the obvious superiority of Western values, as measured through the superior material attainments of the West, conflicts over land, jobs, dignity, sovereignty, or redistribution should be negotiated with the generosity appropriate to those who occupy positions of immense privilege and power, thanks to the inequities of European colonialism. If Muslim populations suffered from a democracy deficit, elections would reveal and moderate those demands. In every case, theology and culture were translated into psychology, economics, development policy, or diplomacy.

American leaders then added a second layer of denial. President George W. Bush stood at the Islamic Center of Washington to insist that “the face of terror is not the true faith of Islam.” Following Bush’s lead, after later atrocities in Paris, Brussels, Manchester, and elsewhere, Western leaders repeatedly said that the killers had “nothing to do with Islam.” At the same time, the notion of “Abrahamic faiths” was revived or normalized, as though Judaism, Christianity, and Islam were merely variations within one spiritual family, separated by temperament more than by theology or civilizational ambition.


 
 

This is 110% garbage. All the hijackers were members of al qaeda, Osama bin Laden was the head of al qaeda, and spoke constantly about his grievances toward israel and u.s  support of israel. 

If you're dumb enough to think that wasnt a factor, simply because it wasnt mentioned in this essay from this one guy, I have a glacier to sell you. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted

Osama bin Laden cited U.S. support for Israel as one of his primary justifications for attacks against American targets, including the September 11 terrorist attacks. [1, 2]

Core Arguments Against U.S. Support for Israel

The "Letter to America" (2002): In his Letter to the American People, bin Laden wrote that the "creation and continuation of Israel is one of the greatest crimes" and labeled the United States as the leader of its creators. [1, 2]

Collective Blame: He argued that American citizens were not innocent because they paid taxes that funded the U.S. military and financial aid supporting Israel's actions and policies toward Palestinians. [1, 2]

Accusations of Hypocrisy: He criticized successive U.S. administrations for ignoring the decades-long displacement and occupation of Palestinians while enabling Israel. [1, 2]

Threats and Continuing Statements

Condition for Attacks: In later audio messages, including a 2010 statement directed at President Barack Obama, bin Laden stated that Americans would "never dream of living in peace" unless Palestinians experienced peace, vowing that al-Qaeda's attacks would continue as long as the U.S. backed Israel. [1, 2]

Ideological Framing: His rhetoric surrounding Israel heavily incorporated antisemitic conspiracy theories, alleging that Jewish interests heavily controlled American media, economics, and foreign policy

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
1 hour ago, Offthemat said:

 

9/11 occurred because of U.S. support of genocide in Israel. Osama Bin Laden basically admitted it. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, red viking said:

9/11 occurred because of U.S. support of genocide in Israel. Osama Bin Laden basically admitted it. 

You’re a bad person.  
 

terrorists are monsters.   Defending them makes you one too 

Edited by Caveira
Posted (edited)
38 minutes ago, Caveira said:

You’re a bad person.  
 

terrorists are monsters.   Defending them makes you one too 

Explaining the reason isnt defending them. Thats simply the facts.

Terrorism isnt justified but the rage itself is, 110%. 

Edited by red viking

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
1 minute ago, red viking said:

Explaining the reason isnt defending them. Thats simply the facts.

The way they've reacted sometimes ( e.g. terrorist acts) isnt justified but the rage itself is, 110%. 

You are  a bad person. 

Posted
Just now, Caveira said:

You are  a bad person. 

If you support the israeli genocide, YOU are the bad person. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted (edited)
6 minutes ago, red viking said:

If you support the israeli genocide, YOU are the bad person. 

bin Laden was a sales person.  He was a politician.  He was a monster.  You can’t take monsters or politicians words at face value.  He’s recruiting.   Everything he does / says / thinks is in the context of murdering the west and having Islam take over the globe.  It’s pure PR and cannot be taken at face value.  It’s designed to rile up maniacs like you.   It works with some maniacs.   Maniacs Like you.  Unfortunately.  

