The 2023-24 B1G Scouting Report (Part Two)

Finally! We’ve made it to Part 2 of the B1G Scouting Report! I trust you’ve been counting the minutes until this dropped, and probably re-read Part 1 a couple of times by now. Regardless of what coping skills you practiced, you’ve made it. The wait is over. In this installment, I will be covering the remaining 21 wrestlers from the B1G who were either All-Americans last season, or wrestled in the Bloodround. If you somehow missed the first part, you can check that out here. If you did read part 1, feel free to skip to the wrestlers, or refresh your memory on the categories and scoring below.

Just as before, let’s keep in mind that this is supposed to be a fun exercise. It’s largely subjective. It’s me making up categories and then assigning points to these wrestlers based on my own thoughts and feelings. I’ll try to justify the scores to some extent in each breakdown of the wrestler, but this is for fun, and in no way shape or form do I have any lack of respect for any of these wrestlers, so please take this as simply a fun exercise. As I did in the first part, I’ll shout out Shea Serrano whose Action Hero Scouting Report was the whole reason I thought to do this exercise. Just like Shea did, I am assigning points to each of my categories based on how heavily or lightly they should be weighed (again, subjectively how I feel they should be weighed). The total points would be 100 (an impossible score to achieve), which will be broken up into six main categories. Reminder, weight classes don’t really matter. So hypothetically someone from a much lower weight who placed 8th could score higher than someone who placed second at a much higher weight. Another refresher, the categories are:

• Offensive Diversity - Since this is my list, I’m going to focus less on effective offense, and more on a diversity of attacks. You always hear about your “go-to” takedown, and that’s valuable, but I like when wrestlers can attack both sides of the body and score in a variety of ways. I also like when they can initiate their own offense and not simply counter-wrestle. I’m going to reward primarily counter wrestlers in a later category, so it’ll likely balance itself out, but for the sake of this category, a large toolbox of attacks will go a long way. Total points available here - 20
• Showmanship - I turned 38 in September, which might sound old to some of you. Maybe it sounds young to others. Regardless, I feel like I’m far from being “Old Man Claunch'', so I like to see some charisma in my wrestlers. Work the crowd in home duals. Tell the away crowds to quiet down when you get a big win. Do some of the fun stuff that you only have so many opportunities in life to do. Spike your headgear! Admittedly, this doesn’t have as big a real effect on the wrestling, but it’s still fun. Total points available here - 5
• Defensive/Scrambling versatility - Counter wrestlers are rewarded here. Along with those roly-poly dudes who just seem to be able to weasel their way out of those situations where they look dead to rights, and then somehow get a 3-point takedown from it (I know, it’s the first time I’ve written it and it seems weird). Being able to scramble is one thing, counter wrestling a second thing, but the wrestlers that hand fight like prime Tyson will also get rewarded here. If they can’t get past your head and hands, then they can’t score, so that’s rewarded here as well. Total points available here - 20
• Wishnificance - This is directly pulled from Shea. He made up this word. He’s great. He describes it as “You know how sometimes when you’re watching a movie a thing happens inside of your chest where all of a sudden you kind of want to be someone from that movie? That’s what this is”. So essentially, when you’re watching someone wrestle, and you think “I should try that”, or you have to rewind a sequence to see what that person did, or you actually try to change your stance or approach based on what they are doing. That’s what this category is. How much does their style make you (or in this case, pretty much me), make you want to wrestle like them? Total points available here - 20
• Upset alert - I heard an analogy about quarterbacks the other day. It was essentially, are you more worried about that quarterback if he is on your team, or playing against you. That’s kind of what this is. If your favorite team is wrestling this guy, and your wrestler on your team should win, how nervous does this guy make you? Some guys just have a way of getting up for big matches and pulling something off. Some guys you already know will absolutely not beat your guy. That doesn’t mean they’re bad wrestlers. Remember we’re scouting top 12 finishers, but some guys make you more nervous is all. That’s what this score is. Total points available here - 15
• Top Game - You should be able to get out from the bottom. That’s not a category because these are adults who are trained to take chances and attack because getting out shouldn’t be that bad, and you can go try again. However, some guys on top are nightmares. It’s like in The Dark Knight Rises when Bruce Wayne has to climb out of the pit, and he falls over and over and it looks like the most awful soul-crushing thing. That’s what it must be like being underneath some of these dudes. For that matter, some of us might rather climb out of that pit than be underneath Patrick McKee. Total points available here - 20

