Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

There have been people talking about a couple of things related to qualifying that seem to take away the idea of earning a spot of nationals: i.e. At-Large, 9th place finishers at B1G's qualifying, 5th place finishers at ACC. I get B1G's being more competitive, but 9th place wrestlers shouldn't take precedence over a 3rd place one from another conference. It's stupid. Here's two alternatives, both occurring 1 week before NCAAs:

Alternative 1:

1. Each conference qualifies Top 3 per weight (except Pac-12, top 2) -- 23 automatic qualifiers.

2. The conferences get different allocations for a "Last Chance Qualifier". Breakdown as follows:

  • ACC gets none
  • Big 10 gets 4 per weight (4th through 7th place @ conferences)
  • Big 12 gets 4 per weight (4th through 7th place @ conferences)
  • EIWA gets 3 per weight (4th through 6th place @ conferences)
  • Ivy gets none
  • MAC gets 3 per weight (4th through 6th place @ conferences)
  • PAC-12 gets none
  • SoCon gets 1 per weight (4th place @ conferences)

Calculated by dividing number of schools per conference in half to get the number of placements. The rest make the Last Chance Qualifier. A total of 15 per weight.

3. 15 to 10 -- 5 groups of 3 (can be seeded or randomly drawn). Round robin, top 2 qualify for NCAAs (tiebreakers would be margin of victory, # of takedowns, # of back points, RT, # of reversals, # of escapes in that order).

 

Alternative 2:

Conference performance in previous NCAA tournaments dictate the allocations for following years (they do something like this for sections in State tournaments).

i.e. 3-yr weighted avg where 2024-2025 gets 100% weight, 2023-2024 gets 75% weight, and 2022-2023 gets 50% weight.

Bonus Points are not taken into effect. Just NCAA placement. Only the highest placer per weight would score allocation points for a conference.

1st - 16 points

2nd - 12 points

3rd - 9 points

4th - 7 points

5th - 5 points

6th - 3 points

7th - 2 points

8th - 1 point

 

Point Percentages

B1G - 37%

Big 12 - 25%

ACC - 15%

Ivy - 10%

Pac-12 - 7%

EIWA - 4%

MAC - 3%

SoCon - 0%

 

Allocations

1. Top 3 per weight except for Pac-12 who gets Top 2 -- 23 wrestlers

2. Percentage * 10 -- Big 10 gets 4 extra, Big 12 3, ACC 2, Ivy 1, Pac-12 0, EIWA 0, MAC 0, SoCon 0

 

All in all:

  • Big 10 gets Top 6
  • Big 12 gets Top 5
  • ACC gets Top 4
  • Ivy gets Top 3
  • Pac-12 gets Top 2
  • EIWA gets Top 2
  • MAC gets Top 2
  • SoCon gets Top 2

 

Let me know, obviously a little convoluted.

 

Posted

Why not use the current allocation process and if you don't qualify, then you go to last chance?

Top 3 per conference would mean a lot of good wrestlers in Big 10s and Big 12s don't qualify. And using historical information for current year allocations is wrong. I think they used to do that a decade or so ago.

Only change I would make to allocation process would be to cap the number of allocations allowed per conference, no matter what the matrix says. For example, conference allocations per weight are capped at 7 or 8. In hesitant about making it so that every conference gets 2 allocations per weight since the PAC 12 has 4 teams, but I do like that idea too.

