Jump to content

Lucho

Members
  • Posts

    391
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Lucho

  1. Yeah he had a really good tournament. He has won world medals at 3 different weight classes and people for some reason think he is robbing guys off the team. Emami is strange because he can be the best wrestler in the world at every tournament but worlds and olympics for some reason. I think his problem is a mental block of some sort. But I think Amir Mohammad Yazdani will be our rep going forward. But it will be between him and Sina Khalili imo.
  2. I think Spencer Lee has to be here he teched and pinned his way to worlds like Zare. I would honestly put Zare 1, Spencer Lee 2, Snyder 3, Dake 4, Bassett 5, Yoshida 6, Sadulaev 7, Amouzad 8, Sheriev 9 and Yazdani 10. Javan is hard for me to justify even though he convincingly beat Uguev as he looked very beatable the whole tournament and lost at Asians too. Sheriev was good but its hard to say as 74 was quite weak this year so I can't rank him too highly. Sadulaev also didn't wrestle anyone noteworthy apart from Snyder so I can't really rank him as high but I think him and Amouzad on their day are as good as the guys above them on this ranking. The problem of course is that Amouzad is way too inconsistent to be a top 5 guy p4p. Yazdani had a close match against Yoshida and beat Tazhudinov pretty convincingly so I think he should be here over despite not winning worlds purely off the fact 97 was probably the hardest worlds bracket of all time.
  3. Iran sent I think their U20/U23 greco team to Russia for the Akyonov Memorial. Ilya Alikhani won at 72, Mohammadi Mohmedi got bronze at 72 and Amir Mahdi Saedi Nava got silver at 82. Other interesting results were Dinislam Bammatov and Musa Evloev losing their finals matches at 67 and 97 respectively. Looks like a pretty high level tournament with many of Russia's top guys competing. From what I gather this might be a selection tournament for the European championships.
  4. How do RAF contracts work is it for a set amount of matches? If so then he can run that contract down and then compete wherever he wants to. But I doubt he will compete in these leagues next year as its so close to the Olympics.
  5. I'm interested to see how team selection is going to work next year as they made big changes to the ranking series allocation points. They might make it mandatory for everyone to compete at Takhti and/or Iran nationals for olympic weights and then do their normal selection for the non-olympic ones. Since best performing wrestlers at ranking series get olympic quotas it doesn't make sense to send a guy who isn't going to be representing Iran at worlds/olympics. What might happen is world medalists sit out and instead the contenders have to win Iran nationals/takhti to then compete against the returning medalist. The winner then gets sent to Asians/ranking series to get ranking points so they can qualify the weight before worlds. Realistically we aren't sending anyone to the US tournament so we only have 2 ranking series we can take advantage of. I'm pretty sure that works as Iran nationals is early in the year and then Takhti is a couple months after that from memory. All these before Asians but maybe too late for the first ranking series.
  6. I'm pretty sure Mohammad Reza Geraei wrestled at 77kg against Askerov. He has moved up by the sounds of things. Mohammad Ali Geraei has wrestled Makhmudov before and beaten him at Asian Games I'm pretty sure but that was when he was much younger. Yousefi is unlucky that he was born in an era where Mirzazadeh and Hedayati compete for Iran. If he wrestled for any other country he would be competing at worlds and olympics. I think Yousefi was Iran's first ever greco super heavyweight world champ. I don't think anyone else had won previously. 5 years later from Yousefi's win, we have had 2 other super heavyweight world champs. The depth is actually wild.
  7. Mohammad Reza Geraei's older brother, Mohammad Ali Geraei also beat Berdimuratov 1-0 off a step out point. Considering their inactivity these are very impressive results. Askerov was a guy the Russians fans wanted to compete at Senior Worlds over Goraiev. Mohammad Reza Geraei wrestles Akzhol Makhmudov next for the PWL belt which is a match I've always wanted to see. Hopefully more of our guys get opportunities to wrestle here especially those who may not have a chance of making the national team anymore. Apparently Ali Akbar Yousefi is competing in the Bundesliga for next season and Snyder is interested to come and wrestle in Iran's league. Snyder coming to Iran would be absolutely insane.