Okay, that’s how this is set up and the scoring is clear. With each athlete, I’ll provide the score, and a brief breakdown of how I see them, including some justifying points. When possible, I’ll try to add some good stories or anecdotes, concluding the breakdown. This is going to be a marathon, but I am confident that you’ll have fun. Which sounds like not what happens in a marathon. Regardless, let’s begin.

Dean Peterson picture courtesy of Tony Rotundo;WrestlersAreWarriors.com; all others from Sam Janicki; SJanickiPhoto.com

Dean Peterson - Rutgers, 125, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 16, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 17, Wishnificance - 18, Upset Alert - 15, Top Game - 15 Total Score - 84

Breakdown: This dude just keeps on keeping on. I was admittedly not as dialed in on Rutgers much of last season. I was focusing on the teams that I was responsible for covering, and as such I caught some Rutgers matches along the way. What I kept noticing was that Dean Peterson kept avenging losses as the season continued. He lost by major decision in the dual to Braxton Brown of Maryland, then went ahead and beat him in both the B1Gs and NCAAs. He lost to Jack Medley of Michigan in the first round of B1Gs, then beat him in the same tournament to take 7th. Then he knocks off Patrick McKee of Minnesota (multiple-time AA at this point), to get into the Bloodround and have his shot at the podium. He lost that match to Noto of Lock Haven, but all Mean Dean Peterson seems to do is get better and build off of his losses. I respect the hell out of that, and as a result, I have his Wishnificance fairly high. His upset alert is as high as it gets, because I don’t have any reason to think he won’t compete with these top guys at this point. Won’t be much longer until he is the guy fending off upsets.

Lucas Byrd - Illinois, 133, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 18, Wishnificance - 18, Upset Alert - 11 Top Game - 17 Total Score - 86

Breakdown: Lucas Byrd has been a fan favorite since I can remember. He’s gritty, scrappy, he’s got those big glasses, he’s as consistent and dangerous as they come. His season ended very similarly to the way it started. With a close loss to Jesse Mendez of Ohio State. Mendez is super tough, but Byrd cruised to the quarterfinals before dropping a one-point loss to Daton Fix. Losing two close matches at NCAAs to two dudes who won silver medals at the world championships is respectable (Fix won world silver at the Senior level in 2021, and Mendez just recently at U20s took a world silver a couple of weeks back). Byrd should come back for his final season as one of the top-ranked guys at 133, and should be considered a legit title threat. Anything can happen, and he’s proven to be in that mix with the best in the world.

Brock Hardy - Nebraska, 141, 7th

Offensive Diversity - 19, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 18, Wishnificance - 14, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 18. Total Score - 85

Breakdown: Talk about a breakout season! I remember hearing rumors before last season starting about Ridge Lovett possibly dropping down to 141 for the year, but ultimately choosing to redshirt. I figured either way he gets away from Yianni, but redshirting is cool also. Turns out the Cornhuskers were just fine at 141 without him. It was clear that Hardy was a national title contender before the New Year. He began the season by winning the Navy Classic and Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational and then had a string of awesome wins through the B1G schedule. His main losses all year came to top opponents up until he got hurt in the semis at NCAAs. He was an All-American, but that weirdly pales in comparison to what he proved he was capable of. You’ve gotta believe that he’s going to come back with a chip on his shoulder this season, and ready to prove that he is a title contender from day one. 

