Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

PSU's 2 stud TF win 2 national titles this year or 2 of Okst's TF win a title. I phrase that in the manner that allows for someone that may or may not be wrestling in march to also be included. I favor Marcus currently against the field but would favor the field against PJ for the time being. Even if Jax were to enter I am not sure that I would favor him against the field accounting for Marcus, that just seems like a horrendous style matchup for him. The other 3 guys are certainly all capable of making the finals but pretty decided underdogs from the perspective of winning the entire thing. I think it probably goes in the order Sergio then Robideau then Dee. Robideau probably has the best odds if he makes the finals to win that specific match but Sergio seems to be more separated from his contemporaries. Dee is going to be in a dog fight from the quarters on and then probably wrestles the best dude in the NCAA in the finals so I think while he has some form of a percentage shot its near zero. Thats a lot to say I would lean PSU but I think both scenarios are decent + money at least for the time being.

I am the personal property of VakAttack

Posted
15 minutes ago, Truzzcat said:

PSU's 2 stud TF win 2 national titles this year or 2 of Okst's TF win a title. I phrase that in the manner that allows for someone that may or may not be wrestling in march to also be included. I favor Marcus currently against the field but would favor the field against PJ for the time being. Even if Jax were to enter I am not sure that I would favor him against the field accounting for Marcus, that just seems like a horrendous style matchup for him. The other 3 guys are certainly all capable of making the finals but pretty decided underdogs from the perspective of winning the entire thing. I think it probably goes in the order Sergio then Robideau then Dee. Robideau probably has the best odds if he makes the finals to win that specific match but Sergio seems to be more separated from his contemporaries. Dee is going to be in a dog fight from the quarters on and then probably wrestles the best dude in the NCAA in the finals so I think while he has some form of a percentage shot its near zero. Thats a lot to say I would lean PSU but I think both scenarios are decent + money at least for the time being.

PSU's two. Vega has Mendez and Dee has MM. That's a lot tougher than Byrd and Shapiro for top contenders. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, happyvalet said:

PSU's two. Vega has Mendez and Dee has MM. That's a lot tougher than Byrd and Shapiro for top contenders. 

This.  A better question might be what’s more likely between Blaze + Duke winning or 2+ total titles for OSU.

Posted
Just now, 1032004 said:

This.  A better question might be what’s more likely between Blaze + Duke winning or 2+ total titles for OSU.

I'd take Blaze and Duke winning over OSU getting 1 title.

Posted

PSU has a very strong chance at 133 and 157. Blaze probably will have 3 tough guys to go thru that will present challenges.

Flo has a guy who lost to a high school wrestler at #1 at 157 and I would rate PJ Duke a near prohibitive favorite against him. The guy who I worry most about is Shapiro based on style of wrestling. 

Posted
8 hours ago, happyvalet said:

PSU's two. Vega has Mendez and Dee has MM. That's a lot tougher than Byrd and Shapiro for top contenders. 

Exactly. Not saying it happens, but we’re talking hypotheticals and odds here and it’s definitely the PSU 2…not because of who they are vs the Okie St duo, but solely because of what stands in the way of the 2 young Cowboys. 

Posted
49 minutes ago, Pinnacle said:

Flo has a guy who lost to a high school wrestler at #1 at 157 and I would rate PJ Duke a near prohibitive favorite against him. The guy who I worry most about is Shapiro based on style of wrestling. 

Funny about their 157 ranking is they justified moving Watters down because he ducked Robideau two weeks ago. It wasn't important for last week's ranking but it's suddenly meaningful now 🤔

Posted (edited)
35 minutes ago, happyvalet said:

Funny about their 157 ranking is they justified moving Watters down because he ducked Robideau two weeks ago. It wasn't important for last week's ranking but it's suddenly meaningful now 🤔

 

Rankings are whatever they want them to be. They just want the clicks for cash.

They make a huge deal out of Watters no going against Robideau, but literally ignore losses to high schoolers. They also ignore wins vs numerous former NCAA Champs in freestyle even though freestyle wins vs numerous former champs almost always translates. And they ignore the Wins vs Champs while marketing those same wins vs champs as a huge deal on their youtube home page. 

