Looking at my Lehigh files that go back more than 50 years now (somehow I don't look any different than I did back then) -- these are guys with no state or prep titles who placed at NCAAs. Some were blue chip recruits anyway, most weren't.
Mike Lieberman, 2x Natl Preps 2nd, NCAA 1st, 3rd in 1975-76 (the last collegian to beat Chris Campbell).
Tihamer Toth-Fejel, California 3rd one time, NCAA 5th in 1976.
Denny Reed, PA A 4th and 2nd, NCAA 7th in 1980 (pinned A/A's to start and finish in his only NCAA tournament); I don't know that he was considered the team's starter at 142 until tournaments.
Chris Ayres, 69-25 in NJ, 19-7 with Blair, no places, NCAA 6th in 1999.
Mark Dufresne, NJ 4th once, 6-17 as a freshman at Lehigh, once wrestled both JV and varsity on the same afternoon at Army, NCAA 6th in 2000 as a senior.
John Van Doren, NJ 2nd and 3rd, NCAA 3rd and 5th.
Dave Esposito, NJ 3rd, 2nd, 3rd, NCAA 3rd and 2nd.
Chris Vitale, PA AAA 5th and 2nd, NCAA 7th.
Mario Stuart, PA AAA 3rd and 2nd, NCAA 5th and 4th.
Current Lehigh Associate Head Coach Brad Dillon, PA AAA 5th and 3rd, NCAA 5th (after the worst OT screwing in NCAA history) and 4th.
Derek Zinck, PA AAA 5th, 5th, 2nd, NCAA 8th and 5th.
Honorable mention to Robert Hamlin, 4x VT 1st, 2x New England 1st, NCAA 2nd, 4th, 2nd -- I believe he's the only A/A in Vermont's history. Nicknamed The Vermontster (a few years later Connor McGonagle of New Hampshire wisely passed on the proposed nickname of The New Hampster).
Scott Parker, PA AAA 4th, 3rd, 2nd, NCAA 8th and 7th.
Ryan Preisch, 2x PA AA 3rd, NCAA 4th.