Dylan D’Emilio - Ohio State, 141, 8th

Offensive Diversity - 16, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 17, Wishnificance - 15, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 14. Total Score - 79

Breakdown: It’s wild to look back at some of these brackets for this. The first round of the B1G Tournament this past season was D’Emilio against Parker Filius of Purdue. Filius got the win there, as well as in the match for 7th and 8th place at the NCAA Tournament. The B1G is great. Anyway, D’Emilio is actually a favorite of mine. I gave him the top Wishnificance score as a result. He’s just a gnarly dude to watch wrestle. I love the hard hand fighting he displays, and then he’ll explode through a takedown just as his opponent gets a breath from the pace D’Emilio establishes early and often. He is also very consistent. He consistently beats who he should, and also consistently loses to the guys who are just a step above. He’s always gotten better though, year after year, and I trust this season as he jumps up to 149, he’ll continue that ascension and I’m excited to see what he’ll be able to do at the upper weight.

Sammy Sasso - Ohio State, 149, 2nd

Offensive Diversity - 19, Showmanship - 5, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 18, Wishnificance - 18, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 19. Total Score - 92

Breakdown: I’m fully aware of the unfortunate incident that occurred that is causing Sammy Sasso to miss this season, and leave his wrestling future more of a question than a certainty. All that aside, Sammy Sasso has done too much for me to move past what he’s done and leave him out of this report. This guy has been a monster since the moment he showed up in Columbus and I’m giving him the scouting report that he has earned. Wrestlers demand respect across rivalry lines, unless you’re a psycho. I’m not a psycho, so I respect anyone who earns it on the mat. Sasso has been in two NCAA finals in three attempts (he made four NCAA tournaments, and was the 3 seed in 2020, but it was canceled due to COVID). He cradles people from top, on his feet, and probably on bottom (I’ve never seen him do this, but if anyone could, it’s probably him). He owns the crowd for home duals, has always been a leader, and is capable of beating anyone in the country at any point. I’ll genuinely miss watching him this season. He was supposed to bump to 157, where many of the Ohio State fans I know felt he should be anyway, so it sucks we won’t get to see that happen. Nothing but positive vibes and hoping for a full recovery for one of my favorite Buckeye athletes that I’ve ever seen compete.

Graham Rooks - Indiana, 149, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 13, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 15, Wishnificance - 11, Upset Alert - 15, Top Game - 15. Total Score - 72

Breakdown: This score isn’t really where I think Graham Rooks is, but I’ve watched him a long time, so there’s probably some prejudice baked into this score from previous seasons. Not his fault, this is my fault. Graham Rooks has been a staple in the Hoosier lineup for the last several years. I feel like we are beginning to see the Escobedo effect with some of the progression of their athletes since he took over the head coaching position a couple of years back. Rooks really broke out last season with a 10-3 dual record, and a run to the quarterfinals of the NCAA tournament last year. That run included upsets in the opening round over Kellyn March of North Dakota State University, and of the number 4 seed Caleb Henson of Virginia Tech. Rooks is entering his final season at Indiana, along with his twin brother (141) Cayden, I’m sure are looking to leave their mark in the Hoosier record books, and I’m excited to watch the crafty veteran chase that dream. He’ll begin this season ranked 7th at 149 by Intermat, your go-to resource for trustworthy and accurate rankings. 

Levi Haines - PSU, 157, 2nd

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 18, Wishnificance - 20, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 18 Total Score - 90

Breakdown: Levi Haines is a beast of a teenager. Let’s remember that he’s a teenager. His age is in the teens. He is not currently ranked in the teens by Intermat. He’s ranked #1, which seems reasonable for the returning NCAA finalist and B1G Champion. Remember when Cael almost didn’t pull the redshirt from him last year? Must be nice. Remember when Levi won the Edinboro Open and Franklin & Marshall Open in what would have been his Senior year of High School? Must be nice. Either way, PSU now gets to return one of the deepest lineups we’ve had in recent history, even for Penn State. Levi Haines is good in every position and looks enormous for 157. Similarly to Will Lewan, the Wishnificance is so high because I would like to feel like what it must feel like to be in complete control against anyone. Once again, must be nice. 