They just want the clicks for the cash. 

 

Edited by Pinnacle
Posted
27 minutes ago, happyvalet said:

Funny about their 157 ranking is they justified moving Watters down because he ducked Robideau two weeks ago. It wasn't important for last week's ranking but it's suddenly meaningful now 🤔

Meh, most of the debate about Watters/Robideau was some people saying Robideau should be ranked above Watters because of the duck, but Flo still has Watters ahead of him.  They just moved Cannon to #1 because they think he has the “best overall resume” which they pretty consistently say is what they go off of. I don’t hate the reasoning here:

“We felt a reordering of the top 8 was needed after the results over the last 2 weeks (and the entire season). Watters overtook the #1 spot after week 3 based on an early-season win over Daniel Cardenas and Antrell Taylor losing to Logan Rozynski and Brandon Cannon. However, now that win over Cardenas is shared by PJ Duke, Vinny Zerban, Landon Robideau, and Meyer Shapiro. On top of that, Watters didn’t wrestle last week against Robideau when West Virginia dualed Oklahoma State. Because of those two factors, we didn’t feel Watters had the resume to retain his number 1 ranking.

We felt Brandon Cannon’s overall resume was the best of this group on the year with wins over Antrell Taylor and Jackson Arrington. On top of that, Cannon has wrestled his complete schedule and has a 100% bonus rate against college competition. 

Similar to Cannon, PJ Duke is 9-0 on the year, and his recent win over Daniel Cardenas gives him the same “best win” as Ty Watters. That win, combined with a win over Logan Rozynski (who beat Antrell Taylor), gives Duke the strength to rise to #3 above Antrell Taylor. 

Defending national champion Antrell Taylor had a rough National Duals, losing to Rozynski and Cannon, but responded with a win over Landon Robideau on Sunday. With that win, Taylor rises to #4 but is kept from entering the top 3 because of the early-season losses.

We chose to keep Landon Robideau above Meyer Shapiro for a few reasons. First, Shapiro missed the first 7 weeks of the season and didn’t wrestle until this weekend. Robideau has been one of the most active wrestlers in the top 8, boasting wins over Daniel Cardenas and Jackson Arrington. It’s worth noting that Shapiro is 1-2 in his career against Cardenas, 0-1 against Antrell Taylor, and 2-0 against Zerban. Shapiro has also never wrestled Cannon, Watters, Duke, or Robideau in college. Because of those factors, we felt Shapiro fit perfectly at #6.

If you have any questions, we welcome and encourage your feedback. Hit up Jon Kozak (email: [email protected]; X: @KozakJon) and JD Rader (email: [email protected]; X: @rader_jd).”

Posted
12 minutes ago, Pinnacle said:

 

Rankings are whatever they want them to be. They just want the clicks for cash.

They make a huge deal out of Watters no going against Robideau, but literally ignore losses to high schoolers. They also ignore wins vs numerous former NCAA Champs in freestyle even though freestyle wins vs numerous former champs almost always translates. And they ignore the Wins vs Champs while marketing those same wins vs champs as a huge deal on their youtube home page. 

They just want the clicks for the cash. 

 

How is the loss to the high schooler relevant to moving someone down?  Did any of the other guys beat that high schooler this year?

Posted

There is just so much consternation the last 2-3 wks over rankings that don’t matter.

Flo has got to be loving this. As we speak Pyles is leaning back in his chair at his desk tweaking his nipples…

When Flo rankings or any websites rankings become the sole and only basis for NCAA seeding, then it’ll matter. Until then, relax, the great thing about wrestling is it’s a sport that always works this stuff out on the mat eventually. March will come and go before we know it.

Posted
Just now, 1032004 said:

How is the loss to the high schooler relevant to moving someone down?  Did any of the other guys beat that high schooler this year?

Because it diminishes the idea Cannon has "the best overall resume". That criteria, "best overall resume" can mean anything, and to me the loss to a high schooler is a dent in that resume. 