  • Bob +1 1
Posted
9 hours ago, SplitTheG said:

There have been people talking about a couple of things related to qualifying that seem to take away the idea of earning a spot of nationals: i.e. At-Large, 9th place finishers at B1G's qualifying, 5th place finishers at ACC. I get B1G's being more competitive, but 9th place wrestlers shouldn't take precedence over a 3rd place one from another conference. It's stupid. Here's two alternatives, both occurring 1 week before NCAAs:

Alternative 1:

1. Each conference qualifies Top 3 per weight (except Pac-12, top 2) -- 23 automatic qualifiers.

2. The conferences get different allocations for a "Last Chance Qualifier". Breakdown as follows:

  • ACC gets none
  • Big 10 gets 4 per weight (4th through 7th place @ conferences)
  • Big 12 gets 4 per weight (4th through 7th place @ conferences)
  • EIWA gets 3 per weight (4th through 6th place @ conferences)
  • Ivy gets none
  • MAC gets 3 per weight (4th through 6th place @ conferences)
  • PAC-12 gets none
  • SoCon gets 1 per weight (4th place @ conferences)

Calculated by dividing number of schools per conference in half to get the number of placements. The rest make the Last Chance Qualifier. A total of 15 per weight.

3. 15 to 10 -- 5 groups of 3 (can be seeded or randomly drawn). Round robin, top 2 qualify for NCAAs (tiebreakers would be margin of victory, # of takedowns, # of back points, RT, # of reversals, # of escapes in that order).

 

Alternative 2:

Conference performance in previous NCAA tournaments dictate the allocations for following years (they do something like this for sections in State tournaments).

i.e. 3-yr weighted avg where 2024-2025 gets 100% weight, 2023-2024 gets 75% weight, and 2022-2023 gets 50% weight.

Bonus Points are not taken into effect. Just NCAA placement. Only the highest placer per weight would score allocation points for a conference.

1st - 16 points

2nd - 12 points

3rd - 9 points

4th - 7 points

5th - 5 points

6th - 3 points

7th - 2 points

8th - 1 point

 

Point Percentages

B1G - 37%

Big 12 - 25%

ACC - 15%

Ivy - 10%

Pac-12 - 7%

EIWA - 4%

MAC - 3%

SoCon - 0%

 

Allocations

1. Top 3 per weight except for Pac-12 who gets Top 2 -- 23 wrestlers

2. Percentage * 10 -- Big 10 gets 4 extra, Big 12 3, ACC 2, Ivy 1, Pac-12 0, EIWA 0, MAC 0, SoCon 0

 

All in all:

  • Big 10 gets Top 6
  • Big 12 gets Top 5
  • ACC gets Top 4
  • Ivy gets Top 3
  • Pac-12 gets Top 2
  • EIWA gets Top 2
  • MAC gets Top 2
  • SoCon gets Top 2

 

Let me know, obviously a little convoluted.

 

Screwed up the math for Alternative #2, late night brain.

Allocations would be (based on the past three years):

  • Big 10 -- Top 7 in conference
  • Big 12 -- Top 6 in conference
  • ACC -- Top 5 in conference
  • Ivy -- Top 4 in conference
  • EIWA -- Top 3 in conference
  • MAC -- Top 3 in conference
  • SoCon -- Top 3 in conference
  • Pac-12 -- Top 2 in conference
Posted

A last-chance qualifier sounds like fun, but the system of allocations is working well. Don't discard that part.

--Move conference tournaments up a weekend.

--Have the last-chance qualifier to earn the final 4 or 5 spots per weight on Friday afternoon/evening of current conference weekend. Announce nationals bracket the following night.

--Invite:

1) the wrestler from each conference who missed an automatic bid by one spot (8 wrestlers per weight)

2) any other guy who earned an allocation for their conference but didn't win an automatic bid (3-5 per weight, nationally, bringing field total to about 12 per weight)

--Only wrestle until spots are earned (e.g. Semi-final winners are finished wrestling)

--Seed only guys who meet both both invitation criteria. Random draw the rest. 

 

That's it. Let's do it.

 

  • Bob +1 1
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, maligned said:

A last-chance qualifier sounds like fun, but the system of allocations is working well. Don't discard that part.

--Move conference tournaments up a weekend.

--Have the last-chance qualifier to earn the final 4 or 5 spots per weight on Friday afternoon/evening of current conference weekend. Announce nationals bracket the following night.

