Absolutely. Candidly, in a case like Starocci where you can't tell how much an injury will affect him, just keep it simple, go with what the matrix says. Had he wrestled more matches, he would have a RPI.
As great as Starocci is, he:
1. Wrestled only 12 matches this year
2. Missed a match against Shane Griffith
3. Will go 0-2 officially at conferences
Thus his seeding matrix gets napalmed