I respectfully see it differently!
Looking at all three of their 2024-2025 seasons (not considering past achievements); I found that it could be argued that Hendrickson is easily the most deserving choice
1) He was mathematically proven to be the most dominant wrestler in the nation
2) His wins over Steveson, Kerkvliet, Trumble (3x; twice by fall), and Schultz (2x) are as, if not impressive than anyone that MM beat this year (including Caliendo)...
3) He just beat a 24-year-old Olympic Gold medalist; Starocci barely beat two college freshmen!
-The 5x Champ thing is cool; but meaningless since he was the only way capable of doing it! If Smith, Sanderson, Dake, Stieber, Diakomihalis, or Brooks were given five chances; they too would be 5x champs!
-Look at the coverage the sport is receiving right now....Because of the shock value, Hendrickson's win last night brought more attention from traditionally non-sport genre outlets than any of Starocci's five titles did!