Exactly.
He's had the hottest gal in school all the way through college (aka wrestling.)
But it's marriage time. Go with what you know or maybe time to test the waters.
We very likely won't agree on the best choice here - but I'm a strong 'test the waters' backer.
So far, everything is working out just fine.
(Testing the waters includes no expectation that they'll actually be good. Thus, the reason they are tested.)