Edited by Caveira
Posted
5 minutes ago, Caveira said:

bin Laden was a sales person.  He was a politician.  He was a monster.  You can’t take monsters words at face value.  He’s recruiting.   Everything he does / says / thinks is in the context of murdering the west and having Islam take over the globe.  It’s pure PR and cannot be taken at face value.  It’s designed to rile up maniacs like you.   It works with some maniacs.   Maniacs Like you.  Unfortunately.  

Wow. You idiot wingers are unreal. He said exactly why he hates the west. It doesn't fit your narrative though so just assume without any basis whatsoever that he was lying. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
5 minutes ago, red viking said:

Wow. You idiot wingers are unreal. He said exactly why he hates the west. It doesn't fit your narrative though so just assume without any basis whatsoever that he was lying. 

You can’t believe a monster / politician / mastermind terrorist to be honest.  You’re full of doo doo.   Everything they say publically is through a PR lens.  You’re dumb if you think otherwise.   110% of his public comments are geared towards recruiting monsters.   It works often unfortunately  

Posted
17 minutes ago, Caveira said:

You can’t believe a monster / politician / mastermind terrorist to be honest.  You’re full of doo doo.   Everything they say publically is through a PR lens.  You’re dumb if you think otherwise.   110% of his public comments are geared towards recruiting monsters.   It works often unfortunately  

So he says its because if israel, for recruiting purposes? Why? Because that's the main reason so many of them hate the u.s., except for him though? 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted (edited)
13 minutes ago, red viking said:

So he says its because if israel, for recruiting purposes? Why? Because that's the main reason so many of them hate the u.s., except for him though? 

Because sheeple like you eat shit up.  
 

you know nothing about sales or Politicians or highly successful leaders who speak through a very specific lens that caters to their product / ideology with every public word they say 

Edited by Caveira
Posted
34 minutes ago, Caveira said:

Because sheeple like you eat shit up.  
 

you know nothing about sales or Politicians or highly successful leaders who speak through a very specific lens that caters to their product / ideology with every public word they say 

If I only devoured rt wing media, then I would know the REAL and SECRET reason muslims hate the u.s. 

Nevermind what the actual muslims say. They're ALL lying.  Ill just trust breitbart instead. 

Unreal. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
Just now, red viking said:

If I only devoured rt wing media, then I would know the REAL and SECRET reason muslims hate the u.s. 

Nevermind what the actual muslims say. They're ALL lying.  Ill just trust breitbart instead. 

Unreal. 

When Muslims tell you they want to dominate the globe - convert or eliminate all opposing religions you should listen to them.  

Posted
2 minutes ago, Caveira said:

When Muslims tell you they want to dominate the globe - convert or eliminate all opposing religions you should listen to them.  

So listen only to that but ignore when they say why they specificallh hate the u.s. so much. 

Selective winger listening. Great. 

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Posted
56 minutes ago, red viking said:

If I only devoured rt wing media, then I would know the REAL and SECRET reason muslims hate the u.s. 

Nevermind what the actual muslims say. They're ALL lying.  Ill just trust breitbart instead. 

Unreal. 

It’s their religion. Pretty simple skippy.   

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted
52 minutes ago, red viking said:

So listen only to that but ignore when they say why they specificallh hate the u.s. so much. 

Selective winger listening. Great. 

Wokester commies listen so well though huh? 

LIVING the dream in the GREATEST COUNTRY on the planet!!!!

Posted (edited)
15 minutes ago, JimmySpeaks said:

It’s their religion. Pretty simple skippy.   

And Osama bin Laden was lying about his reason for 9/11? Lmfao

Edited by red viking

Fighting the Good Fight Against Non-Stop Winger Lies and Hypocrisy

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Eli Gabrielson

    Archbishop Spalding, Maryland
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Maryland
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Jackson McLees

    Travelers Rest, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to The Citadel
    Projected Weight: 149

    Gunnar Gossett

    Union Local, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 165

    Dylan Frass

    Olentangy Liberty, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Central Michigan
    Projected Weight: 285

    Emma Bacon

    Wyoming Seminary, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State (Women)
    Projected Weight: 131
×
×
  • Create New...