  8. It would probably 7-3 USA right now. USA is very very strong right now. Azimi already has wrestled Hidlay and lost at a ranking series tournament a while ago. Although he lost on criteria so it was a pretty close match. Even at 61 I don't know if Javan beats Blaze again if they wrestle.
  9. He hasn't been wrestling that consistently though. He has been doing BJJ stuff in Dubai I think. But yeah I agree in his prime he was really good and deserved more than he got in wrestling.
  10. I think women's wrestling will keep wrestling in the olympics funnily enough. Women's wrestling has a lot of grass roots investment nowadays with countries from non powerhouse countries investing in the sport. You are seeing western european countries contending for medals and even traditional powerhouses like Turkey, India and US building their women's programs. It's a shame Iran doesn't send a women's team as that would make the competition even better. The big thing the IOC wants is diversity in participation and women's wrestling has that. Compare that to men's freestyle and it's not really a point of comparison.
  11. In other news, Mohammad Ali Geraei is competing in PWL against Berdimuratov who is a pretty experienced guy at international level. Would be cool to see him wrestle again. I wonder where he sits now against the rest of the field internationally. It's kinda wild that I don't even think he might not even be top 3 in Iran at 82 anymore. Apart from Farokhi, Abolfazl Mohmedi is very good. Azarshab and Mokhtari were decent as well. I think Ahoura Bouveiri has moved up to 82 as that's where he has been wrestling in the league. He might not see any chance of beating Abdevali and Oskou for the spot.
  12. People can't expect our freestyle results to be like our greco its completely unrealistic. In freestyle there are far more competitive countries who can win medals compared to greco across the 10 weights. Even the US until fairly recently struggled to field very competitive teams. A lot of iranians are overly critical of Dorostkar and Dabir because of non-sporting reasons but make every excuse possible for guys like Khadem when he didn't deliver. The only time Iran has dominated worlds was I think during the 50s other than that it has never been the case.
  13. You can look back at my previous comments where I have said Khadem wasn't a good coach this isn't a new thing I am saying. But the discussion would be between him and Dorostkar for the coaching position. I value olympic golds over world titles and so would most people. But I do agree with what you have said about Dorostkar overall with regards to worlds results. So overall Dorostkar is better than Khadem and should take the coaching spot.
  14. I've already mentioned Khadem wasn't a good coach. What I'm saying is that success in the Olympics is what matters the most in international wrestling. Dorostkar has shown that he is a good coach and has provided good results but it also helps when the federation has provided a lot of support for its athletes and coaches which wasn't the case under previous coaches. Again we will see how he performs in LA where there will be far more eyes on the sport. If he can out perform Russia, US and Japan in the olympics he is the greatest Iranian coach of all time no question at all. But if he can't get at least one Olympic gold out of Zare, Amouzad, Yazdani and Ghasempour than his quality of coaching should be under question. Iran struggles in the olympics not worlds. Look at the medal count for olympics compared to our worlds and its abysmal. He didn't coach in Paris so I can only judge him after LA.
  15. He has looked a lot better at 65 than 61 imo. His gas tank was worse at 61 when I watched him wrestle. Although it would be better team wise for him to go to 61 I don't want another Ghasempour situation to occur.
  16. You could also put that down to overall support by the federation. The facilities and money in Iranian wrestling now isn't even comparable to 5-6 years ago. But you can't say an Olympic medal isn't more valuable than a world one. Do you think Zare wants another world gold or an Olympic one? What about Yazdani?
  17. Khateri I think will stay at 65 especially after winning u23 worlds. I doubt he will come down. I can see Javan staying at 61 but I think Khateri has out grown 61. Even at 65 he seems quite lanky.
  18. 74 will also be interesting next year with Emami, Yazdani and Khalili competing for the spot. I think Elahi more less cements his spot at 70 then. If Javan moves up to 65 who takes his spot? I don't know of any good 61s apart from him.
