The sport has evolved in the past decade and will continue to evolve, so if a coach doesn’t evolve, therein may lie the problem.
Do you think Gable would be winning NCAA titles every year in today’s landscape using the same coaching philosophy as he had in the 90s? I think he’d consistently be on the outside of trophies looking in. Brands seems to operate on the Gable philosophies updated to the present environment to an extent.
The idea of iron sharpening iron has lost its usefulness to a large degree at the collegiate level. Gone are the days of the best recruits never competing against anyone outside of a 2-hour bus ride from their hometowns. Kids are coming into college with a lot of matches against elite opponents from across the country and world.
Kids are also practicing year round with the best of the best from a wide geographic area at clubs with elite coaches, not just with their high school coach, and maybe a couple alumni and/or teammates if they’re lucky. This means kids are coming into college with a significant amount of mileage on them from both competition and practice, so that’s something that can’t be ignored, either.
Buddy carries up the CHA might make one mentally tough and confident in his conditioning and ability to outwork his opponent, but at what cost? Every minute spent on conditioning (particularly at the wrong time) is just extra wear and tear and time being spent on being better at exercising, not better at wrestling.