--Invite:

1) the wrestler from each conference who missed an automatic bid by one spot (8 wrestlers per weight)

2) any other guy who earned an allocation for their conference but didn't win an automatic bid (3-5 per weight, nationally, bringing field total to about 12 per weight)

--Only wrestle until spots are earned (e.g. Semi-final winners are finished wrestling)

--Seed only guys who meet both both invitation criteria. Random draw the rest. 

 

That's it. Let's do it.

 

It works, but what I don't like (and what some other people have mentioned) is how conferences like B1G get 9 or 10 auto qualifiers in some weight classes, even when there are 14 kids competing at that conference tournament. Doesn't exactly seem right in that sense.

What I am proposing is to make the Top 3 (with the exception of Top 2 in Pac-12) a blanket achievement for automatic qualifiers in every conference, with other wrestlers qualifying for the "Last Chance Qualifier" proportionally by conference with the extra current allocation slots or by conference performance in previous NCAA tournaments.

 

I.e. B1G placement after 3rd place still matters so that they can qualify more to the Last Chance Qualifier.

Edited by SplitTheG
Posted
1 minute ago, SplitTheG said:

It works, but what I don't like (and what some other people have mentioned) is how conferences like B1G get 9 or 10 auto qualifiers in some weight classes, even when there are 14 kids competing at that conference tournament. Doesn't exactly seem right in that sense.

What I am proposing is to make the Top 3 (with the exception of Top 2 in Pac-12) a blanket achievement for automatic qualifiers in every conference, with other wrestlers qualifying for the "Last Chance Qualifier" proportionally by conference with the extra current allocation slots or by conference performance in previous NCAA tournaments.

They are allocating 9 for a reason. The conference is deep and they earn those allocations just like other conferences earn less. It’s not charity. 
 

I am a Stanford fan and back when we were at PAC-12s this would have been beneficial. It wasn’t earned though.

Posted
15 hours ago, SplitTheG said:

I get B1G's being more competitive, but 9th place wrestlers shouldn't take precedence over a 3rd place one from another conference.

That's because statistically, 9th place at Big Tens beats 3rd place from SoCon. You can't outrun math.

That said, anyone who MFF or injury defaults on the backside also goes into the Last Chance bracket until the sentiment has been adequately changed that it is being gamed. Injuries suck, but the current sentiment is that gamesmanship is out of control. The Big Ten has taken a big step toward competing by including that into seeding criteria (output is another thread) and changing to require participation is of the same spirit.

i am an idiot on the internet

Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, bnwtwg said:

That's because statistically, 9th place at Big Tens beats 3rd place from SoCon. You can't outrun math.

That said, anyone who MFF or injury defaults on the backside also goes into the Last Chance bracket until the sentiment has been adequately changed that it is being gamed. Injuries suck, but the current sentiment is that gamesmanship is out of control. The Big Ten has taken a big step toward competing by including that into seeding criteria (output is another thread) and changing to require participation is of the same spirit.

Statistics or not, I'd rather see someone who finished 3rd at a conference like SoCon make the jump than someone who fell to the 9th place match in a 14 man bracket be deemed an auto-qualifier. 9th place?? Big 10 is obviously the best conference, so give them more auto qualifiers, but 9 does not promote merit. 

Edited by SplitTheG
Posted
11 minutes ago, SplitTheG said:

It works, but what I don't like (and what some other people have mentioned) is how conferences like B1G get 9 or 10 auto qualifiers in some weight classes, even when there are 14 kids competing at that conference tournament. Doesn't exactly seem right in that sense.

What I am proposing is to make the Top 3 (with the exception of Top 2 in Pac-12) a blanket achievement for automatic qualifiers in every conference, with other wrestlers qualifying for the "Last Chance Qualifier" proportionally by conference with the extra current allocation slots or by conference performance in previous NCAA tournaments.

 

I.e. B1G placement after 3rd place still matters so that they can qualify more to the Last Chance Qualifier.

Yeah, I just don't agree at all. It's no different than a conference with 4 teams getting 2 or 3 bids. If 2 or 3 of the best kids in the country are there, the allocations should go there. 