  19. I don't think Rahmani goes down to 86. He will probably be our 92 rep next year though. If Bassett can win worlds at 20 I think Ferasati can also. Ferasati, Afshar and Shamsipour are very very talented guys and I think will only get better in the next 2 years. I'm not sure if Nokhodi wants to move up to 86 permanently. He seems pretty content being a top 2/3 wrestler in the world at 79. As much as Ghasempour wants an olympic medal his best chance was taking 2-3 years bulking up to 97 instead of going up and down in weight. If Yazdani can do it there was no reason Ghasempour couldn't if Ghasempour is as good as everyone says he is in Iran.
  20. I can agree with Rangraz but not with Dorostkar. He hasn't been able to win an olympic gold medal yet. LA and worlds next year is really going to be the litmus test for him. For the record I don't think Khadem was a good coach and his teams were weak. But he helped Yazdani win gold in Rio against Geduev. Our results in olympics are far worse than at worlds which I find quite strange. Comparatively to Russia and USA we severly underperform at the olympics. I hope that starts to change soon.
  21. I think they are similar in the sense their careers never ended up how we all thought they would. Reza Yazdani deserved to be an Olympic champion and it was injuries that prevented him from that success. I also agree with Ghasempour not making LA 2028, I think we will see someone else take his spot. My dark horse pick would be Ferasati. Although there are good 86s coming out of Iran right now Afshar and Shamsipour are decent. Even Nokhodi has shown he is a good 86 kg wrestler.
  22. I think that is a good compromise imo. Also fair enough on Movahed. Although I think at the end of Zare's career he will be above Movahed in overall honours. I think we could also make a discussion on who would be our all time coach in each style. Mohammad Bana should be the greco head coach imo although Hassan Rangraz has been phenomenal until he wins 3 golds at the Olympics Bana takes that spot. Who would be the freestyle head coach? Barzegar, Khadem and Dorostkar from the modern era would be the picks. I'm not too sure on the older eras. But it would have to be between Barzegar and Khadem.
  23. I agree with your Movahed take but in terms of overall medals and success its not really close tbh. Zare has been dominating since he was 19 and has multiple wins over all time heavy weights (Makhov, Geno, Akgul) as well as winning every worlds match this year by tech. Who else in super heavy weight has done that? Currently there are only 3 guys who have won the same amount of world titles in super heavy weight as him and they were all from the Soviet Era (Medved, Khashimikov and Andiyev) . It's not as easy to do what he is doing as people think. Zare's overall longevity if he wins 2027 worlds and 2028 LA puts him above Movahed. For greco I agree with your list but I would say that the Geraei's brought a lot of eyes to greco in Iran. Hedayati is amazing and will dominate for the next decade but it will require more than an LA gold to take that spot over Geraei imo. Our greco list tho is weaker than our freestyle imo. However I think that's more to do with our greco program developing all timers in the current era compared to freestyle which has historically been our strongest style. Out of the current crop of wrestlers in freestyle only Zare, Amouzad and Javan have shots of becoming all time greats for us. It's honestly a shame how Ghasempour's career has gone. He has become this era's Reza Yazdani.
  24. Yeah I agree with the list. Honourable mentions would be Emam-Ali Habibi and Rasoul Khadem but I don't know who they would go over. You can't remove any of the current guys on the list. If Zare wins 2027 worlds and LA olympics he is Iran's greatest FS wrestler of all time and arguably the greatest super heavy weight of all time behind Medved. I think we probably need a separate one regardless for GR and FS since they are very different styles and there are a lot of deserving wrestlers who should be on it.
  25. One thing I have been thinking of is potentially Iran looking into the US RTC model. Whilst its great we have a national training centre I also think it would be good to have one for each of the major wrestling provinces too. Imagine a similar one built in Mazandaran and Khuzestan not just in Tehran. I think it would help develop a lot more talent as there would be less need for travel. The national team guys should train in Tehran whilst the top guys in each province can train in their provincial training centres. Of course they don't have to be as big or extensive as the main one. A big reason as to why the US has jumped a lot in levels the past couple of years has been because of this. At the grass roots level the US and Russia are far ahead in terms of facilities and infrastructure compared to us. We have only recently been able to narrow the gap at senior level.
×
×
  • Create New...