Jared Franek - Iowa (NDSU), 157, 4th

Offensive DIversity - 16, Showmanship - 2, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 19, Wishnificance - 14, Upset Alert - 12, Top Game - 15. Total Score - 78

Breakdown: Admittedly this score is lower than I would’ve thought for a guy who placed 4th in the country in a super deep weight and is transferring to a theoretically deeper room where he should make some improvements. That being said, this score is more of an indication that you can be elite at one thing and ride that a long way. Not that I’m saying Jared Franek is not good. He’s outstanding. More specifically though, he’s a bruiser. He is as physical as it gets and it looks absolutely miserable to wrestle him. He controls almost every tie-up, and is so wildly physical. He can do just about anything, but he dictates the match, pace, and positioning to where he can keep the match in the exact format that he wants. Franek being taught how to maximize this style by Brands and should be a scary prospect for anyone going up against the Hawkeyes. Get ready to catch these hands. Also, he’s not super animated, so not much in the showmanship category, but wrestling in Carver-Hawkeye seems to bring that out of even the most reserved wrestlers, so that’s subject to change.

Peyton Robb - Nebraska, 157, 6th

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 16, Wishnificance - 16, Upset Alert - 15, Top Game - 16. Total Score - 84

Breakdown: First of all, I’m super happy that Peyton has recovered from the skin condition from NCAAs and appears ready to compete this season. If Instagram is telling me the truth, which I generally assume it is, then he appears to be training with Coach James Green. Training with James Green seems like a great way to get better. Peyton held the number 1 ranking for most of last season, and ultimately if you held last year's NCAA tournament 10 times, I feel like sixth would be the worst he would place. He’s super capable of winning it all this year. As a result, nobody watching their 157 pounder wrestle Robb should feel comfortable. The Cornhusker has been fun to watch over the years, as he continues to make huge progress each year he’s been in the lineup. I’m not sure how this season will end up for Robb, because weirdly I feel like 157 is deeper than it was last year, but he’ll be on the podium barring health concerns. I hope it’s at the top. Seems like how it should end for him.

Dean Hamiti - Wisconsin, 165, 5th

Offensive Diversity - 19, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 17, Wishnificance - 17, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 17. Total Score - 87

Breakdown: Do you like ankle picks and cradles and 7 minutes of offense and scrambles? Then you’ll like Dean Hamiti. Of course, you already know this, because if you’re reading this beast of an article, then chances are that you’ve watched him. I can’t think of a wrestler who wrestles most like their mascot other than Hamiti. The Badger has been an All-American in every chance he’s had, which is saying a lot considering how deep 165 has been the last several years. I had the privilege to speak with Dean a couple of weeks back about being a leader and how he can take the next step as an individual and around where he can have an impact on his team. One common denominator was around doing the right things on and off of the mat. To make these incremental jumps from All-American to NCAA Champion, you need to put in the time in every aspect of your life. I trust he is doing what he needs to on that end, and I’m excited to see what this season has in store for Mr. Hamiti.

Michael Caliendo - Iowa (formerly NDSU), 165, 6th

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 16, Wishnificance - 16, Upset Alert - 14, Top Game - 16. Total Score - 83

Breakdown: NDSU had a great season in 2022-2023, and should be very happy about what they accomplished. They have excellent coaches remaining and have assembled a great staff and will continue the momentum that they built up over the years. One of the interesting things about this world though is that success can lead to movement. This is not a judgment, coaches and athletes have moved from several programs around after success, and Michael gets to be one of them. He and Franek (Jared, mentioned earlier) have transferred to the Hawkeyes to continue their careers. Caliendo is a relentless attacking wrestler, and has proven that he can make adjustments quickly. After losing to Shane Griffith in the Southern Scuffle finals last year, he had a rematch with him ten days later and got the upset win. In fact, Caliendo only had one dual loss all year, and it was to Keegan O’Toole, who most people lost to in duals. Caliendo will be a great addition to the B1G and the Hawkeye lineup for the foreseeable future. Caliendo is only a Sophomore, whereas Franek is more of a one-season rental. His development will be fun to watch.