Did you know there's plenty of data showing that the conference that FAR outperforms their seeds, on average, at nationals is the Big 10? Even with all of the "generous" allotting of many slots to them and high seeding despite many losses that wrestlers carry--they STILL far outperform their seeds, on average, at nationals. Not surprisingly, the smaller school conferences underperform their seeds considerably. 

It means the system is working. Everyone is getting representation. 

I like the idea of a last-chance qualifier, but there's no way in the world the power programs are going to agree to something that tries to convince us that 3 in this conference and 3 in that conference is fair just because the number "3" is the same.

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, maligned said:

Yeah, I just don't agree at all. It's no different than a conference with 4 teams getting 2 or 3 bids. If 2 or 3 of the best kids in the country are there, the allocations should go there. 

Did you know there's plenty of data showing that the conference that FAR outperforms their seeds, on average, at nationals is the Big 10? Even with all of the "generous" allotting of many slots to them and high seeding despite many losses that wrestlers carry--they STILL far outperform their seeds, on average, at nationals. Not surprisingly, the smaller school conferences underperform their seeds considerably. 

It means the system is working. Everyone is getting representation. 

I like the idea of a last-chance qualifier, but there's no way in the world the power programs are going to agree to something that tries to convince us that 3 in this conference and 3 in that conference is fair just because the number "3" is the same.

Read my original post, I had two ideas. One was where the base for each conference is 3, but the proportionality would still exist based on past performances Big 10 auto-qualifiers, for example, would simply drop from 9 qualifiers to 7. The conferences not performing well would stay at 3. Pac-12 gets 2 because of being a 4-team conference.

 

The other idea was to provide this proportionality in the form of having more qualifiers from better-performing conferences be allowed to participate in the "Last Chance Qualifiers"

 

Edited by SplitTheG
Posted
3 minutes ago, SplitTheG said:

Statistics or not, I'd rather see someone who finished 3rd at a conference like SoCon make the jump than someone who fell to the 9th place match in a 14 man bracket be deemed an auto-qualifier. 9th place?? Big 10 is obviously the best conference, so give them more auto qualifiers, but 9 does not promote merit. 

You obviously wouldn't put the 2nd place kid from the Delaware high school state finals over the 3rd place guy from the SoCon on "merit" just because the number is better. It's no different in this case. If all of the 9th place guys from the Big 10 would win in a dual against the SoCon #3s, why is a 3rd place at the SoCon "merit"?

Posted (edited)
5 minutes ago, SplitTheG said:

If you read more of what I said, the base for each conference is 3, there is still proportionality. Big 10 auto-qualifiers based on their performances would drop from 9 qualifiers to 7. The conferences not performing well would stay at 3. Pac-12 gets 2 because of being a 4-team conference.

I see what you mean. Still, why not cut with a precise scalpel and use all the information we have available so we come closer to getting the genuinely best guys--instead of cutting with an axe because it feels easier to accept?

Edited by maligned
  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
1 minute ago, maligned said:

You obviously wouldn't put the 2nd place kid from the Delaware high school state finals over the 3rd place guy from the SoCon on "merit" just because the number is better. It's no different in this case. If all of the 9th place guys from the Big 10 would win in a dual against the SoCon #3s, why is a 3rd place at the SoCon "merit"?

There are two goals to this, and that is a rather egregious analogy you are making.

1. Yes, better performing conferences deserve more qualifiers, but also:

2. More representation across the D1 wrestling landscape, doing this by placing on emphasis on conference placement. 9th place in Big 10's, honestly, I don't care about, and that is where our sentiments differ.

 

So yeah, Big 10's lose 2 qualifiers (for weight classes that have 9/10) and get 7 per weight class. I'm fine with that. Might help out other wrestling schools with their recruitment push. 

