Round Robin - 184 pounds PSU edition

[Jimmy Cinnabon]

Entrants:

• Bo Nickal (4x NCAA finalist, 3x NCAA champ, Hodge winner)
• Ed Ruth (4x AA, 3x NCAA champ)
• Aaron Brooks (3x NCAA champ, potentially a 4x NCAA champ)
• Quentin Wright (4x AA, 3x NCAA finalist, 2x NCAA champ)

How does this shake out in a round robin format?

Bonus: how does Cael do if allowed at catchweight?

Edited October 6, 2023 by Jimmy Cinnabon

[nhs67]

1 minute ago, Jimmy Cinnabon said:

Entrants:

• Bo Nickal (3x NCAA champ, Hodge winner)
• Ed Ruth (3x NCAA champ)
• Aaron Brooks (3x NCAA champ)
• Quentin Wright (2x NCAA champ)

How does this shake out in a round robin format?

Nickal only won it twice at 184 and Wright only won once at 184.

[Jimmy Cinnabon]

Just now, nhs67 said:

Nickal only won it twice at 184 and Wright only won once at 184.

Yes I'm aware, but I'm still slotting them in this hypothetical at 184,

[nhs67]

5 minutes ago, Jimmy Cinnabon said:

Entrants:

• Bo Nickal (3x NCAA champ, Hodge winner)
• Ed Ruth (3x NCAA champ)
• Aaron Brooks (3x NCAA champ)
• Quentin Wright (2x NCAA champ)

How does this shake out in a round robin format?

I think the best version of 184lbers for them could have all of them take a loss.  I think Wright is an absolute landmine for anybody.  He could deck any of them or get decked.

I also think Brooks beats Ruth beats Nickal beats Brooks...

[nhs67]

8 minutes ago, Jimmy Cinnabon said:

Yes I'm aware, but I'm still slotting them in this hypothetical at 184,

They hypothetical one is only using 184lb versions of them.  Meaning not Senior versions of Nickal or Brooks (even though his 'technical' senior season was last season).

[AgaveMaria]

Ed Ruth takes it. He was the best they have had. If Cael is there he would take any of them apart. (if younger & competing)