Off the top of my head, after they went to numbered divisions, Ken Mallory Mont St 1978 and Tom Martucci Trenton St 1981, Carleton Haselrig 1987-1989
There were several more from the small college division- most notably Clarion early 70s with Barton, Rohn, Schalles and Simpson.
AAs would take a bit longer (and wouldn't be from memory)
Just noticed the NY part- none of these from NY