Posted
15 hours ago, SplitTheG said:

There have been people talking about a couple of things related to qualifying that seem to take away the idea of earning a spot of nationals: i.e. At-Large, 9th place finishers at B1G's qualifying, 5th place finishers at ACC. I get B1G's being more competitive, but 9th place wrestlers shouldn't take precedence over a 3rd place one from another conference. It's stupid. Here's two alternatives, both occurring 1 week before NCAAs:

Alternative 1:

1. Each conference qualifies Top 3 per weight (except Pac-12, top 2) -- 23 automatic qualifiers.

2. The conferences get different allocations for a "Last Chance Qualifier". Breakdown as follows:

  • ACC gets none
  • Big 10 gets 4 per weight (4th through 7th place @ conferences)
  • Big 12 gets 4 per weight (4th through 7th place @ conferences)
  • EIWA gets 3 per weight (4th through 6th place @ conferences)
  • Ivy gets none
  • MAC gets 3 per weight (4th through 6th place @ conferences)
  • PAC-12 gets none
  • SoCon gets 1 per weight (4th place @ conferences)

Calculated by dividing number of schools per conference in half to get the number of placements. The rest make the Last Chance Qualifier. A total of 15 per weight.

3. 15 to 10 -- 5 groups of 3 (can be seeded or randomly drawn). Round robin, top 2 qualify for NCAAs (tiebreakers would be margin of victory, # of takedowns, # of back points, RT, # of reversals, # of escapes in that order).

 

Alternative 2:

Conference performance in previous NCAA tournaments dictate the allocations for following years (they do something like this for sections in State tournaments).

i.e. 3-yr weighted avg where 2024-2025 gets 100% weight, 2023-2024 gets 75% weight, and 2022-2023 gets 50% weight.

Bonus Points are not taken into effect. Just NCAA placement. Only the highest placer per weight would score allocation points for a conference.

1st - 16 points

2nd - 12 points

3rd - 9 points

4th - 7 points

5th - 5 points

6th - 3 points

7th - 2 points

8th - 1 point

 

Point Percentages

B1G - 37%

Big 12 - 25%

ACC - 15%

Ivy - 10%

Pac-12 - 7%

EIWA - 4%

MAC - 3%

SoCon - 0%

 

Allocations

1. Top 3 per weight except for Pac-12 who gets Top 2 -- 23 wrestlers

2. Percentage * 10 -- Big 10 gets 4 extra, Big 12 3, ACC 2, Ivy 1, Pac-12 0, EIWA 0, MAC 0, SoCon 0

 

All in all:

  • Big 10 gets Top 6
  • Big 12 gets Top 5
  • ACC gets Top 4
  • Ivy gets Top 3
  • Pac-12 gets Top 2
  • EIWA gets Top 2
  • MAC gets Top 2
  • SoCon gets Top 2

 

Let me know, obviously a little convoluted.

 

9th place in the Big Ten should absolutely get precedence over 3rd place from almost every other conference.  

The big result of your changes is to make nationals worse.  

Posted
Just now, boconnell said:

9th place in the Big Ten should absolutely get precedence over 3rd place from almost every other conference.  

The big result of your changes is to make nationals worse.  

Look I understand, a guy like Fugitt places 11th at B1G's, gets 4th at NCAAs (I might be wrong, but that seems a rather rare phenomenon anyways). I'd just rather them not auto-qualify by securing a place like 9th or 11th at conferences. That's what last-chance would be for.

Posted
6 minutes ago, SplitTheG said:

There are two goals to this, and that is a rather egregious analogy you are making.

1. Yes, better performing conferences deserve more qualifiers, but also:

2. More representation across the D1 wrestling landscape, doing this by placing on emphasis on conference placement. 9th place in Big 10's, honestly, I don't care about, and that is where our sentiments differ.

 

So yeah, Big 10's lose 2 qualifiers (for weight classes that have 9/10) and get 7 per weight class. I'm fine with that. Might help out other wrestling schools with their recruitment push. 

