WADE SCHALLES because he entertained the (small) crowds out in Western Pennsylvania every match.
He had a bridge for his missing front incisor, he'd take that out before the match and smile, a big assed, gap-toothed grin, while he was competing. and usually pinning his foe. Hulk Hogan sort of stole his act, IMHO
After Wade...
Bo Nickal, Jason Nolf and Zane Retherford were fun to watch. Anthony Casar, but too little of him.
Carleton Haselrig, Jon Trenge, Carey Kolat, Kyle Dake, and Bryce Andonian for the thrill ride.