Caleb Fish - Michigan State, 165, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 16, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 15, Wishnificance - 14, Upset Alert - 15, Top Game - 15. Total Score - 79

Breakdown: Nobody should feel at all confident matching up with this Spartan. Fish is athletic and strong and capable of beating some of the best in the country. After a tough B1G tournament, Caleb needed an at-large bid to make the NCAA tournament. There are a couple of dudes who wish that his bid had gone to someone else. Namely Julian Ramirez of Cornell and Holden Heller of Pittsburgh, who he beat on the way to the Quarterfinals. Fish dropped that match to Quincy Monday, as well as his Bloodround match to Michael Caliendo (pretty sure it’s not Frank’s brother), but still an excellent tournament. 165 is a weird weight this year. Quincy Monday graduated, Griffith and Kharchla are bumping up a weight, but mostly everyone else returns. Still, Caleb Fish holds great position and if he’s slept on, he’ll be a nightmare.

Shane Griffith - Michigan (formerly Stanford), 165, 5th

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 20, Wishnificance - 20, Upset Alert - 15, Top Game - 18. Total Score - 94

Breakdown: Makes sense that an NCAA Champion would score so well. Even so, I was surprised at some of the scores I instinctively had for him. Of course, Wishnigicance is so high. He has a degree and NCAA title from Stanford, saved their program (yes, he was the lynchpin in saving that program), and now he gets to cut less weight and wrestle for (and obtain a degree from) the University of Michigan. That’s something that anyone in their right mind would want to do. Upset Alert has to be maxed out as well. He’s beaten everyone in the country before, and I have to think that getting into this room, and potentially being a little healthier than he’s been the last couple of years, would be an improvement. Pair that with the fact that he can be the guy doing the upsetting rather than always being the targeted guy to be upset, then you get a high score. But thinking through some of his offensive attacks, how he shuts his opponents down, and can get creative when he needs to, he just kept scoring well in every category. Is there going to be a more fun match than Griffith vs. Starocci to look forward to this season? Maybe, but this will be the one I’m looking forward to the most.

Carson Kharchla, Ohio State, 165, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 17, Showmanship - 2, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 16, Wishnificance - 15, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 16. Total Score - 79

Breakdown: From the moment Kharchla (the K is silent) burst into the lineup, he’s been a monster. The barrel-chested blonde bruiser was not screwing around when he beat Alex Marinelli in his freshman season, and was undefeated in duals that season as well, while finishing seventh. Last season he just didn’t seem to have the same edge. I know he was dealing with some injury concerns, and he’s moving up weights this season to 174, so I can only assume the weight cut might have been an issue, but it wasn’t the same. What you get with Kharchla though, is fundamental and physical wrestling. He’s not afraid to stick his face into the fight. Win or lose, his opponents don’t want to do whatever that was anytime soon. Carson has a big frame, so I trust he’ll be able to perform better last season at the higher weight. 174 is wildly deep in the B1G, and across the country, but regardless he’s the kind of wrestler that could largely benefit from coming up a weight class. Similar to when Ethan Smith of the Buckeyes moved to 174 a couple of years ago. 

Edmond Ruth - Illinois, 174, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 15, Showmanship - 2, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 20, Wishnificance - 14, Upset Alert - 12, Top Game - 18. Total Score - 81

Breakdown: Edmond is as skilled as it gets defensively. He’s more than capable offensively, and I’ve seen him go upper body, and work towards your more traditional shots, but he is so confident in his ability to do all of the tough stuff. The tough stuff includes accumulating riding time, mat returns, and all of the defensive nuances that he so eloquently deploys. If my life depended on taking Edmond Ruth down, I’d begin getting my affairs in order. Anyway, Ruth didn’t make the podium last year, and sometimes when you wrestle so conservatively you can lose some of those close matches that you’re so used to winning, but I think that if Edmond can put together some more confident attacks, and pair that with his defense, he will be close to being as special as his brother was.