The best resume to me using everything my eyes have ever seen belongs to PJ Duke. He beat Yianni twice. Flo can do whatever they want. Ignore some things, make a huge deal of others. Not that anyone cares, but PJ Duke is the higher ranked guy in my view. My view, my truth. Lol. Whatever. 

Posted
5 minutes ago, Nak21 said:

There is just so much consternation the last 2-3 wks over rankings that don’t matter.

Flo has got to be loving this. As we speak Pyles is leaning back in his chair at his desk tweaking his nipples…

When Flo rankings or any websites rankings become the sole and only basis for NCAA seeding, then it’ll matter. Until then, relax, the great thing about wrestling is it’s a sport that always works this stuff out on the mat eventually. March will come and go before we know it.

OMG. I did not need that image to flash across the screen. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Pinnacle said:

Because it diminishes the idea Cannon has "the best overall resume". That criteria, "best overall resume" can mean anything, and to me the loss to a high schooler is a dent in that resume. 

The best resume to me using everything my eyes have ever seen belongs to PJ Duke. He beat Yianni twice. Flo can do whatever they want. Ignore some things, make a huge deal of others. Not that anyone cares, but PJ Duke is the higher ranked guy in my view. My view, my truth. Lol. Whatever. 

You are certainly welcome to your opinion, but Flo has been very consistent over the years in not considering freestyle results.

Posted (edited)
42 minutes ago, 1032004 said:

Meh, most of the debate about Watters/Robideau was some people saying Robideau should be ranked above Watters because of the duck, but Flo still has Watters ahead of him.  They just moved Cannon to #1 because they think he has the “best overall resume” which they pretty consistently say is what they go off of. I don’t hate the reasoning here:

“We felt a reordering of the top 8 was needed after the results over the last 2 weeks (and the entire season). Watters overtook the #1 spot after week 3 based on an early-season win over Daniel Cardenas and Antrell Taylor losing to Logan Rozynski and Brandon Cannon. However, now that win over Cardenas is shared by PJ Duke, Vinny Zerban, Landon Robideau, and Meyer Shapiro. On top of that, Watters didn’t wrestle last week against Robideau when West Virginia dualed Oklahoma State. Because of those two factors, we didn’t feel Watters had the resume to retain his number 1 ranking.

We felt Brandon Cannon’s overall resume was the best of this group on the year with wins over Antrell Taylor and Jackson Arrington. On top of that, Cannon has wrestled his complete schedule and has a 100% bonus rate against college competition. 

Similar to Cannon, PJ Duke is 9-0 on the year, and his recent win over Daniel Cardenas gives him the same “best win” as Ty Watters. That win, combined with a win over Logan Rozynski (who beat Antrell Taylor), gives Duke the strength to rise to #3 above Antrell Taylor. 

Defending national champion Antrell Taylor had a rough National Duals, losing to Rozynski and Cannon, but responded with a win over Landon Robideau on Sunday. With that win, Taylor rises to #4 but is kept from entering the top 3 because of the early-season losses.

We chose to keep Landon Robideau above Meyer Shapiro for a few reasons. First, Shapiro missed the first 7 weeks of the season and didn’t wrestle until this weekend. Robideau has been one of the most active wrestlers in the top 8, boasting wins over Daniel Cardenas and Jackson Arrington. It’s worth noting that Shapiro is 1-2 in his career against Cardenas, 0-1 against Antrell Taylor, and 2-0 against Zerban. Shapiro has also never wrestled Cannon, Watters, Duke, or Robideau in college. Because of those factors, we felt Shapiro fit perfectly at #6.

If you have any questions, we welcome and encourage your feedback. Hit up Jon Kozak (email: [email protected]; X: @KozakJon) and JD Rader (email: [email protected]; X: @rader_jd).”

My point wasn't faulty reasoning, it was conveniently applying it this week but not last week. That is spelled out in their justification. 

Edited by happyvalet
Posted
5 hours ago, manatree said:

I was expecting you to be asking: What’s more likely, Rutgers winning the title or Jimmy honoring his bets?

