I was having a hard time exactly filtering through wrestlestat to see who had wrestled the most matches. But here are a couple guys that stood out to me in my search. Let me know of any others. Following three have 30 or more matches against D1 competition so far
Tommy Askey, Appalachian State - 33 matches wrestled against D1 wrestlers so far this year at 22-11
Kurt Phipps, Bucknell - 31 matches wrestled against D1 wrestlers this year at 21-8
Tyler Stoltzfus, Lock Haven - 30 matches wrestled against D1 wrestlers this year at 21-9