Aaron Brooks - PSU, 184, 1st

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 19, Wishnificance - 17, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 19. Total Score - 90

Breakdown: It’s wild to look back now at some of the NCAA Finals matches that Brooks has wrestled. He’s so far beaten Trent Hidlay (multiple-time ACC Champion and All-American, and general badass. Great hair also.), Myles Amine (Olympic Bronze medalist, World Bronze medalist, multiple-time world team member and 5x All-American), and most recently Parker Keckeisen (3x B1G Champion, placed 3rd, 3rd, and 2nd at NCAAs, and currently ranked #1 at 184, not so great hair). That is one hell of a resume. Add in that Brooks had to beat Hidlay in the semifinals two other times just to make the finals. This gets lost in the weeds sometimes, but not by me. Not today folks. Aaron Brooks has managed to lose a match here and there during his career, but not when it matters most. I always appreciated his style and approach, but last season I was on the floor during the B1G finals between Brooks and Kaleb Romero, and let me tell you, the physicality doesn’t come through the TV the same way it does in real life. He looked like he was trying to break bricks over Romero’s head with the hand fighting, he just forgot to hold the bricks. It was nuts. Upset alert is low because he doesn’t often have the chance to upset anyone, even after bumping up a weight class to 197 this season. Other than that, he’s got high marks across the board.

Silas Allred - Nebraska, 197, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 17, Showmanship - 5, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 16, Wishnificance - 18, Upset Alert - 15, Top Game - 15. Total Score - 85

Breakdown: Silas was such a fun story last year wasn’t he? Jumps into the lineup after the excellent career and eligibility of Eric Schultz came to an end, and he hit the ground running. A theme of many of the Cornhuskers last season getting their first chance to compete in the lineup, was that they showed up ready to wrestle. If winning a B1G title is evidence enough of that, then please let me draw your attention to exhibit B (the B stands for B1G championship at 197 pounds by beating the defending NCAA champion, Max Dean). Allred and his mustache return for their Sophomore season and do so being ranked 7th in the preseason by Intermat. He certainly has the upside to outperform this, but he’ll have his work cut out for him to repeat this season as B1G Champion. Although I’m sure if you’re Silas, that’s the sort of doubt and bulletin board material that you’re looking for to keep grinding. 

Zac Braunagel - Illinois, 197, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 15, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 18, Wishnificance - 18, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 16. Total Score - 84

Breakdown: From the moment the Braunagel’s arrived at Illinois, they’ve been a low-key favorite of mine. You’ll notice from my breakdowns on wrestlers with similar styles (physical, mean, punishing, painful, etc…) I like this style. Zac bumped up to 197 last season from 184, and that seemed like the right move for him. He was able to use his strength as more of an asset and his athleticism was still excellent for that weight. He had his best season to date and was 1 point away from the semifinals, and two points away from the podium. 197 this season is missing the last two NCAA Champions (Max Dean 2022, Nino Bonaccorsi 2023) and yet seems to be just as deep, if not more so. Everyone on the podium this season is going to have to earn their spots, but Zac is certainly one of those guys that nobody is excited to face as they put their toe on the line.

