I'm as big a PSU fan as there is. That being said, if Byrd runs the table, IMO he deserves the #1. Wrestled All-Star, hasn't missed a dual (that I know of). His schedule is not on him.
I know it's not in any criteria, but being defending champ should be worth something (it is, since Bryd is ranked 1 in every poll solely based on him winning last year and hasn't lost this year)
Blaze/Davino will meet again in B1G semi's