Returning DI All-Americans for the 2025-26 Season

Here are the wrestlers who have earned NCAA All-American honors, at some point in their careers, and are active in 2025-26. They are sorted by expected weight class for the upcoming season. There are a few teams with multiple AA’s at the same weight class. They have been included. 

The number in parentheses at the weight, is the number of AA’s in that respective class. 

Which weight classes will be the toughest? 

125 lbs (7)

Luke Lilledahl: Penn State (3)

Stevo Poulin: Iowa State (8)

Vince Robinson: NC State (1)

Sheldon Seymour: Lehigh (6)

Troy Spratley: Oklahoma State (2)

Eddie Ventresca: Virginia Tech (5,7)

Jore Volk: Minnesota (7)
 

133 lbs (10)

Drake Ayala: Iowa (2,2)

Lucas Byrd: Illinois (1,7,7)

Chris Cannon: Minnesota (7,7)

Ryan Crookham: Lehigh (3)

Richie Figueroa: Oklahoma State (1)

Evan Frost: Iowa State (6)

Zan Fugitt: Wisconsin (4)

Tyler Knox: Stanford (8)

Dylan Shawver: Rutgers (7)

Jacob Van Dee: Nebraska (7)
 

141 lbs (12)

Nasir Bailey: Iowa (4)

CJ Composto: Penn (4,8)

Braeden Davis: Penn State (5)

Anthony Echemendia: Iowa State (5)

Brock Hardy: Nebraska (2,3,6)

Ryan Jack: NC State (7)

Jesse Mendez: Ohio State (1,1,6)

Aaron Nagao: Penn State (5)

Dylan Ragusin: Michigan (5)

Zeth Romney: Cal Poly (3)

Luke Stanich: Lehigh (5)

Vance Vombaur: Minnesota (8,8)
 

149 lbs (5)

Jacob Frost: Iowa State (7)

Caleb Henson: Virginia Tech (2,1,5)

Lachlan McNeil: Michigan (5,6,4)

Ethan Stiles: Ohio State (6)

Shayne Van Ness: Penn State (3,3)
 

157 lbs (8)

Daniel Cardenas: Stanford (4)

Gavin Drexler: North Dakota State (8)

Tyler Kasak: Penn State (3,3)

Meyer Shapiro: Cornell (5,3)

Casey Swiderski: Oklahoma State (7)

Antrell Taylor: Nebraska (1,8)

Ty Watters: West Virginia (4)

Vinny Zerban: Iowa State (6)
 

165 lbs (6)

Joey Blaze: Purdue (2)

Matt Bianchi: Little Rock (7)

Michael Caliendo: Iowa (2,4,7)

Peyten Kellar: Oklahoma (5)

Hunter Garvin: Stanford (6,6)

Mitchell Mesenbrink: Penn State (1,2)
 

174 lbs (8)

Levi Haines: Penn State (3,1,2)

Patrick Kennedy: Iowa (4)

Carson Kharchla: Ohio State (7)

Christopher Minto: Nebraska (4)

Simon Ruiz: Cornell (5)

Matthew Singleton: NC State (7)

Cam Steed: Missouri (7)

Danny Wask: Navy (8)
 

184 lbs (4)

Silas Allred: Nebraska (7)

Max McEnelly: Minnesota (3)

Jaxon Smith: Maryland (6)

Rocco Welsh: Penn State (2)
 

197 lbs (7)

Josh Barr: Penn State (2)

Bennett Berge: South Dakota State (4)

Rocky Elam: Iowa State (6,3,4,5)

Stephen Little: Little Rock (6,7)

Camden McDanel: Nebraska (8)

Joey Novak: Wyoming (5)

Mac Stout: Pittsburgh (7)
 

285 lbs (6)

Yonger Bastida: Iowa State (5)

Nick Feldman: Ohio State (5)

AJ Ferrari: Nebraska (3,1)

Taye Ghadiali: Michigan (8)

Ben Kueter: Iowa (8)

Isaac Trumble: NC State (4)