Greg Kerkvliet - PSU, HWY, 2nd

Offensive Diversity - 18, Showmanship - 3, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 19, Wishnificance - 17, Upset Alert - 12, Top Game - 17. Total Score - 86

Breakdown: Greg Kerkvliet has been an NCAA Title contender essentially since slowly walking into the D1 wrestling scene. Even before then, he was beating Jordan Wood for World Team spots. He’s been the biggest and the baddest for as long as most of us can remember, except that he hasn’t actually won a title yet. That’s okay though, we’re still living in this golden age of NCAA Heavyweights, so there are a couple of generational talents who have fewer championships (or in some cases, none), then you’d guess. I expect him to get it done this year, and his preseason ranking says as much. Strong scores in just about all categories except upset alert, where it’s low just because I don’t know which situation he’ll be in where he’s going to be upsetting anyone. The remaining field of heavyweights is different from previous seasons in that nobody returns who has had a win over him previously. He’s decidedly the favorite and I’m sure intends to bring it all home this season.

Lucas Davison - Michigan (Northwestern), HWY, 5th

Offensive Diversity - 17, Showmanship - 4, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 17, Wishnificance - 20, Upset Alert - 13, Top Game - 16. Total Score - 87

Breakdown: I thought about moving this one from being right after Kerkvliet, but hear me out. Yes, in this subjective (reference the intro) nature of this scoring system, I can come up with a total score where Davison has more points than Kerkvliet, despite him having not beaten Kerkvliet yet. Here’s how! 

Where Davison scores more points is Wishnificance, to begin with. Both Greg and Lucas are taller and stronger than I am, which is awesome, but Lucas has a degree from Northwestern (technically he has two degrees from Northwestern, nbd) and Michigan soon to have one from Michigan as well. Now I couldn’t have gotten into Penn State either, but it’s not like Greg has a bad Wishnificance score. It’s just not two prestigious institutions, so there are the extra three points in my subjective point of view. Upset alert is simply higher because he’ll have more chances to get upset wins, being ranked lower than 1 and all. Not to say that Lucas Davison isn’t a tremendous wrestler in his own right. Despite battling through injuries at the end of last season, and through NCAAs, he managed to place 5th in the country, earning his second All-American status (he has an NWCA honorable mention AA status from 2020 as well at 197). He’s got great attacks, and a mean ankle pick, excellent athletic scrambles, and should put together a solid season for the Wolverines. That upset alert is high though, he could get it done if he puts it all together. Also, training with Adam Coon and Mason Parris is probably not making him any worse.

Yaraslau Slavikouski - Rutgers (Harvard), HWY, Bloodround

Offensive Diversity - 16, Showmanship - 2, Defensive/Scrambling Versatility - 18, Wishnificance - 19, Upset Alert - 14, Top Game - 15. Total Score - 84

Breakdown: I’ll be the first to admit that I was not super high on Slavikouski before last season. It’s my fault for not watching enough Harvard wrestling. There’s only so much time I have with covering the B1G, three kids, two jobs, podcasting, coaching, eating, sleeping, exercising, and breathing, and I wasn’t able to fit them in as much as I would have liked. I accept full responsibility for this, but it’s not my fault. Slavikouski was 30-8 at Harvard and the 10 seed when the NCAA tournament was canceled, then Ivy Leagues elected not to participate in the following season, then he was hurt the next season. I knew I wasn’t crazy! Despite my not having seen him compete as much as many of these others that I’ve been subjectively assigning points to, I won’t hesitate to do it here either. Jokes aside, I watched some of his matches from last season to catch up and have some credibility to this. He’s strong, athletic, smart, and clearly capable of beating some of the best in the country. His only losses at NCAAs last season were a 1-point loss to Trent Hilger (multiple time All American for Wisconsin), and a 2-point OT loss to Lucas Davison (referenced above). Plus, you’ve gotta love anyone ready to dive headfirst into the B1G wrestling schedule, specifically the Heavyweight schedule. The B1G had 11 Heavyweights represented at NCAAs last season, and they only lost Boone McDermott (transferred from Rutgers to Oregon State), Hillger and Mason Parris. Probably safe to assume the addition of Yaraslau and of Seth Nevills (Maryland transfer from PSU) will backfill two of those, and there’s probably more that we aren’t even considering yet as potential NCAA Qualifiers in the B1G. Get ready Yaraslau, the waters here are deep!