Best case? Cael actually did report whatever he was required to and nothing really happens.
Worst case? The team gets the “death penalty,” Carter is blackballed from wrestling, Cael loses his job, and it destroys wrestling’s reputation even more.
Realistically? PSU “investigates” and finds no wrongdoing, Carter goes to MMA, and nothing really happens. Maybe PSU loses an occasional recruiting battle that they wouldn’t have otherwise.