Again, I think you're too caught up in the appearance of a number. Another example: you wouldn't take the 3rd place from the SoCon over the 9th place from nationals. The 3rd place from the SoCon is obviously closer to 9th place from Big 10s than from nationals, but the point remains--the numbers don't matter. They're just numbers that are completely dependent on their environment. The quality is what matters. 

  • Wrestle +1 1
Posted
1 minute ago, SplitTheG said:

Look I understand, a guy like Fugitt places 11th at B1G's, gets 4th at NCAAs (I might be wrong, but that seems a rather rare phenomenon anyways). I'd just rather them not auto-qualify by securing a place like 9th or 11th at conferences. That's what last-chance would be for.

But that's not what your proposal is doing.  You have made it clear you want 3rd place in the SoCon over 9th place in the Big Ten.  You have made it clear you want to give unearned auto qualifiers just based on conference finish.  That isn't about not qualifying with 9th place.  That's about putting in worse wrestlers because they got 3rd in a conference.  

If you just want to award at large spots based on a last chance tournament, you are just going to send more Big Ten guys than are currently there.  

  • Bob +1 1
Posted (edited)
25 minutes ago, SplitTheG said:

Statistics or not, I'd rather see someone who finished 3rd at a conference like SoCon make the jump than someone who fell to the 9th place match in a 14 man bracket be deemed an auto-qualifier.

You write this already knowing and admitting the the B1Gwrestler is better. To what purpose does that make a better product? 

Edited by MPhillips

.

Posted
Just now, MPhillips said:

You write this already knowing and admitting the the B1g wrestler is better. To what purpose does that make a better product? 

To the purpose of growing the sport outside the Big 10.

Posted
Just now, SplitTheG said:

To the purpose of growing the sport outside the Big 10.

Letting lesser wrestlers undeservingly take spots from better wrestlers will help, "grow the sport?"

  • Wrestle +1 2

.

Posted (edited)
1 minute ago, MPhillips said:

Letting lesser wrestlers undeservingly take spots from better wrestlers will help, "grow the sport?"

I mean there are other ways NCAAs doesn't get the best guys beyond this too. Why not allow schools to have multiple entries for wrestlers? Wouldn't that make the best all-around tournament? Or is there something else that the tournament should strive for?

i.e. What if Penn State could have PJ Duke and Tyler Kasak at 157? What if OK State could have Ronnie Ramirez and Jax Forrest at 133? 

So where does the line get drawn? Are you really caught up on the 9th place guy being the one that is making the tournament so much better, or is it what you are used to?

Edited by SplitTheG
Posted
Just now, SplitTheG said:

Why not allow schools to have multiple entries for wrestlers? Wouldn't that make the best all-around tournament?

I thought you wanted someone other than just B1G wrestlers...

.

Posted
1 minute ago, MPhillips said:

I thought you wanted someone other than just B1G wrestlers...

I do, I'm asking you since your point is that the tournament would be so much worse.

Posted
11 minutes ago, boconnell said:

But that's not what your proposal is doing.  You have made it clear you want 3rd place in the SoCon over 9th place in the Big Ten.  You have made it clear you want to give unearned auto qualifiers just based on conference finish.  That isn't about not qualifying with 9th place.  That's about putting in worse wrestlers because they got 3rd in a conference.  

If you just want to award at large spots based on a last chance tournament, you are just going to send more Big Ten guys than are currently there.  

At least at a Last-Chance the extra qualifiers from presumably the Big 10's would wrestle their way in.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Matthew Cooley

    Oakdale, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Cal Poly
    Projected Weight: 285

    Mason Basile

    Tampa Jesuit, Florida
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Franklin & Marshall
    Projected Weight: 149, 157

    Deacon Morgan

    Rochester Adams, Michigan
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Michigan State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Khary McCall

    Springboro, Ohio
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Kent State
    Projected Weight: 174

    Sarah Pulk

    Badger-GB-MR, Minnesota
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Northern Michigan (Women)
    Projected Weight: 180
×
×
  • Create New...