A true war of attrition this would be.

Posted
1 hour ago, 1032004 said:

You are certainly welcome to your opinion, but Flo has been very consistent over the years in not considering freestyle results.

 

I liked Willie's take on this yesterday on Basch. This is pretty close... "they could have gotten to the same place by just doing what I did from the start". Willie S. way of doing it is more informative and its not close. 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Pinnacle said:

 

I liked Willie's take on this yesterday on Basch. This is pretty close... "they could have gotten to the same place by just doing what I did from the start". Willie S. way of doing it is more informative and its not close. 

His are predictions, not rankings.  And there’s really no way to argue with him about his because he can always say, “it’s just, like, my opinion, man”

Edited by 1032004
Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, 1032004 said:

His are predictions, not rankings.  And there’s really no way to argue with him about his because he can always say, “it’s just, like, my opinion, man”

Flo calls what they do rankings, but they aren't true rankings either. They are half rankings, half standings. And even if you wish to nitpick that description, for Flo to start out saying they are willing to consider some things but hell no they won't consider others while marketing those other things like they are really a big deal makes what you are doing somewhat of a farce.

Flo even includes folkstyle results in a headline about freestyle matches i.e. "Blaze beats 3 NCAA Champions"

The cross over between free and folk is real, their denial of them is head in the sand worthy. That is why this comes up all the time. 

Edited by Pinnacle
Posted
3 minutes ago, Pinnacle said:

Flo calls what they do rankings, but they aren't true rankings either. They are half rankings, half standings. And even if you wish to nitpick that description, for Flo to start out saying they are willing to consider some things but hell no they won't consider others while marketing those other things like they are really a big deal makes what you are doing somewhat of a farce.

Flo even includes folkstyle results in a headline about freestyle matches i.e. "Blaze beats 3 NCAA Champions"

The cross over between free and folk is real, their denial of them is head in the sand worthy. That is why this comes up all the time. 

I think they did a whole segment recently talking about a large number of guys whose freestyle results differed significantly from their folk results.  So in those cases wouldn’t they have to “consider some results but not others”?

Also, lol at comparing the headline of an article to rankings…

Posted
5 hours ago, Pinnacle said:

PSU has a very strong chance at 133 and 157. Blaze probably will have 3 tough guys to go thru that will present challenges.

Flo has a guy who lost to a high school wrestler at #1 at 157 and I would rate PJ Duke a near prohibitive favorite against him. The guy who I worry most about is Shapiro based on style of wrestling. 

Can’t look at Flo rankings at all for legitimacy.  Last week they kept Watters at #1 when he didn’t step on the mat. This week Zerban gets dropped for not competing and they reward Canon.  They need guys who understand competion and combat.  JD understands it.  Pyle is a jock sniffing stat guy that doesn’t understand that when you step in the arena and your opponent doesn’t, you win.  You prepared. You dealt with the mental and physical adversity to be there.  

Posted
4 hours ago, Pinnacle said:

Because it diminishes the idea Cannon has "the best overall resume". That criteria, "best overall resume" can mean anything, and to me the loss to a high schooler is a dent in that resume. 

The best resume to me using everything my eyes have ever seen belongs to PJ Duke. He beat Yianni twice. Flo can do whatever they want. Ignore some things, make a huge deal of others. Not that anyone cares, but PJ Duke is the higher ranked guy in my view. My view, my truth. Lol. Whatever. 

Flo has Duke ranked higher than Intermat does fwiw

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Rankings

  • College Commitments

    Bryson Galloway

    North East HS, Pennsylvania
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Slippery Rock
    Projected Weight: 133, 141

    Joe Constable

    Fort Dodge, Iowa
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Iowa State
    Projected Weight: 285

    Konner Larkin

    Valiant Prep, Arizona
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Arizona State
    Projected Weight: 149

    Adan Castillo

    Clovis, California
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Little Rock
    Projected Weight: 285

    Sy Strobel

    West-Oak, South Carolina
    Class of 2027
    Committed to Appalachian State
    Projected Weight: 184
×
×
  • Create New...